How would you have handled this? I slipped during conversation tonight.

Status
Not open for further replies.

.cheese.

Member
Joined
Feb 13, 2007
Messages
3,808
I was out to dinner with my cousin and his girlfriend tonight as we usually do every other week or so. He's only a year older than me, but he's about to graduate law school whereas I am only just about to start. We started talking about lawschool stuff and I asked him if he had registered for the bar yet. He said he's filled out all the paperwork, but just today got his fingerprints done. I asked whether he used the electronic method or the standard card. He said that he used the electronic scanner, and then he said, "But it doesn't really matter because they're both the same. You get a printed piece of paper with the electronic method that you have to send in just the same."

Then I kind of slipped. I said, "Well, actually, they're not quite the same. The electronic method digitizes the prints and they get automatically sent to a central database that I believe is hosted by the FBI. While you send the card, they don't have to process and scan it like they would have to do with the standard card - therefore it usually speeds up the process, or at least ensures you have no delay from the processing of your prints."

Before I even realize how stupid it was of me to say that, he asks the inevitable question, "How do you know this? You haven't had to apply for the bar yet."

and without thinking I say, "Well, I haven't applied for the bar, but I have had to get my fingerprints scanned just like you."

at this point, I finally realize what I've just set myself up for and I'm thinking, "Why am I an idiot?"

The logical question comes - "For what?"

Here's where I just really didn't know what to say. I don't like telling people that I have a permit. Not even family. I say it online here because none of you know who I actually am, therefore it's relatively safe. Even if you do, chances are you have one too, so I'm not worried. However, there's just too much potential for a problem when friends or family know, as I've already found out from my own parents who can't keep their mouths shut.

So I say, "Oh well, it probably sounds much more interesting than it is. It was just for a license I needed."

He asks, "Oh you mean your ham radio license?"

I actually started to lie, "Um.... yeah... that's it." and then I felt bad about lying, "Actually, what was that, ham radio? Oh no, that's not it. It's just another license. Nothing important."

they start probing, "what for?"

and all I can think of as I try to squirm out of it is, "Oh... well it's a long story. It's nothing bad or interesting though." - truth was that it's a very short story, and I would imagine if I did tell them it would probably be of some interest or novelty.

They kept probing a bit and ultimately dropped the subject... but all in all I think I handled it very poorly. I just didn't know how to regain control once I had made that initial slip.

Obviously, I know not to make that same mistake, but I was wondering how (in general) you guys handle stuff like this.

I know it's not that big of a deal to just be honest about it, but I just don't feel comfortable. I have a family that is not used to the notion of guns and permits at all - in fact most are blatantly anti (and one is a journalist whom has been quoted here on more than one occasion with his anti articles - of course I won't name him). I have an aunt who stopped speaking to one of her nephews (not my side of the family) who is in the business of manufacturing sex toys. Just manufacturing and selling to distributors. He just contracts with factories in China to make them, and gets them to distributors, and that's his whole business. She also goes on rants about guns and why they should be banned. I've never debated the topic with her because I'm pretty sure she'd stop talking to me too just because that's how she obviously deals with anybody who does anything she disagrees with. I only mention all of this to better explain why I'm not open about the whole permit thing and pro-RKBA thing with family.

Also, how would you have answered the "For what?" question without mentioning the permit and at the same time not making it sound weird?
 
You look them straight in the eye and tell them it was for a type of military service and you really don't want to talk about it.

Since under Fed code the unorganized militia is a part of the military you would not be lying. Any guestions after that just reply you would rather not say, which would also be the truth if you don't mind streching one of the logically fallacies.

Selena
 
"Ohh... I had to renew my green card."

"What? You're a citizen. Come on. Really."

"Alright, alright. I got caught flying a stolen Cessna across the border with 200 keys of heroin and 2.5 million in cash on board."

"Oh stop it. Really. Why were you fingerprinted?"

"Oh ok then. I was picked up as a suspected Hawaiian terrorist and spent some time in Guantanamo. Wasn't a particularly pleasent experience to remember. Happy?!"

:D


-T.
 
wow. You guys are so much better at this than me.

Those are some good ideas.

stomach pains... hmm... I have a chronic stomach issue actually, that's a good one. I could definitely use that to get off of a subject.

I have a bad feeling my carrying is going to come up on T-day. My father told one of my other aunts (his sister) who just happens to be the gossip-queen of the family. I have a horrible feeling come T-day, everybody is going to know. I may use the "stomac pains" idea to get out of it should it come up. I could take a moment to be excused from the table and come back when they all have a new subject.

Thanks!
 
Must suck being a "closet CCW". We're no different than other people. We can come out now.

Sorry to be so harsh. It makes me sad when one of us feels he/she has to live with a secret.

I have some commie relatives out in San Diego. I can do without them.
 
You tell the truth somewhat proudly that you wish to defend yourself from evil inspite of the legal mess you had to submit too to apply for the right to self defence.
Any sane person would understand the need for the need of A small defensive firearm.
 
nothing wrong with being a closet CCW. Im not totally, but I prefer to keep it to myself as do my friends who shoot also.

You should have just told him it was for the last time you were in the joint....and thats where you got the idea to be a...:barf:... lawyer.
 
Be proud of it. No need to advertise it, but with family a simple answer would be best. Carrying concealed is nothing to be ashamed of. You made a choice to protect yourself and those around you. Here's how I'd of done it (after the fact from behind my keyboard. :) )

him,"How do you know this? You haven't had to apply for the bar yet."
you,"Well, I haven't applied for the bar, but I have had to get my fingerprints scanned just like you."
him,"For what?"
(what I'd of said)
"When I got my concealed handgun permit I had to get finger printed as well as pass a rigorous background check."
him,"what would you need that for"
you, "being a law student, I would have thought you'd understand that there are bad guys that I should be able to defend myself against" (or something like that)
 
Must suck being a "closet CCW". We're no different than other people. We can come out now.

It does suck!

All I'll say though is that I've learned at least with my family it causes problems.

The gun issue caused such a problem between my San Fran dwelling brother and myself however, that we don't talk anymore. So, I'm definitely afraid of causing more damage between myself and family members.

You should have just told him it was for the last time you were in the joint....and thats where you got the idea to be a...... lawyer.

I think when I finally am through with law school and am practicing, it will be easier as I may end up specializing in self-defense cases.
 
It's going to be a big deal because you made it a big deal. That can't be helped since you already added the stigma to it.

By not being direct you showed yourself to be dishonest toward him. I personally would have just told him instead of playing politician. You accept your relatives with what you perceive to be their flaws, if they can't do the same it means that they didn't care much for you anyway. Either way, they can't call you a liar.

So, I'm definitely afraid of causing more damage between myself and family members.
So what you're saying is that you have relatives that you think actually dislike you for who you are and that's worth being dishonest for?
 
I find myself with just the opposite sometimes.

I have an aunt and uncle who are staunch Republican. I am...while I wouldn't say liberal, my feelings on most issues lean toward what would be considered "liberal". If anything, I consider myself libertarian. But I digress. To give you an idea of how conservative these people are, one time I was adding powdered iced tea mix to a glass of water, and my fiancee says "Wow, have a little iced tea mix?" And I responded "Eh, so I'm liberal with it, so what?" Using, of course, the textbook, not political, meaning of the word. My aunt comes rushing around the corner, and looks around saying "Did I just hear the 'l' word in my house??" :what:


So needless to say, most conversations I try to keep superficial. It would be difficult to have serious talks with them. Well, except guns, of course.

I think in the situation you describe, where the honest answer would be less than desirable, the "background check, job I didn't get" would probably be the best answer.
 
No offense, but you lack the guile to be a lawyer! Think more about what you say! You don't want this to happen when negotiating for a client on a million dollar matter.
 
Since you want to avoid a lie, simply say "Security clearance", and let it go at that.

The fingerprints are for a security clearance, to give you authorization to carry concealed. Because it is a security issue, you can say nothing further.

Carrying concealed is nothing to be ashamed of, but to remain concealed, and thus protected it is frequently wise to keep quiet about it. Once another person knows, you lose control of the information.
 
Interesting.

Honestly I can't help you much because I can't relate.

I only posted because I'm so surprised at your desire to hide the fact that you have a permit. Do you mind if I ask what state you're from?

Myself, I'm from MA, surrounded by antis, work with antis, have relatives that are antis, etc.. I gleefully showed off my permit to pretty much anyone who would humor me as soon as I got it. You could almost say I'm proud of my permit and my firearm(s).

Just shocks me to know that someone would want to cover that up I guess. I'd almost be more likely to try to cover up the fact that I was a lawyer ;)

Dope
 
This doesn't need to be about whether I need to be open about carrying a concealed weapon.

I'm just looking for those of you who choose not to disclose it deal with either evading the topic, or if something like this happens - I'm looking for easy ways to change the subject, or at least answer questions without getting into the cwp issue.

I know many of you would prefer that we all proudly speak of the subject, but I feel I can carry to protect myself without being a walking advertisement for RKBA. I'm proud to be willing to protect myself as I feel it's the responsible way to live. However, I also value discretion when it comes to controversial topics.

No offense, but you lack the guile to be a lawyer!

I don't feel I need to be willing to lie to be an attorney.

I think you need to practice dissembling a LOT if you actually want to become a good lawyer.

same thing as above. Although if you wanted to say I need to practice being quicker on my feet when it comes to responses, I'd agree.

I only posted because I'm so surprised at your desire to hide the fact that you have a permit. Do you mind if I ask what state you're from?

Florida. I think "Hide" is the wrong word. I just don't want to bring it up. If somebody asked me, "Do you have a permit?" I'd probably be honest then. I just don't feel I need to bring it up and disclose it, especially with my anti family.
 
Very interesting. I have no problem letting friends and family know I am licensed and trained to carry concealed. The bonus.....I get to invite folks shooting and educate people who are curious about guns and never had the opportunity to ask questions about shooting and our individual right to keep and bear arms. It's nice to innoculate folks against the media misconceptions of who/what firearms owners are.
 
Do all states require fingerprints as part of bar admission? Never knew that, that doesn't really sound like a great thing.
 
I had mine done digitally for my Insurance licesnce here in FL. Pisses me off I gotta pay for it again!
 
Do all states require fingerprints as part of bar admission? Never knew that, that doesn't really sound like a great thing.
I'm not sure, but I would wager most if not all do. Prints are required for many applications, to conduct a criminal background check, and to insure the applicant is who they say they are. For example, a nursing license requires prints, as does a medical license. In some states, a real estate license requires prints. A haz-mat license does too. Some states require prints for a marriage license. Those are only a few that come to mind immediately.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top