Should VT Pres. and Blacksburg Police Chief Be Fired?

Status
Not open for further replies.
hmm river helps but i can't find a blockade

are you advocating declaring martial law for every homicide? you comparing a full scale riot with a double homicide?!

sure it might not have been 71? how old were ya?
i'm looking and not finding any report that cops sealed the city.

oops correction i did find this thread in a search but other than that....
 
I don't think it was '71. I was about 18 or 19 at the time. Where are you looking? It may have been more like mid-70's. Anyway, I was THERE and saw it with my own two eyes, so this isn't second hand information.

The cops blocked every road into the city.

"you comparing a full scale riot with a double homicide?!"

Nope. You comparing a college campus to a real city?
 
mike101 said;
"In the mid 70's, some of the Hispanic population of Camden, NJ were rioting, setting fires in the downtown area, etc. The police from Camden and surrounding towns cordoned off the whole damn city! My friends and I spent the rest of the night trying to sneak into Camden, just to see if we could. We could not. The only way in would have been to go around Camden, drive to Philly, jump in the Delaware River, and swim over. And Camden is a hell of a lot bigger than 2600 acres."

Just a couple of questions:

How long had the riot been going on before the city was sealed shut?

How much manpower from other agencies was used and how long did it take them to arrive on scene?

Do you really believe that they sealed off a city in less then two hours?

Here is a little example of how these things work: Back in September we had a train derailment near here. I was working an evening shift 4p-midnight. The train derailed at 4:17. About 4:25 someone noticed that there was vapor leaking from some derailed tank cars and the fire department was called. The fire department arrived on scene about 4:33. The firefighters were unable to get eyes on the placards on the leaking cars from a safe vantage point so they began to suit up their hazmat team and sheriff's deputies (two working for the entire county at the time) began to go door to door at nearby residences evacuating people. Additional fire personnel located the conductor and the manifest so they could attempt to identify what was in the cars that were leaking. The wind speed and direction was measured and about 4:40 the decision was made to close the interstate because the derailed cars were only a few yards up wind of the highway. I was assigned to assist a state trooper with closing the interstate at the North end of the affected area. The trooper an I took our squad cars down onto the Southbound lanes and got traffic stopped, then diverted up the ramp. Unfortunately many people didn't get the message and drove up the ramp and instead of following the detour sign, went right back down the ramp and back onto the interstate, driving through the affected area.

We placed cones where the squad cars were sitting and I took my squad up to the top of the overpass and blocked the ramp going back down the into the Southbound lanes. I then began directing traffic to make the left turn to follow the detour sign. There were still several drivers who were fearful of leaving the interstate and ignored my direction to turn left, drove around my marked squad car blocking the ramp and continued South on the interstate. I ended up stretching yellow crime scene tape across the entire ramp.

Around 4:45, the county Emergency Service and Disaster Agency (a volunteer organization) was activated. They began arriving on the scene within about 5 minutes. The other fire departments in the area called out their hazmat teams and dispatched them to the scene, the DOT began arriving with large lighted signs for the detour route about 3 hours later.

All in all it took over 4 hours for sufficient people from all the various agencies involved to arrive on scene to really get everything locked down and secured so that all entrances into the affected area were sealed off. And the area around the train wreck was much smaller then the college campus or Camden. the fact of the matter is, unless you have the personnel you need on site in a staging area, you don't seal off anything of any size and complexity within two hours. It's physically impossible.

FMJMIKE said,
The Police were too busy chasing a false lead. That's not being psychic. Thats being incompetent !!! The murderer had time to mail packages and film videos between the murders.

Too bad the cops were not searching for a possible murderer on campus. They had assumed the murderer had left campus !!! An assumption that is criminal and/or incompetent and should be reason for firing/charging those responsible.

What leads did they have to follow? Please post a link to the investigator's notes on the first homicides. I must have missed the part about the detailed note the scumbag left at the scene of the first murders telling the police of his nefarious plans. :rolleyes:

I suppose you will support the police sealing off your entire town, locking it down, permitting no movement until the suspect is in custody the next time there is a violent crime in your town. :scrutiny:

Jeff
 
C.Daddy

OK, I've been poking around a little. Camden had riots in the '60s (who didn't), and again in '71, and again in '74. The worst was in August '71, and it involved the Puerto Rican community. That must be the one. So, I was not quite 18 at the time. And yes, the river helps. But if the river wasn't there, they would have had Philadelphia's finest to deal with. At the time, Frank Rizzo was Philly's mayor. He was an ex-cop/Police Commish., and a legend in his own time. The Philly cops pretty much had free reign to do whatever they saw fit. Nobody would have messed with them, trust me. You could find yourself buried in a vacant lot in North Philly.

Jeff- The rioting went on for 3 nights. The city was closed off on nights 2 and 3. Don't know exactly how much manpower was involved, but police from Gloucester, Haddon Twp., Collingswood, Pennsauken, and Woodlynne (all three of them, Woodlynne is TINY) were involved. Collingswood and Pennsauken aren't exactly metropoli, either. Is "metropoli" a word?

I realize that the police could not throw an actual blockade around the whole campus, but most of it is open ground. I still think they could have done something with the buildings. And, they didn't even start emailing students until the second wave of shootings was underway. And emailing was a stupid, and woefully inadequite way to warn them.
 
Last edited:
"The police from Camden and surrounding towns cordoned off the whole damn city!"

Cordoning off is different than locking down. One encircles, the other entails not only cordoning, but preventing movement between points on the campus as well as in and out of buildings - any movement at all actually, maybe even within buildings.

John
 
The VA Tech campus was shut down just last year (August 2006) in response to a shooting suspect being in the area.

http://www.roanoke.com/news/roanoke/wb/79080

Access to Tech's campus has been largely shut down, with classes canceled and staff evacuated.

I'm sure that that situation was not identical, but it does show that it can be done--more importantly that it HAS been done recently.

This situation was simply one of the best examples we've had in the U.S. of what happens when large pools of unarmed victims are created and told that someone else will keep them safe. They aren't kept safe, and then, worse yet, their deaths are used as a pretense to disarm even more citizens.
 
Last edited:
I just hope that all the people who are defending the actions taken by the Police and President of Va. Tech are not in a position of responsibility. I would hate to think they are letting defeatists and people not willing to take responsibility for their actions do anything where their inaction would lead to more deaths. These poor dead students and faculty deserved much better !!! If you don't expect more out of people you won't get it.
 
Wouldn't it had been better to at least made an effort to place at least one policeman in each building.

Let's do the math --

The VT campus PD has about 30 police officers.
The Blacksburg PD has about 50 police officers.
The Christiansburg PD has about 30 police officers.
The Montgomery County Sheriff's Office has about 40 deputies.

That's around 150 LEO's total in all of Montgomery County (how many are on duty on a Monday morning?).

The nearest state police office is in Salem, VA, nearly an hours drive away.

There are 300+ buildings on the main VT campus (not including the outlying areas). Not to mention the several miles of steam tunnel that run underneath the campus and connect almost every building. How exactly were they supposed to put an officer in every building?

You guys with the perfect 20/20 hindsight need to go over to Israel and join the IDF. You could make a fortune as advisors. They've been trying to stop suicidal mass killers for decades with very little success.
 
fmj said
"I just hope that all the people who are defending the actions taken by the Police and President of Va. Tech are not in a position of responsibility. I would hate to think they are letting defeatists and people not willing to take responsibility for their actions do anything where their inaction would lead to more deaths. These poor dead students and faculty deserved much better !!! If you don't expect more out of people you won't get it."

hmmm most remarkably almost all the folks defending the folks in charge are just that folks who are or have been in positions of responsibility. you know those guys with experience doing it as opposed to imagining how they could do it better if only....
maybe some of the keyboard commandos could regal us with their background and experience vis a vis responsible positions and moving and controlling large numbers of folks, much less doing it when things get a lil hairy. I'm sure we all wait with bated breath to be enlightened and informed. we will be sure to pass on the recommendations to those at the top and to implement them in our own affairs
 
The students were warned and the college was locked down a few months before the Va. Tech Massacre. I guess a lockdown is possible and not so difficult as some seem to think. The murder that caused that lockdown wasn't even on campus. On campus murders must not be serious enough to justify a lockdown or a warning. Just doesn't seem logical to me !!!
 
I don't know if they should be prosecuted/fired or not. How could you really know unless you were them and you were there. My whole problem with this is that everyone is looking for someone/something to blame. Conservatives blame not enough guns, liberals blame too many guns, etc, etc.

There is one person to blame and that is that SOB that finally put the gun to his own head and pulled the trigger, saving us taxpayers a load of money. If only he'd have done that with the first shot....
 
There is one person to blame...
The shooting is his fault. It's not quite so easy to assign the blame for it's going on for so long and claiming so many victims.

I'm not saying anybody should be fired--in fact I'd prefer that it not get taken care of that cleanly. That would put it to rest too rapidly and easily in many people's minds. People need to think about this for awhile.
 
"I'm sure that that situation was not identical, but it does show that it can be done--more importantly that it HAS been done recently."

Two major differences come immediately to mind.
Number one, they knew who they were looking for - Morva.
Second, they had from 2:30 a.m. to plan it and implement it before most folks got up.

"About 2:30 a.m. Sunday, Morva overpowered the officer, seized his pistol and shot Derrick McFarland, a hospital security guard, Davis said."
 
I don't want to see anyone lose their job but there is a problem with the timeline. 2 hours between the first pair of murders and the next large group of murders. also quite a distance between the locations.:uhoh:
 
What's the problem with the timeline? They were questioning one victim's boyfriend as a person of interest, but did not know who they were looking for or the motive, although a domestic situation was a reasonable assumption given the circumstances.

I suppose with enough manpower they could have stopped and searched everyone on campus. :scrutiny: After all, the guy wasn't walking around with a sign on his back, he was just one of many students in the crowd.

John
 
"And where does it say that a college president is authorized to call the shots, after a double murder occurs on campus?"

As the presidnet of the university he is the highest level of 'government' present.
This is a state chartered land grant university.
It is not legally located IN the town of Blacksburg since it is STATE property.
The campus police are deputized by the Va state police.

Who else would be in charge?
The governor?
 
My opinion means little to this arguement. It is in the hands of an official investigation. It will be interesting to see what they come up with. My apologies if I got to riled up. I am extremely upset about this............:(
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top