There are people who deserve to die. The guy they executed in SC-he murder his estranged wife, and his FIL in front of his children-he admitted it freely. No hope there. For the crime of starting The Crips a man should die, notwithstanding the murders; but in the years he's been in, he's worked to correct that mistake.
The question is not whether "Tookie" should be executed. The larger question is: Is there a role in our penal system for clemency? Can the condemned, who will never take a step outside prison ever again, be allowed to live out his natural span in an attempt to undo the harms he caused?