Why do you need an assault rifle?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why does anyone need a Corvette?

Should they be banned?

There is more of a correlation between high powered automobiles and accidents than scary looking rifles and crime.
 
Oh Oh i got another one

look'em right in the eye and say, "Because my d*ck is too big to need a Porche".
 
Because you don't need something as powerful as a hunting rifle (if you don't hunt), so a small-caliber, relatively low-powered carbine is just the thing for target shooting without beating up your shoulder. And AR's are famous for their accuracy, and are one of the most popular centerfire target rifles in the United States.

FWIW, the whole "why do you need" question revolves around the misconception that the AR-15 is at the upper end of the power/lethality spectrum, rather than at the lower end. .223 Remington is the LEAST powerful of all common centerfire rifle calibers.
 
You should mention how many millions of people have been killed by thier own governments or fellow countrty men over religious, or ethnic differences
 
"Why do you want an assault rifle?"

"The same reason anyone wants the best of anything. In this case, I don't want to depend on the defense of my life and others on a less accurate and inferior weapon."
 
Last edited:
first of all Im glad that there is still discussions about the 2nd amendment in your school.I've become rather cynical about what schools teach these days regarding the Bill of Rights.

Agreed about the true definition between a real assault rifle and what has been deemed so regarding civilian models but to point out the definition I think would be pointless in class though for the overall discusson.Even western militarys who have full auto capability use it rarely.

I would be careful how I word myself in class,considering todays paranoia in schools some might start wondering about you just because you say you want one.I'd defend the position by saying you know adults that own.

I would try to change the debate from you defending yourself into a offensive intelectually.Point out that first and foremost the 2nd amendment is about defense,both personal and from a government gone tyranny.If they say that would not ever happen in America ask them if people are beyond wanting to impose their harsh will upon others even in America?Fact is given the right situations tyranny is always possible.

Point out that so called assault weapons are actually used in a small percentage in crime,and that the ban of 92 included types not considered military type weapons.Let them try to understand that peoples intent has more to do about crime than a weapon of choice.Let them understand that as long as there are people who will do harm then its a natural right for someone to be able to defend themself.

Let them understand that what someone "needs" is based on personal opinion,with anything in life.For every question or comeback that might be given to you from them there has already been discussions about it here at the forum such as "why not own nuclear weapons" and such.In all though I'd try to stay calm headed in the debate even when faced with overwhelming opposition.

And try to think ahead of time any comeback they might have for you and prepare your answer.
 
hmmm...

How about this...

...Why do you want a PLaystation 3? You already have an x-box, or game-cube or other platform, right?

Same thing...

BTW...the right to defend yourself is God-given...it's only affirmed by the 2nd amendment...
rauch06.gif
 
quote;BTW...the right to defend yourself is God-given...it's only affirmed by the 2nd amendment.

Absolutely!....unfortunately mentioning God in the classroom might lead him to detention.:confused:
 
Lots of great answers on here already. here are some less-great answers that I've occasionally used when asked why i needed this or that gun.

1. I don't.
2. To shoot bullets out of.
3. Zombies.
4. To impress my brothers and cousins.
5. "Hunting deer".
6. It makes it easier to kill people.
7. Less messy than using a machete.
8. To compensate for my incredibly small penis.
9. So I can shoot it and it will go "bang" and I can yell "yee-haw".
10. Because I'm a big old redneck.

For larger caliber rounds I like to say "in case dinosaurs aren't really extinct."
 
I'd ask them "Why do you need your PC with an internet connection/books/SUV or Sports Car/designer clothes?"

My answer? "Because people like yall think I don't."
 
First, the AR15 is not an assault rifle.

That said, every US male citizen between the ages of 17 and 45, should be in possession of a select fire M16 or M4 as the proper armament for their role as members of the militia.
 
1. I don't.
2. To shoot bullets out of.
3. Zombies.
4. To impress my brothers and cousins.
5. "Hunting deer".
6. It makes it easier to kill people.
7. Less messy than using a machete.
8. To compensate for my incredibly small penis.
9. So I can shoot it and it will go "bang" and I can yell "yee-haw".
10. Because I'm a big old redneck.

For larger caliber rounds I like to say "in case dinosaurs aren't really extinct."
Click to expand...

Those are the best answers ever! Can i use a couple of them?
 
The next time I hear a question like that I will respond, "So I can kill black jew babies! What else?" Its what they want to here.

(If no one realizes that is a joke).
 
Everytime I read one of these posts it's always the same answers, "because I want one, why can't I, or an AR-15, AK, or whatever isn't an assult rifle." I agree with all of those. However, I think we're missing the point of why anti's say we shouldn't have them, because they kill people or makes it easier to kill people. I think this is reinforced by some of the high-profile shootings, Columbine (.22's with high cap mags), DC sniper (.223 isn't a sniper rifle), and the bank robbers with AK's shooting it out in CA. All the things we like about "assult rifles" ie pistol grips, hi-cap mags, collapsable stock make the weapon eaier to shoot, carry more ammunition, or easier to hide/use. Some may scoff, but these are some legit points (not enough to ban them IMHO). Now how do you address these points besides claiming self-defense, fun, or by banning them you only hurt the good guys. When we say we need assult rifles because they're fun, or it's our responsibility, anti's and most of the general population dismiss us as gun nuts and crazies. How do you address thier points? Hopefully the answer isn't we'll never change thier minds but I have a sneaking suspicion this is probably the case.
 
Everytime I read one of these posts it's always the same answers, "because I want one, why can't I, or an AR-15, AK, or whatever isn't an assult rifle." I agree with all of those. However, I think we're missing the point of why anti's say we shouldn't have them, because they kill people or makes it easier to kill people.
Click to expand...

First of all, the antis don't care about your answer. There is no answer that will satisfy them.

I was in a debate on another forum, and the antis kept changing the rule -- the intruder in the house became "someone who has to steal your DVD player to get a fix." Then it was "A skinny, pimple-faced teenager who has to steal your DVD player" and eventually, "A skinny 13-year old who is stealing your DVD player to pay his mother's medical bills."

You cannot convince them with logic because they invent their own logic.
 
It is all about homeland security.

We have had homeland security from the writing of the 2nd Amendment of the Bill of Rights untill the present day, we just didn't call it Homeland Security.

I have stated that I use my firearms (assault rifles) for the protection of my family, myself and my community. I also use them for sport such as hunting and target shooting.

I don't believe in stepping lightly and saying because I want one or I can have them or I like them etc.

These firearms are our/your first line of defense when you are under attack. Doesn't matter if it is a robber, rapist, terrorist, mad dog, rabid animal you name it. Fire arms are as much a defensive tool as an offensive tool or assault rifle. It is too bad that political correctness etc has taken over for common sense.

Vern
 
If they ask again just say:

I need one, because you won't own one, and things DO go bump in the night.
 
It's not putting the best foot forward for RKBA, but sometimes you just have to have a little fun at their expense.

Give them the "Well, DUH!" look and say, "In case I need to assult something. ;)
 
From the JPFO book "Death by Gun Control": Hatred + Victim Disarmament + Government = Genocide.

Our society is too successful and material. Disbelief in the real existence of real hatred will lead to willing subjugation.
 
Correct me if I am wrong, but the true definition of an assault rifle is a select-fire weapon.
Click to expand...

I was asked why I wanted/needed an assualt rifle.
Click to expand...

Whenever that question comes up, I always ask the questioning person to define "assault rifle" or "Assault Weapon". Most can't, which proves they don't have a clue and are just regurgitating some propaganda the read in the mass media. If they do define it, often they refer to "machine guns" to which I explain the legal implications and severe limitations posed on those buying/owning class III weapons.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

C
  • Locked
Just a Thought
2
Replies
39
Views
1K
Shung
S
J
  • Locked
Save Assault Rifles now
Replies
4
Views
392
Sam1911
S
S
  • Locked
is an ar15 an assault rifle
2 3 4
Replies
80
Views
3K
Robert
Robert
P
  • Locked
My Grandma told me today that they need to ban Assault Weapons
2
Replies
26
Views
1K
Peetmoss
P
F
  • Locked
I want a HIGH capacity ASSAULT rifle!
2
Replies
45
Views
3K
Logan5
L
Back
Top