Quantcast
  1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

.40 vs. .45

Discussion in 'Handguns: Autoloaders' started by JImbothefiveth, Mar 17, 2009.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. JImbothefiveth

    JImbothefiveth Member

    Joined:
    Aug 24, 2008
    Messages:
    2,711
    Location:
    Oklahio
    I'm home sick, so I decided it's time to start another caliber war. What are the pros and cons of each? I think the .40 can go through barriers better, and the .45 is bigger. I'd probably be using a sub-compact, so I'm not sure if either would have enough velocity for the hollowpoints to work. If it does, I'm not sure if the .45 or .40 would be better.

    Thanks.
     
    Last edited: Mar 17, 2009
  2. BlindJustice

    BlindJustice Member

    Joined:
    Jul 26, 2007
    Messages:
    2,798
    Location:
    Pullman, WA
    Howz this for a ref. point

    COmparing light weight* to light, medium weight to medium weight
    and heavy weight to heavy weight * across the 3 most popular
    cartridges available in semi-atuomatics.

    Double Tap Ammo offeringss
    These are ALL Speer Gold Dot JHP
    .45 ACP ----- .40 S&W ------ 9MM LUger +P
    --------------------------------------------
    185 gr.--------- 155 gr. ------ 115 gr.
    __ 1225 FPS --- 1,275 FPS --- 1,450 FPS
    ___ 616 Ft.lbs --- 560 Ft. lbs--- 511 Ft.lbs
    200 gr._______- 165 gr._____ 124 gr.
    __ 1125 FPS --- 1,200 FPS --- 1,310 FPS
    ___ 562 Ft.lbs---- 528 Fl.lbs --- 473 Ft lbs
    230 gr.--------- 180 gr. ------ 147 gr.
    __ 1,010 FPS -- 1,100 FPS -- 1,135 FPS
    ___ 521 Ft.lbs -- 484 Ft.lbs --- 421 Ft.lbs


    If you calculate the Area of each cartridge's bore
    i.e. Caliber and consider the
    .451 = 100%
    .401 = 78% the surface area of a .45
    & .355= 62.8% the surface area of a .45

    I have a 1911 5" Bbl. in .45 ACP
    & the CZ 75B 4.7" Bbl. in 9mm Parabellum

    I don't have a .40 S&W yet, I'd like to
    get a S&W 610 for .40 S&W or 10MM Auto
    however, I do have a Bar Sto Bbl. in .400 CorBon
    and the 155 gr. Gold Dot @ 1400 FPS
    or 165 gr. Hornady XTP @ 1350 FPS in stock.

    Pick your poison

    Randall -
     
  3. Hungry Seagull

    Hungry Seagull member

    Joined:
    Feb 19, 2009
    Messages:
    2,167
    I feel pretty comfortable with my 230 grains then. Not too hot and not too much wear and tear.

    Im amazed at the chart showing some of the really hot fast loads unable to match a slow moving 230 grain 45.
     
  4. Hanafuda

    Hanafuda Member

    Joined:
    Nov 13, 2008
    Messages:
    120
    BlindJustice, wherever you sourced your table from, does it include barrel lengths? I've seen charts like that lots of times before, and .45acp is usually tested out of a 5" barrel, while 9mm and .40 are tested from 4.25 inch or even 4 inch barrels. Kinda skews the results in favor of the .45 ... even .75 inches of additional barrel length makes a huge difference.

    An analysis is also incomplete without looking into the effect on each caliber when fired from 'subcompact' platforms, which usually means a 3 inch or shorter barrel. IIRC, the .45 suffers most from the short barrel, especially in standard pressure 230gr.
     
  5. ArmedBear

    ArmedBear Member

    Joined:
    Sep 8, 2005
    Messages:
    23,171
    more weirdness. delete.:)
     
  6. ArmedBear

    ArmedBear Member

    Joined:
    Sep 8, 2005
    Messages:
    23,171
    Don't mistake ft-lbs. for effectiveness.

    Even if they have the same energy, smaller, lighter rounds don't do what bigger ones will -- because the equation changes as soon as the bullet leaves the air and hits the target, and it favors heavy bullets.

    Velocity burns off really fast when you hit something with a light object, going fast. Something big and heavy, going slower, tends to keep going. Consider hitting a cantaloupe with a 3/4" dowel, as fast as you can whack it. Then hit it with a baseball bat at a slow leisurely swing speed. Which will be more likely to bust the cantaloupe?

    Small-diameter, high-speed rounds can penetrate car doors better, and you can fit smaller rounds in a smaller gun. These things make them useful.

    These things don't make them big, and don't make them heavy.
     
  7. mljdeckard

    mljdeckard Member

    Joined:
    Jun 5, 2006
    Messages:
    12,769
    Location:
    In a part of Utah that resembles Tattooine.
    I only use full-size autos, I prefer to make the ammo perform as intended. But if I did get a smaller-frame auto, I would look at smaller bullets, as they were designed to give similar velocity from shorter barrels.

    Nothing I know of beats a 230 gr HST from a full-size frame.
     
  8. JImbothefiveth

    JImbothefiveth Member

    Joined:
    Aug 24, 2008
    Messages:
    2,711
    Location:
    Oklahio
    No, it needs to be a sub compact. This might be the only .40 or .45 I will have for a while.
     
  9. mr.trooper

    mr.trooper Member

    Joined:
    Mar 9, 2005
    Messages:
    1,829
    Location:
    Midwest
    1,010 fps Is VERY hot for a 230 grain 45 acp. Factory ammo is more like 850.

    DEFENSIVE factory ammo in a 185 grain 45 acp is more like 1,000 and not 1,225.

    Factory ammunition for 40S&W lines up with the numbers on the above chart very well. The 45 acp is VERY hot, and very skewed. As far as factory ammo is concerned, 40 S&W is significantly more powerful than either 45 or 9mm.
     
  10. BlindJustice

    BlindJustice Member

    Joined:
    Jul 26, 2007
    Messages:
    2,798
    Location:
    Pullman, WA
    Hanafuda, the numbers are from the Double Tap online 'catalogue'
    I tried to get the highest nubmers for each example but I will go back
    and double check and list the platforms. list barrel length as well.
    for each of the values listed. & will when I get time and
    re-post it however, I have a Doctor's Appt. this afternooon.
    FWIW - DT usually uses Glocks for semi-autos, and I'm pretty
    sure that's what they used for each of the cartridges listed.

    Armed Bear - FWIW, I just listed the ft lbs. because it was available
    I'm not a believer of just kinetic energy i.e. ft. lbs being a good
    iindicator of effectiveness. I forget which law of motion is the one that
    states the heavier the object the more resistance to slowing down, but you can't beat rules of physics.
    Isn't the simple formula for a measure of
    momentum = bullet weight X vlocity \
    ( no squaring of the velocity like KE ? )

    IF so, somebody list it and i'll add that to the
    chart as well.

    Randall
     
  11. ArmedBear

    ArmedBear Member

    Joined:
    Sep 8, 2005
    Messages:
    23,171
    BlindJustice, sorry if I implied that you were a believer in that.:)

    I meant to respond to the posts that implied that ft-lbs. = effectiveness, and as mr. trooper shows above, this misconception continues.
     
  12. BlindJustice

    BlindJustice Member

    Joined:
    Jul 26, 2007
    Messages:
    2,798
    Location:
    Pullman, WA
    Mr. Trooper,

    I choose to carry in .45 ACP the DT 200 gr. - out of my 625 5" Bbl. the
    recoil perceived/judged is just a bit more than
    a load I have chrono'd 200 gr. SWC @ 1,025 FPS>

    As far as the 1225 for DT 185 gr. - CorBon claims
    1150 for it's same weight bullets but they only list BBl. Len.
    & not a specific platform. Sometime this spring I'll get
    out in the country to the friend that has a chrono
    and see what I have on hand chronos out of my .45s.

    FWIW - the DT 9mmx19 147 gr. @ 1135 fps. is very accurate
    & controllable in my CZ 75B.

    R-
     
  13. mr.trooper

    mr.trooper Member

    Joined:
    Mar 9, 2005
    Messages:
    1,829
    Location:
    Midwest
    Oh im sure its good ammo; i just wanted to point out that these are very hot hand loads, and do not reflect what 99% of shooters use.

    I used to hand load 200grain FMJs to just under 800fps out of my Full sized 1911. They cycled reliably, and recoil was lighter than many 9mms. But I was reloading for economy, not power. I was getting over 1,500 rounds out of a single pound of powder. :)
     
  14. JImbothefiveth

    JImbothefiveth Member

    Joined:
    Aug 24, 2008
    Messages:
    2,711
    Location:
    Oklahio
    If I used a .45 ACP, I would probably use 200 or 230 grains. Would those reach the required velocity out of a subcompact?

    Also, it would probably be a glock if that matters.
     
  15. mr.trooper

    mr.trooper Member

    Joined:
    Mar 9, 2005
    Messages:
    1,829
    Location:
    Midwest
    probably not. As stated, those velocities are likely from a 4.5-5" barrel.
     
  16. BlindJustice

    BlindJustice Member

    Joined:
    Jul 26, 2007
    Messages:
    2,798
    Location:
    Pullman, WA
    The Double Tap numbers posted
    platforms
    .45 ACP 1911 5"
    .40 S&W Glock 23 4"
    9mm Luger Glock 17 4.4"

    Here's the SPeer tables data combined in the same way
    as my presentation of the Double Tap Ammo.
    * More on Bbl. Len. at Bottom

    Source -Speer Handgun Ballistics
    These are ALL Speer Gold Dot JHP
    .45 ACP ----- .40 S&W ------ 9MM Luger
    --------------------------------------------
    --- 5" ------------ 4" ---------- 4" ---
    ----------------------------------------------
    -- 185 gr.------- 155 gr. ------ 115 gr.
    __ 1050 FPS --- 1,200 FPS --- 1,210 FPS
    ___ 453 Ft.lbs --- 496 Ft. lbs--- 374 Ft.lbs
    -- 200 gr.+P____ 165 gr._____ 124 gr. +P
    __ 1080 FPS --- 1,150 FPS --- 1,220 FPS
    ___ 518 Ft.lbs---- 484 Fl.lbs --- 410 Ft lbs
    --- 230 gr.------ 180 gr. ------ 147 gr.
    __ 890 FPS __ 1,025 FPS --- 985 FPS
    ___ 404 Ft.lbs -- 420 Ft.lbs --- 317 Ft.lbs


    So, SPeer also uses the 5" Bbl. len. - I this isn't to
    give the .45 ACP cartridge advantage, but just as DT does
    the company presents to information to the largest
    percentage of platforms on the market for that cartridge
    which is why they're using 4" for .40 S&W and the 9mm Luger
    cartridges.

    * Some say DT doesn't load their .40 S&W as hot as other
    cartridges because the company started off loading
    10mm Auto to full power loads. That a company might
    do this could be backed up when you look at Cor Bon's
    10mm Auto offerings, who some say are watered down
    because Peter Pi & the Company wants to promote the
    .400 CorBon - draw your own conclusions.

    I don't classify, Double Tap, Buffalo Bore, CorBon as
    Hand loads.

    Anybody hear of the new Buffalo Bore offering in
    .45 Auto Rim? 200 gr. SWC @ 1200 FPS talk about HOT!!!

    FWIW - I have .45 Auto RIm with new Starline cases and the
    Leadhead 200 gr. hardcast cusom load on m y spec. to
    1,-25 FPS by Reeds Ammo & Research Oklahoma City OK.
    In my 625 5" Bbl. 45 oz empty, it has a bit more recoil than
    WWB 230 gr. JHP.

    Randall - Doc sez I'm gonna live, woot.
     
  17. JImbothefiveth

    JImbothefiveth Member

    Joined:
    Aug 24, 2008
    Messages:
    2,711
    Location:
    Oklahio
    I found that a 180 grain federal hydra-shock will go about 964 FPS out of a g27, according to a table I found. Is that enough for it to work?
    In .357, a Corbon 125 grain JHP will go about 1320 FPS out of a subcompact, is that enough for it to work?
    A +pressure 200 grain Corbon JHP will go 930 FPS, will it work at those velocities?
    And finally, will a semi-auto lose energy compared to a T/C? If so, those tables aren't valid.
     
  18. EHL

    EHL Member

    Joined:
    May 7, 2008
    Messages:
    647
    Location:
    Tulsa OK
    instead of doing all of this math and numbers tables to figure out whether a specific load will "work" why don't you just go and test some out in some water jugs, wet packs, ballistic geletin, or heck, a side of beef. I'll take the info of how a bullet works with my own eyes over what some guy in a lab coat paid by the bullet company to give favorable results, any day of the week. I've tested my own carry ammo in alot of these testing methods and I've tried from point blank range with the shortest barrel I've got to make sure this sucker will "work" for me in a SD situation.
     
  19. earlthegoat2

    earlthegoat2 Member

    Joined:
    Aug 28, 2008
    Messages:
    4,514
    Location:
    SE GA
    yawwwwwwn,

    both will kill
     
  20. JImbothefiveth

    JImbothefiveth Member

    Joined:
    Aug 24, 2008
    Messages:
    2,711
    Location:
    Oklahio
    I can't shoot them, because I don't own either of them. I was wondering if anyone knew what velocity was needed for certain hollowpoints to work.
     
  21. LightningCrash

    LightningCrash Member

    Joined:
    Jan 26, 2009
    Messages:
    60
    Side of beef?! That's a brilliant idea.
    Homeland here had beef ribs on sale for $1.50/lb.

    I wonder if my gun range will let me put it on a target hanger.
    You may be on to something.
     
  22. MDW GUNS

    MDW GUNS Member

    Joined:
    Mar 6, 2004
    Messages:
    381
    Location:
    Maine USA
    Ahhhhhh, best caliber is anyway the .357 SIG! :neener:
     
  23. Deanimator

    Deanimator Member

    Joined:
    Mar 30, 2006
    Messages:
    10,916
    Location:
    Rocky River, Ohio
    .45 is easier to shoot because the recoil is less sharp.

    It's easier to have a gun amenable to smaller hands in .40. Double column, double action guns in .45acp tend to be too big for small to average hands. I won't buy a gun that I can't accurately shoot one handed if necessary.

    If you can properly control them, either will do.
     
  24. BlindJustice

    BlindJustice Member

    Joined:
    Jul 26, 2007
    Messages:
    2,798
    Location:
    Pullman, WA
    FWIW - I did some testing using old magazines - cars & motorcycles
    NOT ( gasp ) old Guns & Ammo. I stacked them vertical
    with the spine down in a box open ends up, and wrapped the box
    with Duct tape so it held together after soaking it completely
    and letting it sit overnight. I doeused it again before we went
    out to the proverbial 'gravel pit.'

    I had a friend bring his 6" Bbl. .357 Mag. and I had
    my 625 5" BBl. .45 ACP and a 617 for pllinking
    It was a couple of years ago and I've lost the email
    I wrote up about the results but as best I recall

    .45 ACP
    CCI Blazer 200 gr. JHP
    Winchester 230 gr. FMJ Yellow box
    WInchester 230 gr. JHP Yellow box
    Remington 186 gr. JHP
    CorBon +P 165 gr. @ 1250 FPS
    CorBon +P 185 gr. @ 1150 FPS
    & .357 Mag. was some 125 gr. JHP

    Shot one of each in spots separated
    then we picked up the box, shot a bunch of
    pop cans, and water fulled liquid detergent
    bottles which had such hard thick plastic they
    werten't too spectacular, the bullets just punched
    through. Anyway the next day the magazines
    had dryed out some so I placed it so the side I had
    shot was up, and cut the box away, peeling off one
    magazine at a time, retrieving bullets

    So the results for each...
    .45 ACP
    CCI Blazer 200 gr. JHP
    penetrated about 9 magazines but not
    much deformation of the jHP = cheap target ammo
    Winchester 230 gr. FMJ Yellow box
    14 magazines, & about the same as the Blazer
    = not much more than the bullet dia. 'wound channel' (WC)
    WInchester 230 gr. JHP Yellow box
    This one ended up the winner 13 magazines, and nice mushroom
    with good percentage of weight retention
    Remington 186 gr. JHP
    About 11 magazines deep but it had mushroomed more
    CorBon +P 165 gr. @ 1250 FPS
    CorBon +P 185 gr. @ 1150 FPS
    Theese two had a big honking start to the WC but the
    bullets looked like a mushroomed wiry tangle and less than a
    third of weight retention and stopped after 7-8 maggazines.

    & .357 Mag. was some 125 gr. JHP I think it was Federal Hi-Shok.
    About 12 magazines deep and good expandion
    so it was a good basebline to confirm the WIn 230 gr. JHPs

    I should try this again because since then I've fgot the 1911,
    a CZ 75B in 9mmx19 and a 686 4" and 60 3" in .357 Mag.

    Randall
     
  25. EHL

    EHL Member

    Joined:
    May 7, 2008
    Messages:
    647
    Location:
    Tulsa OK
    The problem is that different hollowpoints will react differently to barrel lengths, velocities, clothing that the perp was wearing, and distances from the barrel to the target. Take for instance the Hydra shoks; they have a reputation of not expanding due to their propensity to get clogged up. (they aren't the only ones that do this though) The new Hornady Critical defense rounds have flex tips that supposedly address this problem. But the best advice I could give would be to make the small investment of testing out the bullets you're interested in on your particular handgun. If you are fortunate enough to have a common firearm like a 1911 or a Glock you will easily find reports from others who have tested ammo with these guns. There are plenty of websites that are run by independant gun guys who test out the various ammunitions and report their findings, albeit an amatuer finding but an honest one nonetheless. There are several agencies that use particular brands of ammo because they have been thoroughly tested for combat reliability as well. Looking at the stuff they use and investigating that bullet is a great start. Winchester Ranger, Federal HST, both have solid reputations with law enforcement because they WORK. I can vouch for both of those brands because I've tested them at point blank range on various testing materials and they not only expand and keep their weight, but they penetrate beautifully. (12 inches on average from a 3" barrel both bullets being 230 grain)
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page