I used my Illinois FOID card once to try and buy a beer in another state and had the police called on me because the waiter and the manager both thought it was bogus.
The Police said that my name and DOB checked out but the restaurant had no obligation to return my ID to me. Cop mentioned he'd never heard of needing a permit to own a gun.
It took over an hour of wrangling with the manager before she would even give me my ID back.
Also, one time out with my entire family I used it in an Illinois restaurant and the waiter wouldn't accept it while making the comment, "You aren't carrying a firearm now, are you?" He'd never seen one before, either.
I don't know what FOIDs look like now, but the one I had looks like a fifth grader had a go at making it with a pair of round-tip scissors and a manual typewriter.
All other times I've been asked for ID (like when buying ammo at Wal-Mart) I've been open carrying, so the whole "rifle or handgun?" question is a bit unnecessary.