Police department shoots two dogs in isolated incidents.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Blackfork

Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2006
Messages
1,219
Location
East Texas
March 21, 2007
BY NICHOLAS P. ALAKAJIS [email protected]

ROUND LAKE BEACH -- Take a step inside Bonny Palka's home and you'd never guess that her living room and kitchen were the setting for a bloody police shooting just a week earlier.

Floors have been mopped, walls scrubbed and the carpet -- well, the carpet has been cleaned and scrubbed and scrubbed some more. A blanket now covers some of the worst-stained areas.
» Click to enlarge image
Bonny Palka of Round Lake Beach holds up the tank top she was wearing at the time of her arrest. It's covered with blood from her dog, Bam, who was shot by police.
(Marina Samovsky/News-Sun)

But in that very home, at 602 Ivy Court, is where Bonny says one of her best friends was taken away, because of overzealous police officers. And she was forced to spend the night in a holding cell wearing bloody clothes.

Palka's black Labrador retriever, Bam, was shot and killed in the early hours of March 13 while Round Lake Beach officers were serving a drug warrant at the home.

In an odd game of he-said, she-said, Palka claims that police were ruthless in shooting her pup. Police, on the other hand, say they feared for their own safety, and the integrity of the case when they fired three fatal bullets.

About the only thing both sides agree on is the location of the incident.

After an investigation into suspected drug use at the home, village police officers arrived to search the home around midnight. Palka, 49, was home with her boyfriend, Keith Glorioso, 41, her 18-year-old daughter, and her daughter's boyfriend.

Palka said after police pounded on the door and entered the home, her dog, Bam became excited. As she attempted to restrain him, officers began yelling. And before anyone could get Bam out of the way, he was shot -- while running away from officers, according to Palka.

"I saw they had guns, and I said 'don't shoot the dog,'" Palka said. "Then they put three bullets to the dog. They didn't even give him a chance."

Round Lake Beach Deputy Chief Gary Bitler said Palka's story is not entirely true.

"The dog was being aggressive," Bitler said. "It was not running away. Most of the time they just run in the opposite direction."

It is department protocol for officer to shoot a dog if they feel threatened, Bitler said. The discretion is up to the officer.

"We can't be held at bay, standing near the door, while people are running around the house doing whatever they're doing," he said.
Shot three times
Bitler says that Bam was shot in the jaw once and twice in the shoulder, which shows that it was facing officers when shot.

Palka counters that Bam was shot near its rear end. Palka did provide a CD full of photos taken after the shooting. In images too gruesome for publication, Bam's jaw is nearly shot off and there appear to be a bullet wound near the left side of his rear end.

Bam's body was taken to Lake County animal control after the shooting, but spokeswoman Leslie Piotrowski said her agency does not know where the dog was shot, because they were not there.

Bam bled all over the kitchen floor, before Palka took him into her arms, where he bled all over her, while he gasped for his final breaths.

That's when Palka's night got even worse. Both she and Glorioso were arrested for possession of cocaine, and where taken to a separate holding cells before a morning appearance in the Lake County Courthouse. The two teenagers at the home were also cited for possession of drug paraphernalia.

Palka said he wasn't allowed to change out of her bloody, smelly clothes, and was forced to spend the night shivering, in a tank top and sweatpants. The smell caused her to vomit three times.

Bitler said the department regrets forcing her to stay in holding cell with blood-soaked clothes. There was no female officer at the scene, and he said officers made a decision at the time to not let her change, because they could not supervise her.

"I would probably prefer they didn't make her do that," Bitler said. "I guess that's all hindsight."

What makes the story stranger is that Bam wasn't the only dog shot by RLB police last week. The following night police killed a pit bull while serving another warrant.

A pit bull makes more sense, Glorioso said. Those dogs are traditionally violent. Black labs don't have a violent reputation, he argues.

"Bam was rowdy, but he was happy. He was jumpy, (but he) never bit anybody."

Glorioso said he thinks that police are too quick to pull the trigger. He points to last weeks' incidents as a reason for that.

Bitler said that's not the case. Those incidents are isolated, and just happed to occur on back-to-back night, Bitler said. A different officer shot both dogs.

Though all dogs shot by local police are taken by Animal Control, Piotrowski said they do not keep statistics on how many dogs are shot, and which department does the shooting.

Palka said her Glorioso have filed a complaint with the police department. They doubt it will be taken seriously. They've also hired a lawyer.

Palka doesn't pretend to be the perfect victim. She was arrested for cocaine possession, in a home where her adult daughter was found with drug paraphernalia. Still, those ills do not justify her dog being shot, she said.

Bitler did offer some condolences to both families. "We hate to do that. A lot of us are dog owners," he said.

Last week's incidents may change the way the department deals with dogs, Bitler said. How exactly, he's not sure, but he wants to avoid officers having to fire a weapon at pet.

"We'll look at it," Bitler said. "We're always looking for different ways to do things."
 
Well, if you are going to do things that you know might bring the police around, bad stuff might happen. Labs may not be violent, but they can be protective just like any dog.


Is there any standard protocol for dealing with dogs on searches/raids? Just curious what LEO's are supposed to do if not this.
 
Well we can all sleep more soundly knowing that the cops have stopped some woman from taking cocaine. By killing her dog and arresting her.
 
I know some people will not like my response, but it's only a dog. I treat all animals as equals, no matter how cute or domesticated they may be.
 
I can't be held accountable for the consequences of someone shooting my Jack Russell Terriers-- regardless of the circumstances. No, they are not just dogs-- and I wouldn't consider them a threat to anything but a tennis ball.


Ask me about my opinion of that pet food manufacturer who got a lot of pets killed-- and then only wants to have to pay replacement costs of the pets.


John
 
@Lucky

HAHAHA good one! Dave Chappelle is our local hero (I live in Greene County, Ohio where he was born and raised, so I see him quite often and have taken numerous picture with him) so I am quite familar with the skit in question :)

"And then his wife threw her titties in my hands. It was weird"
 
How dare those people live their lives in the manner they want too! The dog deserves to be shot for associating with those drug taking scum. Next thing you know, they'll be wearing make up, skimpy clothes and dancing with members of the opposite sex. Well, at least it will give the cops and the judges something to talk about at the bar where they smoke cigarretes and drink alkyhol.:barf:
 
While I feel sorry for the dog, drug addicts don't get any sympathy from me. I would rather associate with zombies and vampires than a drug addict. It is like something evil takes over their brain, and they will lie, steal, cheat and defraud anybody around them just to satisfy their urges.
 
A lot of you sound ticked off that an officer had to shoot a dog because they were trying to serve a search warrant. Am I hearing this right? If the dog was shot in the jaw then it was facing the cops, unless the cops now have those special boomerang bullets that we hear about all the time :uhoh: If any of you think that black labs can not be vicious when people are threatening the family then you are loco. My 100lb lab will give life and limb to protect us and inflict serious damage while doing it.
The bottom line is these criminals had coke in their house and the police knew it. They were executing a search warrant and came up against a dog that may have been hindering and/or threatening them. If the dog was shot in the jaw and chest then face it the dog was probably not running away.
If this idot lady didn't want bad things to happen to her then she shouuldn't be doing bad things. PERIOD.
 
And it was reported that there was also a wound near the left side of its rear end. Ever heard of an angle of, oh I dunno, \ yeah kinda like that facing away? I know its a \ but use your imagination, I can easily see the animal be facing generaly away and still manage to get its jaw blown off. Yet another case where the war on some drugs makes us all safer, shooting a dog that didn't hurt a sole and making its owner spend all night covered in its blood. Yeah, real good. So the next time the neighbors little rat dog comes onto my yard and barks at me like the little rat he is I can whip out a gun and shoot him right? I mean so long as I feel threatened? Newsflash, when a strange person comes in the home most dogs freakin bark.

You can say what you want about the owners because of the cocain, fact is that doesn't mean they were lowlife drug rats. And that doesn't give the police license to do whatever the hell they want without damn good reason.
 
If the dog was shot in the jaw then it was facing the cops, unless the cops now have those special boomerang bullets that we hear about all the tim
Have you ever lived with or been around dogs? I ask because every time I've chased off a dog they have looked over their shoulder while running off, making sure they are not being pursued. This places the jaw in a perfect position to be shot even though the animal was fleeing.
 
How much cocaine did they find?
From reading this story, this reminds me of the college student who was shot and killed when being served a search warrant of his home to bust him for dealing marijuana. They found less than a half oz in the house...but hey, 'criminals' deserve what's coming to them right? The day people who are drinking alcohol are considered criminals for drinking it in their own homes i will start to believe that these people deserved the treatment they received. Oh wait, no, i won't (that didn't work either...prohibition anyone? how is that any different than what is happening now with the vaunted 'war on drugs'?)
 
Sindawe, I wrote that I have a lab.
"As she attempted to restrain him, officers began yelling. And before anyone could get Bam out of the way, he was shot -- while running away from officers, according to Palka."
So she was trying to restrain the dog and the cops shot the dog? Right next to her? If the dog was running away, why did she try to get the dog out of the way?
And is it possible that the dog was facing the officers and the shot missed the head / chest and struck the rear of the dog travelling towards the rear or are you assuming the bullet hit from behind and traveled toward the head?
And why does it matter how much coke was in the house? Is recreational cocaine use of an eightball or less legal?
Lupinus, you know a lab is not a rat dog. C'mon man. I guess most dogs bark while running away from strangers in their house too?
I don't know the whole story nor does anyone. I am just looking at it from my view and you from yours. That's all.
 
If the cops were shooting at a low angle at the dog's head and missed, it would likely hit it in the backside if it didn't completely miss. Someone not familiar with wounds could easily mistake a backside exist wound and assume they shot him from behind.

The simple fact is that if you use drugs, you have a good chance of bringing the cops down on you and nothing good will come of that. Even if drugs were legalized, there will still be reasons for LEO's to conduct search warrants.


I asked earlier: Do LEO's have any sort of protocol for dealing with dogs other than shooting them?
 
ive seen video's on TV of cops shooting a dog that was running around wagging its tail at the officers.

the officers pulled a car over that they thought matched the description of a bank robbery get away car. pulled it over. got the occupants out (a famly mother father and 2 kids) and the famly dog. the dog was in the car and jumped out the window of the car when the cops had the famly on their knee's with their hands behind their heads. the dog jumped out and ran up to one of the cops wagging its tail not being agressive at all. the cops let out a girly scream (was a man) and shot the dog in the face with a shotgun.

10 mins later they get a call on the radio that they got the car from the robbery, and it didnt match the car they pulled over in the least. wasent eaven headed the same direction.
all the cops did was say sorry. gave the famly a garbage bag for the dog. and drove away.

real nice. they used the same excuse that the officer felt threatend by an "attacking dog" where they showed the video of the dog prancing around wagging its tail being friendly.
 
Unless they shot the dog in the @ss, its at least plausible the dog was facing the officers and therefor not entirely passive or retreating. Serving warrants is always high risk, and in the half second you have to shoot/don't shoot, unless the dog's butt is the only thing I can see, the dog goes down. Sorry. Now, the general reputation for a particular department being trigger-happy is another matter. Cite an examination that shows they shoot more often than other departments and I will readily look with a critical eye. While I believe Aries saw what he says he saw, neither he nor I were there. The vagaries of how descriptions get screwed up and why police pull a vehicle over are too esoteric to go into, even if I knew them all, which I don't. Descriptions are off constantly, it matters little what direction the vehicle was going. That can be wrong as often as the color of the car. The animal's owner can always sue. I would.
 
yeah I guess mom's cocaine and her daughter's drug paraphenalia was planted. I am sure they are the model family

Yes, by all means, break down their door and kill their dog! They are doing something illegal ! I sure know that every person i know who has ever done any cocaine is a complete scourge of society, a total addict and should have their home invaded and their pet killed. Hell, why not just do the same thing to people who drink a bottle of whiskey in their house, or smoke a joint of weed. People who are in pain and illegally get a couple of painkillers from a family member should probably get the same treatment too... Hell yeah! ZERO TOLERANCE ****es!!
 
Yes, police officers often do have to shoot aggressive dogs when the officers are serving a warrant. Most of the alternative solutions to aggressive dogs are no solutions at all.

Closing this one because there's been a lot of heat, little light, and too much all-cops-are-bad ranting.

As always, feel free to PM me or another moderator if you have any questions about the closure.

pax
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top