TOP 12 revolvers of all time

Status
Not open for further replies.
klover is not "clover" it's K lover:

1)sw 19
2)sw 19
3)sw 19

(since I have 3 of em) course ccw is 638-2 and it is very, very accurate and smooth.
 
Ok, I'll play.
Any three to five inch N-frame smith.
Preferably older. Model 29 will suffice for now.

The ruger blackhawk.
Spawning the really, really hot load revolution.

Most of the rest of my specific suggestions fall into one of the above categories other than....

The J-frame airweight.
A super-lightweight pocket 5-shooter with power to spare, and outfitable with CT laser grips, and quick sight picture night sights.
Not exactly of historical significance, unless you value your life, and want a small "always" gun that does the things that this gun can do.
And do so nicely.
That is significant to me.
 
Top 12 revolvers of all time means you aren't asking for "favorite" but which ones made the largest impact. Well, it is hard to pick only 3 to nominate because so many were significant.

The Patterson, pretty much the first modern revolver. The Colt 1851 and 1860, and Remington 1858 which fought the Civil War and helped tame the West. The SAA goes without saying. The first S&W M&P, introduced over a hundred years ago now and still going strong (all K-frames). The first S&W .357magnums. The Chief's Special- one of the first pocket guns strong enough to actually depend upon. The Detective Special- one more round in a pocket revolver. The Python- a legend in its own time. The M29, "it can take your head off" .44mag- legend, hunting, and for many, fun. The S&W 60- the first stainless. And many many more.....It is almost too hard to choose three to nominate.

Here is my attempt to decide which are more important:

-The SAA. Other guns certainly served with it and may have given it a run for its money back in the "Old West", but none stir the imagination today as the SAA does.

-The M&P. Every K-frame you have today is a direct decendant, and the .38spl (and by extension then, the .357mag) wouldn't be what it is today without the M&P (would it have caught on, or even been developed, without this gun).

-Chief's Special- the first J-frame. Who doesn't own a J-frame or equivelent? A pocketable gun with sufficient power for defense that is still unmatched half a century later.
 
1. S&W M19

2. Colt Python

3. S&W PC Stealth Hunter .44Mag (Green&Black Birdsong finish)
 
Historical significance: S&W Model 3: New Model Russian (1874-78) - The original centerfire handgun cartridge, the .44 Russian of 1871, in a fast to reload top-break.

Traditional: S&W 625 or 629 Mountain Gun. Big bore N-frame with a tapered tube, partial lug, etc. Use squared grips for the 'dated' effect.

Technical: Ruger Super Redhawk .454/.480. Materials choice, features, commercial production, and excellent ergonomics for really big bore six-shooters... a step ahead, albeit towards the techno-ugly.

Stainz
 
The Colt Walker/First Model Dragoon. The first really practical revolving pistols, which made all other pistols AND the sword obsolete. These convinced the world's military's that the revolver was practical.

The 1851 Colt Navy. This really generated the wide acceptance of the revolver. With the '51, the revolver became a truly portable personal weapon that could be comfortably worn on the person.
The first true "pistol fighters" used the '51 Navy.

The Colt SAA. There were other cartridge pistols, but none were more wide spread, and like the '51 Navy, gained acceptance for cartridge revolvers.

The Colt Model 1889 Navy. This was the world's first swing-out cylinder revolver, which every revolver since has basically copied.

The Colt Army Special/Official Police and the S&W Military and Police.
These made the swing-out cylinder revolver THE police firearm.

The Colt Detective Special. From 1927 until at least the mid-60's, if you were a detective, undercover, or off duty cop, you carried a "Dick" Special. S&W didn't even try to offer an alternative until the Chief's Special of 1950.

The Colt Python. The heavy lugged barrel has been copied as closely as possible by every revolver maker since. You have to search for a revolver that DOESN'T have a Python-like barrel.

The Colt Trooper Mark III. The worlds first revolver made with molded steel parts, and intended to be "machine" fitted instead of hand fitted, and the first modern revolver to use the transfer bar ignition.
All revolvers designed since use the same production methods and use virtual copies of Colt's transfer bar system.

The S&W Model 27 .357 Magnum. While really nothing but a slightly modified standard S&W revolver, it was the idea of a very high powered cartridge in a handgun that changed the revolver forever.

The Colt .357. The world's first mid-framed Magnum revolver. Before this, all .357's were large frame revolvers. For the first time, a Magnum revolver was small enough, and light enough for every-day carry.
Also introduced the idea of a factory fitted pair of "Target" grips on a service firearm.

The S&W Model 19/66 Again, just a slightly modified standard S&W, but this became THE police handgun for 3 generations of police officers.
For a considerable time, if you were an American cop, you carried a Model 19/66.
The Model 66 convinced the world that stainless steel was the wave of the future.

The S&W Model 29. Yet again, just a modified standard S&W , but introduced the world to the idea of a truly powerful "hand cannon" with enough power to bring down bigger game.

The Ruger Super Blackhawk. There were other large bore magnum hunting revolvers before, but it was the Super Blackhawk that made the "hand cannon" hunting revolver available to the general public.
A few additions to a well-informed list:

The Chamelot-Delvigne Model 1873. The most successful revolver of its time.

The Mauser 1878 Zig Zag. Historically insignificant, but very neat.

The Model 1883 Reichsrevolver. The bonus answer to revolver safety catch trivia.

The Merwin Hulbert Fourth Model. The ultimate refinement of a noteworthy design.

The Nagant Model 1895. The gas seal action makes it the only revolver to have been successfully silenced.

The Webley-Fosbery Automatic Revolver. Res ipsa loquitur.

The Manurhin MR-73. The most robust and accurate revolver ever made.

The 454 Casull. The first ultra magnum revolver.

The S&W 500. The last ultra magnum revolver.
 
S&W model 17 great double action 22lr.
Ruger Single Six 22lr I bet more shooters have cut their teeth on this than any other model
S&W model 29 who hasn't wanted one?

I'm forced to stop at 3. Others have already mentioned some fantastic models and the reasons for their choice so I'd underscore the pick for K frams and a J frame/SP101 size frame.

-Jim
 
1) Old Colt Python - smoothest SA/DA revolver made.
2) Ruger Security Six - toughest SA/DA revolvers ever made
3) Webley-Fosbery - The waltzing gun. One step forward, two steps back and besides, it was used to kill Stan Archer. OK, more seriously, Colt Walker Dragoon. It wasn't the first revolver (and there had been revolvers in the flintlock days), but it was the revolver that made repeating firearms possible.
 
Ya'll missed one:neener:

Elmer Keith's #5 influenced the rebirth of the single action revolver in the 1950's, and helped prevent it from fading into hstory.

I will then vote for the .44 mag M29

and the Freedom Arms Casull.
 
Only 3? Hmmm.......

OK, here we go.......


Colt SAA
Colt Python
S&W M29



Hororable mention goes to:

S&W J frame
Ruger Redhawk (started Rugers present line of RH, SRH, GP's SP's)
 
I'll vote for the premier grade FA 454 Casull. Awesome power, high accuracy, precision manufacturing, and supurb fit and finish.

Also the S&W K-22 and the Walker Colt.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top