All Out Caliber War! .38Spl vs 9mm vs .40S&W vs .45ACP vs .41Mag

[Valkman]

I've discovered the ultimate "carry gun" (for agony) is Ruger SBH in .454 (bandolier holster required).

Finally, someone who knows his stuff! 7 1/2" barrel, carried Mexican style! Until the 4" S&W .500 gets here, anywho. Is there a VM2 for that?

 

[Majic]

Now everyone of yall know the .22lr beats out all the cartridges even if you added them all together.

 

[Handgunr]

gotta agree with Doc', the Maximum is nasty (been married to it for 20yrs)

Oh, .......calibers listed ?

Auto-10mm............revolver, .44Mag.

Bob

 

[gibson45acp]

.357 snubby tucked in pants
XD45 with 14 rounds of 45acp Cor-bons -right holster
glock 19 w 15 rounds on left holster
mini-14 (i'm from Cali) with 40 round mag in hands

 

[FM2Wildcat]

.357 Magnum backed up with a .38 Super.

 

[Deer Hunter]

12 gauge double sawed off PGO in a shoulder holster rig for the win!

 

[DWARREN123]

To put my penny and a half in. "THE 32 H&R MAGNUM"!

 

[Cousin Mike]

.600 Nitro Express... all day every day.

Because anything less is for pussies!

 

[Skywarp]

10mm the round designed by God himself.


If you disagree you're going to hell.


Now you can't argue. Hellfire awaits those who disagree with me.

 

[Spencer]

TWOTWENTYTHREE

 

[10-Ring]

Best for me?? 45 acp of course

 

[Mike_in_OC]

for CCW I use the G23 .40,

for SHTF I would strap on the G17 with about 5 17rd mags ready to go.

 

[1man]

I'll throw a another 45acp in the mix!

 

[screamin eagle]

I vote .45 cause it's short and fat like me and the 9mm makes me

 

[Ben Shepherd]

Well, out of your choices, the 41 won't be beat. Did I mention that for me one of my 41 redhawks is the most accurate revolver I own? Shoots pretty flat clear out to 200 yards with a good handload.

Now if we want a testoterone drippin' muscle war, screw it, I'm bringin the 454, the heck with all the whimps you're bringin' to the fight!

 

[denfoote]

YAWN!!!!!

 

[Ben Shepherd]

Denfoote: You're off topic a little, but I'll play:

EVERYONE knows it's gotta be an estwing!!!

 

[FastMover]

a dull Case XX Trapper with a broken tip!!!

 

[telomerase]

There's an isotope of Californium with a critical mass of around ten grams. Only the .45 is big enough to make this work (and then the .45 would actually have one-shot knock-down power).

 

[Black Majik]

Wow, I was the first to reply two years ago!


... My opinion still stands...

 

[MrPoker]

knows it's gotta be an estwing

Yup but it has to be the 20 oz

 

[kmrcstintn]

me likes da medium calibers...

.38 spl, .38 spl +p, .357 mag, 9mm, 9mm +p
_____________________________________

Smith & Wesson 642--.38 spl & .38 spl +p

Smith & Wesson 19--.38 spl & .38 spl +p & .357 mag

Beretta 9000S--9mm & 9mm +p



planned renovations:

Ruger GP100--.38 spl & .38 spl +p & .357 mag.
Armscor M200*--.38 spl & .38 spl +p

*this is a revolver that is made in the Phillipines by a company that makes 1911's and revolvers on older Colt machinery using Colt original specs--the M200 resembles and is a licensed copy of a Colt .38 spl police style revolver

 

[wabbitkillr]

10mm For light weight/concealability(Glock 29).44mag for the hipster.
Oh yea,357's rule!
P.S. 9mm's Suck. 40's are the weak-wristed choice of 10mm.

 

[SFvet]

Good 'ol 20MM

 

[MCgunner]

If you can't get it done with the .22 LR, you just don't know how to shoot. The .22 had killed more deer than any other caliber, so what's killing a man to THAT?