Its all about perspective

Status
Not open for further replies.

Pentrite

Member
Joined
Feb 2, 2014
Messages
60
Location
Reno, NV
Que the scary music. This is a true story.. with VIDEO!! Could have been a real "somebody picked the wrong girl.. glock commercial"
18 year old girl. Home alone with the dog. 9:15pm. Dog starts barking and running towards the door, continues barking. Someone starts banging on the door. No one is expected. My daughter turns on TV to view video cameras outside. She sees a figure move down the steps towards the yard and into the shadows then look through the window at her watching the cameras.. He then moves out of camera range. The man moves again up the side of the house and again knocks however he is not in light, still in the shadows. Then he moves out of camera range again. She asks several times "who is it?" with no response.
My daughter is starting to panic and decides to arm herself. She takes the dog and the gun and barricades herself in the safe room. (one way in, no windows, locked from the inside.) Knocking continues for several minutes, seems relentless. Unfortunately I didn't have a video monitor in the safe room then. From there she calls me but I'm 45 min away. She tells me the story of how she saw a guy looking in the window, and got the gun. I decide to call the police and tell her to stay put. The sheriff dispatch tells me that they will go by and check, but she comes back on the phone almost immediately and tells me that its a Deputy at the door. He never identified himself as a Deputy and didn't stay in camera range. I have since moved the cameras around for a better view of the yard but this was a learning experience. My daughter was pretty upset.
Video is here.. https://vimeo.com/95963076
What she saw and what she missed in the delay of turning on the TV monitor..

The deputy was looking for a missing child. The childs cell phone was tracked to a street one block over. He said he thought the kid was in our yard. My daughter couldn't sleep that night.

lessons learned:
more lighting off the steps
video monitor in the safe room
told daughter to call police first, not me...

btw, she is a crack shot with my 9mm, even without the laser! daddys little girl!
 
Before looking at your video, I wasn't thinking the "intruder" was a deputy, then in the first second it was obvious, I guess I'm confused as to how she couldn't tell? It is odd he didn't announce himself when she asked who was there.

This is a great reason why arming yourself, going into a safe room in the home and calling the police is a far superior approach than opening the door armed or (yikes!) shooting through it as has been done and suggested before.

Thanks for posting, glad it turned out fine. She did good, I think perhaps the reason it was more obvious to me is I'm in tune with body language and posture more.

He looked, walked, moved like a cop. That and the hand mike, then the vest profile. Taken all together at a glance he screamed cop to me even in the first dark second.
 
Also consider...

Installing motion activated lighting

Installing a wireless intercom system
 
I agree with him looking like a deputy. My question was why he didn't say "deputy sheriff" or something like that.. and why he didn't stay in the light? I have a door camera that looks directly down in front of the door which shows perfectly who he was. While he is lurking in the bushes, looking through the window in the shadow, its a little harder to tell. Especially when you are 18 and alone.

I am looking into an intercom. My motion lights work great if you are standing under them. Now I have one more.

Last year 4 people in our town were killed in two home invasions by the same guy. He burned the second house down to destroy evidence, then killed a 5th and stole his truck. Its not a bad neighborhood but when she is alone, the door stays closed and locked. The cameras are way better than a peep hole!

If he had just stayed still for a second..
Snapshot.png
 
Last edited:
Psychologically, the reason she didn't recognize him as a deputy is due to confirmation bias. We see what we expect to see and our minds suppress data to the contrary.

When he banged on the door she wasn't expecting anyone and got scared. She thought he was an intruder already. When she turned on the monitor, her mind focused on the guy in the shadows looking through the window confirming her fears. It disregarded the other clues that he wasn't an intruder.

I'm a training junkie and this is why we train things like chamber checks, hand search everyone prior to force on force training, double and triple check things etc.
 
Someone in a uniform =/= friendly. I'd say even if she had thought it was an officer, the right move was still to barricade herself until it was confirmed that this actually is a sworn officer. Police impersonators are not that uncommon.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top