His initial story should have raised lots of flags. Guns don't knock people down, but he reports that it happened almost every time he shot one of them.
"Van Meter said he shot and hit him in the right side, knocking him down immediately."
"Van Meter shot again and hit him in the back and knocked him down."
"Van Meter said he jumped on a pile of logs and shot at the assailant waist-deep in the beaver pond. The man went down..."
I'm guessing he accidentally shot himself and didn't want to admit it. Shot himself some more and came up with the story to cover it up.
You'd think after he went to that trouble he'd try to keep his story consistent...
Or he could just be insane.
"Van Meter said he shot and hit him in the right side, knocking him down immediately."
"Van Meter shot again and hit him in the back and knocked him down."
"Van Meter said he jumped on a pile of logs and shot at the assailant waist-deep in the beaver pond. The man went down..."
I'm guessing he accidentally shot himself and didn't want to admit it. Shot himself some more and came up with the story to cover it up.
You'd think after he went to that trouble he'd try to keep his story consistent...
Or he could just be insane.