Let's Talk Alternatives

Status
Not open for further replies.
I gave up magnum powders for bullseye in the pistol mags. Same accuracy, same recoil, less noise, far cheaper, longer barrel life only 1-200 FPS lost. Red dot will work too, as will power pistol, HP-38. I switched to only H335 for 223. Do not use pistol primers in rifle, I have personally seen an AR go full auto from it, and the police did come, and had lots of questions. Floating firing pin will set off a pistol primer. I have shot many rifle primers in pistols, Glock, Ruger, CZ, Springfield, Kel-Tec, beretta come to mind. My A.O. 1911 would not reliably light them off, but it has a 30lb firing pin spring.
 
I’ve often wondered what other characteristics powders have that isn’t talked about. Is it really so simple as to select a close burn rate and get similar results?

In another life I built drag race motors and fuel selection was a big deal. Wrong fuel could cause detonation and engine damage. Or just make less horse power and run slower. The numbers everybody looked at was octane but burn rate effected the tune (ignition timing) and was just as important.

Along that line of thought, anybody know of an “octane” chart for gun powder? Seems like a characteristic that has to be known by at least the manufacturers know. A “low octane” powder might be more prone to pressure spikes. I’m just typing out loud and haven’t studied powder characteristics in any way so hopefully I’m not too far in left field.
 
Is it really so simple as to select a close burn rate and get similar results?

In another life I built drag race motors and fuel selection was a big deal. Wrong fuel could cause detonation and engine damage.

Not a bad analogy, some powders do different things under different environmental conditions, yet another reason data differs from different sources.
 
3031 is great for 30-30 but it seems to go fast. I have heard of people using it in .223 so I assume that to be why it disappears. Glad I have a few cans.
 
If that’s an offer, I’d make sure you do it legally. :)

It wasn’t actually, just an idea that assumed the legality wasn’t in question

And therein lies the rub. There are ways to do it, but it's expensive ($90 surcharge) USPS won't touch it at an price, so it must go UPS/FedEx. That's fine, but UPS/FedEx won't move anything overland into Alaska because of Canadian Customs. That leaves only Next Day and 2nd Day Air. So another price increase. Should be okay if I'm willing to pay, but it's not. Able Ammo told me straight up they chose not to do business with Alaskans because UPS/FedEx by air requires a specific size box with specific markings, and they don't want to bother. My buddy can't send it to me because UPS/FedEx are required by law to only accept hazmat packages from certified hazmat (It's a DOT training/certificate) shippers, which I don't think you can get if you're not working in the industry. (I learned some of this working in auto parts department. We had one guy who was a certified hazmat shipper, and he was the only guy allowed to package airbags, which are the same 1.4S hazmat classification as ammo/powder.)

So, between government regulations and company policies, it is pretty much impossible for any private citizen to mail order powder and primers in Alaska; you have to be a business, and it only works for them because thy order multiple pallets of product, which cost in the tens of thousands of dollars, and they ship it up on a barge through a freight forwarding company, and they're buying through a wholesale distributor.

The only thing I have ever had any luck with was ordering loaded ammo, having it shipped to a family member in the Lower 48, flying down to visit, and then bringing it back in checked baggage. Alaska Airlines is best at this as they allow a maximum of 50 lbs of ammo. United only allows 11 lbs.
 
So, you can fly to the lower 48, pick up a maximum of 50 lbs of Manufactured ammo, and fly home with it in your checked bags. Now let's run with that thought...

What if you were to fly to your family members place for a visit. Maybe a few days or a week. While there you could load up your 50 lbs of ammo and then fly home. Of course you would have to have some loading equipment at your family's place, along with the components needed, but it is a thought to consider.

Another thought I had (it's 3am here and I'm only on my second cup of coffee) is that you could talk to your normal supplier of powder and primers. See if they would add an additional bunch of powder and primers to their next order specifically for you. I would think if they order pallets worth tens of thousands of dollars that an extra ten or twenty pounds of powder and maybe five or ten thousand primers wouldn't be a big deal, and if they are concerned with the extra cost you could pay for it in advance. They may charge you a little extra for the special order, but it could work for you.

chris
 
And therein lies the rub. There are ways to do it, but it's expensive ($90 surcharge) USPS won't touch it at an price, so it must go UPS/FedEx. That's fine, but UPS/FedEx won't move anything overland into Alaska because of Canadian Customs. That leaves only Next Day and 2nd Day Air. So another price increase. Should be okay if I'm willing to pay, but it's not. Able Ammo told me straight up they chose not to do business with Alaskans because UPS/FedEx by air requires a specific size box with specific markings, and they don't want to bother. My buddy can't send it to me because UPS/FedEx are required by law to only accept hazmat packages from certified hazmat (It's a DOT training/certificate) shippers, which I don't think you can get if you're not working in the industry. (I learned some of this working in auto parts department. We had one guy who was a certified hazmat shipper, and he was the only guy allowed to package airbags, which are the same 1.4S hazmat classification as ammo/powder.)

So, between government regulations and company policies, it is pretty much impossible for any private citizen to mail order powder and primers in Alaska; you have to be a business, and it only works for them because thy order multiple pallets of product, which cost in the tens of thousands of dollars, and they ship it up on a barge through a freight forwarding company, and they're buying through a wholesale distributor.

The only thing I have ever had any luck with was ordering loaded ammo, having it shipped to a family member in the Lower 48, flying down to visit, and then bringing it back in checked baggage. Alaska Airlines is best at this as they allow a maximum of 50 lbs of ammo. United only allows 11 lbs.

I had no idea Alaska was an island!:confused: That's bad for a person just trying to be free.

Maybe a place in Washington on the coast that will ship it, on an actual boat. Probably a lost cause because they're sure to be sold out too.

If it was me, I would throw money at one of your LGS. Somehow guarantee that you'll buy multiple 8 pound cans of powder and 50,000 primers all at once. This sucks because you'll need to have $3000 to make such an order.
 
Why can't you just walk into a gun store that sells powder, and place an order?

If I want a certain powder, that's what I do. 300-MP? Asked my LGS to get me some. BE-86? Asked my LGS to get me some. When they place their next powder order, what I want goes on that list.
 
Have you tried here?
https://www.alaskaammogroup.com/

From Ketchikan to Barrow, if a plane or boat goes there, we’ll deliver!

Not the cheapest I’ve ever seen but not $90 either.

D933F909-E8D7-492A-B08A-0741D53E83FE.jpeg

I didn’t check everything on your list but the Fairbanks location has 2400, H-110 and 4064 in stock. At that shipping price I’d be buying 26 lbs of stuff though.
 
Just to clear some things up, do NOT have someone ship you powder or primers. These require a HAZMAT shipper to send them. FedEx and UPS both have a process if you want to get certified.

Which brings me to this: powder and primers are classified as either 1.1 or 1.4 Explosives (I can't remember which offhand) for the purposes of shipping. That means they can't be sent by air (FedEx has this right on their HAZ page, UPS is a bit harder to find). The reason for this restriction is the cargo can't be monitored while in flight and several aircraft have been lost when their cargoes exploded and/or caught fire. The whole list of what is and is not acceptable for transport on an aircraft is widely available. And before anyone gets all excited, the reason the Alaska Ammo group can get away with an aircraft delivery is going to be because the pilot is in a small aircraft (in the same cabin actually) and can monitor his cargo directly.

Bottom line, if you are in Alaska, you get whatever the boat or truck will bring you from the lower 48.

This all coming from a former - but longtime - HAZ-certified shipper.
 
H110 is near identical to W296, which I’ll bet is also gone because this is pretty common knowledge amongst the Magnum handgun crowd.
Enforcer is in the same ballpark as H110. Incredibly fine granules compared to other pistol powders I've used (Titegroup, WST, CFE Pistol), which tend to jam up my powder trickler. Burns a little dirty, but I may need to load a little hotter.
 
The M1 is a different animal powder wise. Generally you want to stay as close to the 4895 burn rate as possible to avoid damage to the operating rod. Some known alternatives are IMR 4320, W748, Varget, N140, R15. Some others that might work...AR Comp, Vn135, IMR 3031, CFE 223, H335. Most of the above will also work in .223. Some that others have used that I would not personally are BL-C2 (I experienced erratic ignition and a bent op-rod in cold weather following Hornady Garand data), H414/W760 (should be too slow, but I know a guy on CMP forums that swears by it), IMR 4350 (should be too slow, but I've seen it used).

For the handgun powders, IMR/H 4227, AA9, Alliant magnum pistol or Lil' gun will get you close. Some of the mediums slower than HS-6 will make loads with heavy cast bullets suitable for large game, but will not match the velocity of the magnum powders.
Or, he could install an aftermarket gas plug. $40 solution, requires no modifications. https://www.midwayusa.com/product/100471950
 
With regard to primers, I often use pistol primers in .500 S&W cases meant for rifle primers. They seat a little deeply, but are perfectly reliable. Sample of one, of course...
 
Have you tried here?
https://www.alaskaammogroup.com/



Not the cheapest I’ve ever seen but not $90 either.

View attachment 922234

I didn’t check everything on your list but the Fairbanks location has 2400, H-110 and 4064 in stock. At that shipping price I’d be buying 26 lbs of stuff though.

I have checked with those guys. You're looking at the "Bush Order" page, which is a common thing for local businesses up here. Costco even delivers food to the bush (rural village with no road access). I do believe they transfer product between Fairbanks and Anchorage. (THB, I looked at their Anchorage inventory, and, when I didn't see 4895, I moved on to something else.)
 
powder and primers are classified as either 1.1 or 1.4 Explosives (I can't remember which offhand) for the purposes of shipping. That means they can't be sent by air

Loaded ammo is 1.4S. I know this because airbags are also 1.4S.

So...my question then, is this: can all loaded ammo be shipped by air? Because I was looking at ableammo.com and some of their ammo was marked "cannot be shipped via air" even though ti was nothing special.
 
Or, he could install an aftermarket gas plug. $40 solution, requires no modifications. https://www.midwayusa.com/product/100471950
I have one. They are illegal for Service Rifle. DQs the gun. If it were SHTF (and we may see that) and I had to have a rifle, and the only ammo I could get was commercial 30-06 hunting ammo, then yeah, I could do that. Alaska hasn't had any rioting yet, thankfully.
 
Loaded ammo is 1.4S. I know this because airbags are also 1.4S.

So...my question then, is this: can all loaded ammo be shipped by air? Because I was looking at ableammo.com and some of their ammo was marked "cannot be shipped via air" even though ti was nothing special.
I'm not sure off the top of my head if ammo can be shipped via air, but I want to say yes (I will dig up an answer as soon as I have a bit more time).
 
Grafs claims to ship to Alaska, as does Powder Valley, and Midsouth.

Have you contacted them and been told differently?
 
I do believe they transfer product between Fairbanks and Anchorage. (THB, I looked at their Anchorage inventory, and, when I didn't see 4895, I moved on to something else.)

If I am understanding what you are saying, you don’t have a lot of options that are not a lot more expensive.

I did check their inventory though and it looks like you are good to go, if you order now.

They have 3 lbs in stock as of 1:00 today.
https://fairbanksammo.ecwid.com/Hodgdon-H4895-1lb-p62666842

As well as others on your list.
https://fairbanksammo.ecwid.com/IMR-4064-1lb-p62666869

https://fairbanksammo.ecwid.com/Hodgdon-H110-1lb-p62666834

https://fairbanksammo.ecwid.com/Alliant-2400-1lb-p86400754

That’s 4 of six listed in the OP in stock deliverable in your State, add some AR comp, Ram shot x-terminator or other suitable .223 powders they have in stock and load away.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top