barnbwt
member
- Joined
- Aug 14, 2011
- Messages
- 7,340
"But using this argument gives a government that does not recognize morality grounds to call the whole Bill of Rights null and void."
Fixed it for you. Faith is ultimately where many morals come from, since many serve no 'utilitarian' purpose for the betterment of mankind. An amoral government is free to work its will on any and all, so long as sufficient betterment for the part that matters can be argued. The concept that the individual has value is not part of utilitarian theory, as the greater portion of the group (or the part that matters) always takes precedence. An individual's claim to personal worth comes from themselves, and often as a product of their faith.
We get hung up on specific details of faith and religion and forget that the actual guiding principle of our government was that individuals are valuable and deserve to be shielded from ruthless utilitarian tyrants. The king was supposedly ordained by God to rule in the best interest of his subjects, after all, and rest assured he argued just that as he ordered Hessian mercenaries to annihilate the Colonial militia.
TCB
Fixed it for you. Faith is ultimately where many morals come from, since many serve no 'utilitarian' purpose for the betterment of mankind. An amoral government is free to work its will on any and all, so long as sufficient betterment for the part that matters can be argued. The concept that the individual has value is not part of utilitarian theory, as the greater portion of the group (or the part that matters) always takes precedence. An individual's claim to personal worth comes from themselves, and often as a product of their faith.
We get hung up on specific details of faith and religion and forget that the actual guiding principle of our government was that individuals are valuable and deserve to be shielded from ruthless utilitarian tyrants. The king was supposedly ordained by God to rule in the best interest of his subjects, after all, and rest assured he argued just that as he ordered Hessian mercenaries to annihilate the Colonial militia.
TCB