A lawyer told me the best bet would be to yell loudly, "I'm going to get help, I'm calling the police." Then get out of there as it technically is still a dangerous situation.
Of course, if there is nobody around to hear this (much like yelling out "STOP or Ill shoot") other than anyone currently within the house (assuming an HD situation anyway), then such a phrase may not amount to much.
It is impossible to say what you would do under these circumstances.
Well, I would agree with you in terms of what may/may not happen before and during a violent encounter. But, what happens after? Im of the assumption that (once the threat has been reduced/eliminated), another "mental mode" would take over. This would be either A). Let the downed BG lay and let God take care of it from there or B) call for assistance (not just from LE, but from a hospital). Hence, "after the fact involves, in essence, two choices. The choices one can/must make both before and during an attack are, IMHO, far more numerous.
Our instruction at my CCW class, from two former police officers, that the best course of action was to do nothing.
Im curious. Why? I mean, I can see how, say, altering the "scene" or making any impromptu decisions may prove detrimental. But, choosing to at least call for ambulatory assistance or if capable, administering aid? How could this be construed as anything but a positive?
These very acts are demonstrative of a "humanistic" mindset vs. a "live or let die" mindset. Now, I can understand if someone in this situation has been rendered incapable of anything other than shock and the ability to call for the police. But, if one can go one step beyond and at least attempt to administer aid....I say "why not?"
To the OP-
If you did give first aid do you think this would work for or against you in a civil court?
I could certainly see how any attempt at aid, regardless of whether it was personally administered or not, would improve the "shooters" reputation if ever considered by a jury.
However, given my current capabilities (or lack thereof) I would simply make one call: 911
Then, I would inform dispatch of the situation and request not only the police, but (if applicable) an ambulance as well. After that, I would essentially consider it out of my hands.