TOP 12 revolvers of all time

Status
Not open for further replies.

Brian Williams

Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Dec 22, 2002
Messages
10,655
Location
Kampong Cham, Cambodia
You get to pick 3 revolvers to add to the list and those 3 are your nomination and vote for what we THR's consider the top 12 most desireable, useful, pretty, handy, whatever your justification. We will look and see what comes up as the top 12.



I will start with

Colt Model P 1873 in Cavalry garb with 7.5 barrel and 45 colt

S&W M&P Pre-war, Post-war, Pre mod 10, Mod 10

Ruger OM Blackhawk in 357
 
My nominees (excluding duplications from previous posters) include:
a) Smith Model 27 (and predecessors) – Began S&W’s N Frame .357 magnum family
b) Smith Model 19 – Indicative of all K Frames
c) Early Colt Python (you pick the caliber and the barrel length) – Classic Beauty never fades

PS - My buddy Dan submitted while I was typing . . . and notice, great minds think alike.
 
O.K. Here they are:

1. 1860 Army Model Colt. The pinnacle of black powder beauty.


2. 1873 Colt SAA. do I need to elaborate?:D


3. The Colt Python. The pinnacle of modern revolver beauty.;)


Yes, I like Colts. No I do not hate Smiths, Dan Wessons, Taurus, etc.
I have owned Smiths, and fired them in the military. (Issue Commando models, as well as post war M10's!):cool: I know Colt has made some real stinkers. That said, I still like Colts.:D
 
Hmmm... interesting question! My take on this is: what revolver SIGNIFICANTLY CHANGED the handgun/revolver market? What revolver had such an impact that its effect has been seen ever since?

IMHO, revolvers meeting these criteria would be:

1. Colt Paterson;

2. S&W Military & Police (which gave rise to the Model 10, the K-frame, etc.);

3. I'd vote for the Colt and S&W Models of 1917 for the third gun. These introduced moon-clips, which have remained popular, and in recent years have been growing in popularity with such guns as the S&W 625.

I would not include the S&W Model 29, because whilst this gun was undoubtedly important, as a firearm, it was basically nothing more than a strong N-frame, which had been around since the early 1900's. What made the Model 29 so popular was its cartridge, the .44 Magnum.
 
Put me on the list for the Centennial model hammerless pocket protector.

Oh yeah... and a Dirty Harry 44 MAGNUM. :D
 
S&W Registered Magnum - Historical significance and just plain coolness should be obvious.
Colt Python - It's the Python. :D
J-frame S&W - how many pockets have one of these in 'em?
 
S&Ws that "must" go into such a list: original M&P, original registered magnum 357, original 44Mag.

Colts: PATTERSON, above all. Then the SAA.
 
the Colt SAA in .44-40 or .45 Colt, the S&W N frame triple Lock .44 and it's children, the M&P and it's children.;)
 
The N-framed guns ofcourse...


But of the tons of various models out there, notably the Model 27 and the 1917 along with the 45ACP revolvers it inspired.

Moon clip 45ACP wheel guns are just darned fine guns.
 
Any of the older Colt designs should fit as well as the early S&W offerings. To me one that fits is the Ruger Blackhawk as its strength has spawned many absolute nuclear loadings. The shear strength of the action makes a candidate. I guess if you wont accept the Blackhawk maybe the Redhawk
 
So far: / = 1 vote
///// Colt SAA or Model P 1873 in Cavalry garb with 7.5 barrel and 45 colt
///// Colt Python
//// S&W M&P Pre-war, Post-war, Pre mod 10, Mod 10
//// Smith 29
//// Smith & Wesson "Registered Magnum"
/// Smith & Wesson model 19
// Smith Model 27
// Colt Paterson
// Colt and S&W Models of1917
/ Ruger OM Blackhawk in 357
/ Ruger SP101
/ Dan Wesson Model 15
/ Ruger Single Six
/ S&W mountain gun
/ 1860 Army Model Colt
/ S&W 681
/ Centennial model hammerless pocket protector.
/ J-frame S&W - how many pockets have one of these in 'em?
/ the S&W N frame triple Lock .44
/ Ruger Blackhawk
/ Ruger Redhawk
 
1) S&W Registered Magnum ( I will be shooting mine tomorrow!)
2) Colt Python (I will be shooting it tomorrow also)
3) Colt SAA

It will be a fun day!
 
My top three:

1. Smith & Wesson Model 19...the ultimate in balance, pointability, and power.

2. Smith & Wesson J-frame...the quintessential civilian CCW and LEO backup gun

3. Smith & Wesson Model 29...representative of the big-bore N-frames.
 
First multiple barrel pistol was Merwin & Hulbert in 44-40. A Army with skullcrusher butt would be my choice. The 44-40 was the round that provided a centerfire match of rifles and pistols. Second choice would be the Webley Mark series in 455. A service standard big bore has to be appreciated. Third choice would be the Colt New Service. The Pythons, Troopers and 1917s were developed from this platform.
 
The most influential:

The Colt Walker/First Model Dragoon. The first really practical revolving pistols, which made all other pistols AND the sword obsolete. These convinced the world's military's that the revolver was practical.

The 1851 Colt Navy. This really generated the wide acceptance of the revolver. With the '51, the revolver became a truly portable personal weapon that could be comfortably worn on the person.
The first true "pistol fighters" used the '51 Navy.

The Colt SAA. There were other cartridge pistols, but none were more wide spread, and like the '51 Navy, gained acceptance for cartridge revolvers.

The Colt Model 1889 Navy. This was the world's first swing-out cylinder revolver, which every revolver since has basically copied.

The Colt Army Special/Official Police and the S&W Military and Police.
These made the swing-out cylinder revolver THE police firearm.

The Colt Detective Special. From 1927 until at least the mid-60's, if you were a detective, undercover, or off duty cop, you carried a "Dick" Special. S&W didn't even try to offer an alternative until the Chief's Special of 1950.

The Colt Python. The heavy lugged barrel has been copied as closely as possible by every revolver maker since. You have to search for a revolver that DOESN'T have a Python-like barrel.

The Colt Trooper Mark III. The worlds first revolver made with molded steel parts, and intended to be "machine" fitted instead of hand fitted, and the first modern revolver to use the transfer bar ignition.
All revolvers designed since use the same production methods and use virtual copies of Colt's transfer bar system.

The S&W Model 27 .357 Magnum. While really nothing but a slightly modified standard S&W revolver, it was the idea of a very high powered cartridge in a handgun that changed the revolver forever.

The Colt .357. The world's first mid-framed Magnum revolver. Before this, all .357's were large frame revolvers. For the first time, a Magnum revolver was small enough, and light enough for every-day carry.
Also introduced the idea of a factory fitted pair of "Target" grips on a service firearm.

The S&W Model 19/66 Again, just a slightly modified standard S&W, but this became THE police handgun for 3 generations of police officers.
For a considerable time, if you were an American cop, you carried a Model 19/66.
The Model 66 convinced the world that stainless steel was the wave of the future.

The S&W Model 29. Yet again, just a modified standard S&W , but introduced the world to the idea of a truly powerful "hand cannon" with enough power to bring down bigger game.

The Ruger Super Blackhawk. There were other large bore magnum hunting revolvers before, but it was the Super Blackhawk that made the "hand cannon" hunting revolver available to the general public.
 
Walker Colt
Colt SAA
S&W 29

and I don't own any of them :banghead:

P.S. 3's not enough. I'd like to add:
Colt Detective Spl
S&W Chief's Special (and j frame derivatives)
S&W M&P
Ruger Blackhawk
 
Colt Patterson - the first practical revolver
Colt SAA - no explanation needed
S&W Registered Magnum - started the high pressured revolver trend
 
Most historically important handguns:

Colt Patterson-first revolver
Colt Walker-First magnum, and practical battle revolver
Colt M1889 first swing out revolver
Model 1900-first auto pistol
Colt 1911

My top for desireability:

Colt Python- agrueably the finest production revolver ever produced. In a 41 Magnum, but the 357 gets honorable mention

Colt 1911- For me the high water mark is a depression area National Match, all came together on this the best fit and finish Colt ever produced, Accurate, and mature design. There are other Colts that are desirable, but not all the pieces came together to achieve a total package like the NM 1911 of this era ( commercial models not the military )

Smith and Wesson- registered Magnum, Old pinned and recessed N Frames fall right behind this.

I look back on this list and it truelly pains me to leave some guns out, and some would probably question why a couple even made my list, ex: a Model 1900 auto over a Colt SAA. In my opinion while I would rather own the Old Colt SAA, the M1900 ushered in a whole new generation ( still being used today) of firearm design. The 1911 really was the important gun in this development but the M1900 was first and influenced all future auto firearm designs. From the historical perspective it was impossible to hold this to 3 guns but I left off many that should be listed. Dfariswheels list has several of those important revolver milestones, but I feel although he covered the wheel guns well, auto pistols are histoically significant.

On my desireable list there are several other guns that should be on the list but I held my choices to three which means hard choices of what I want most, from both beauty and functional standpoints.
 
Some great posts here! I'd ignorantly add:

the first double-lock production revolvers to go above .44 in power - Freedom Arms preceded Taurus, but the Raging Bull really broke this market segment open.

And the new X-frame - it ain't my cuppa, but it's interesting, fun to shoot once, and does tend to energize things! John Ross has an interesting paean to it on his web site.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top