America, the experiment ,has failed?

Status
Not open for further replies.
"We got problems folks -- my head's nowhere near the sand -- but I ain't giving up yet. The pendulum's swung a bit too far for our taste...

...but it is a pendulum."

Thank you. Short and to the point.

"The rhetoric of defeat" => seems to be an increasingly popular lifestyle. JT

______________________________

"The claimed "separation," while perhaps not a fantasy, is certainly a fiction and may indeed be a perceived fantastic development never intended by the Founders."

How true. Mr. Jefferson had specific ideas about separation and why it was needed. These ideas were based on the place of the Anglican Church in colonial Virginia and were aimed at eliminating the right of the Church to collect taxes, outlaw other religions and impose penalties. It had nothing to do with banning the word GOD from use on public property. JT
__________________________

http://usinfo.state.gov/usa/infousa/facts/democrac/42.htm

"BACKGROUNDER ON THE VIRGINIA STATUTE FOR RELIGIOUS FREEDOM

In Virginia, the American Revolution led to the disestablishment of the Anglican Church, which had been tied closely to the royal government. Then the question arose as to whether the new state should continue to impose taxes to be used for the support of all recognized churches. The proposal had a number of supporters who, even if they no longer accepted an established church, still believed that religion should be supported by the public purse.

For some Virginians, however, imposing religion on people smacked of tyranny. Thomas Jefferson and James Madison, both of whom would later be president of the United States, argued that religious beliefs should be solely matters of individual conscience and completely immune from any interference by the state. Moreover, religious activity of any sort should be wholly voluntary. Not only did they oppose taxing people to support an established church, but they also objected to forcing people to pay taxes even for their own church. To Jefferson, a high wall of separation should always keep church and state apart.

Jefferson drafted the following measure, but it was Madison who skillfully secured its adoption by the Virginia legislature in 1786. It is still part of modern Virginia's constitution, and it has not only been copied by other states but was also the basis for the Religion Clauses in the Constitution's Bill of Rights. Both men considered this bill one of the great achievements of their lives, and Jefferson directed that on his tombstone he should not be remembered as president of the United States or for any of the other high offices he held, but as the author of the Declaration of Independence and the Virginia Statute for Religious Freedom, and as the founder of the University of Virginia."
 
Much of the rest of the world despises the immoral culture (in their view) we export to them. As a result, a minority of one of the world's major religions, Islam, declared war on us decades before we really acknowledged we were at war. The events of 9/11 removed all doubt that we're profoundly hated by a fairly large group of people, who consider killing innocent women and children moral and ethical because all those women and children are infidels, and therefore not innocent (in their view).

Those events inevitably led to a sharp reaction by the US government in the form of reduced freedom for US citizens, and most citizens embrace these reduced freedoms, because we've forgotten Franklin's admonition, "They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety." That's as complete a rejection of the nanny state as you'll ever hear.

In short, if the terrorist's goal was to change us, they've already succeeded. We're not as free as we once were.

We've not really changed in any way they'd care about, however. To do that, we'd need to subscribe to their morality, and that hasn't happened yet. So we're still just as much worthy of death.

I think 9/11 really showed us just how strong we are: our strength might be a mile wide but only an inch deep. Three buildings and a field were struck by passenger jets and our economy teetered for quite a while.

The nightmare scenario would be for those who hate us to acquire 5-6 nukes and detonate them simultaneously, as al Qaeda is wont to do. The Russians claim all their tactical nukes are accounted for, but others claim differently. But if they simultaneously detonated in DC, NY, Boston, Philly, LA & SF, there would be chaos for a while, inevitably followed by either martial law or anarchy, or both. TEOTWAWKI.

But whether it's slowly, one freedom at a time, or quickly, with simultaneous nuke detonations, it don't look good for the home team.
 
I think most of the folk on this forum will outlive the American Republic. Our political process has become insulated from public outrage and we are laboring under the burden of imperialistic foreign policy-- without the advantages of outright imperialism.

Our society is too individualistic, but at the same time too dependent upon others-- we believe that society owes us a living but that we do not owe society anything ourselves.

Best we can hope is that the crash doesn't do too much damage and that the society we build from the ruins is better.
 
I think everyone should read "Atlas Shrugged" by Ayn Rand.

Oooo is that a new book?:rolleyes:

Sorry for the sarcasm, I agree everyone should read it once.

All the libertarians and objectivists voting third party are hastening the state looking more like the one in her book(s).

You guys, we need to get in control of the existing party structure.
 
Not a bad read...for fiction. Or is it science fiction? Fiction or science fiction - that's a good topic for a freshman year essay question.

John
 
FDR's New Deal really started the ball rolling. Since then it is just pickin up steam. But you will never convience any one with a left ward bent that he did not make it better. New and appproved Republic with the new and approved false interpretation of the Commerce Clause.
 
I used Putin as an example to make people's head spin. Putin is the ex-KGB equivalent of Pat Buchanan in one way: You probably don't agree with 50% of what he thinks/feels/believes, nor his methods, but you do feel he loves his country, and puts it first. A sorely lacking quality today.

JohnBT, you make an excellent point.

I don't have the quote in front of me (paraphrasing here), but "If my neighbor worships no god or 20 gods, it neither picks my pocket nor breaks my leg" sums up Jeffersons view.

And I agree.

Except if my neighbor has 5 children out of wedlock, or earns little enough to qualify for the EITC, or is a politician, or a lobbyist, or Walmart (BigCorp du jour), or ...on and on it goes...

It's not that the law is no longer blind (if it ever was), it's that whom one is, whom one knows, and which "tribe" (special interest group/caste/class) one "belongs" to does make an increasingly large difference in how much our pockets are picked, or legs broken. I didn't use "tribe" as an accident, I really see the country going tribal in many ways.

I am afraid I don't believe the system can "self correct". Enough bad precedent has occurred to justify (legislatively/judicially/executively) just about anything being "legal" or "illegal", or even "both" at the same time.

I remember a quote about government being like fire... just enough to warm the hands... today it's a forest-fire.

I have only slightly more faith in the voters to see past the current hydra that is the Dem/Repub party, and start actually making a difference by voting 3rd party. FWIW, i'm in that camp now and if my vote, dollars, and my voice is all I have, then I will use them all to effect positive change, to whatever degree I can.

It is only the watchdog that fails if the prize is stolen. The idea of America and its founding documents are the prize, and if we value them, we better start barking and baring teeth.

Pessimist? Sure. Quitter? Nah, I like this place too damn much to be driven from it.
 
A great song...

The New American Way
Lyrics/Music: Dropkick Murphys
The punishment no longer fits the crime


Each day when I wake up and I set my best foot forward I'll make an effort to be all that I can be. I take a look around me and I wonder how things change so much in the few short years since I was a young boy.

Do you know what we're fighting for? I know in an instant I could lose everything I'm working toward.

Chorus:
I know I'll win my battles though I fear we'll lose the war to the new American way.

The morals of this nation's youth have long gone astray lead by tolerance, indifference, and this kinder gentler way that has corrupted and destroyed so many of our boys and girls oh lord I start to wonder will it ever come around?
 
Want to save America?

Think recalls and impeachments. All branches. Think terminations. Bureaucracy.

Do it or lose it.

Those elected to use such power would have to admit the failure of their own institutions. The Senate can't even entertain, let alone pass a rules change. The Legislative branch will not challenge the Judicial, because it wouldn't be dignified, they live in glass houses, and most of them are also lawyers. What they will do is take partisan shots at the Executive. If you look closely, you will often find the grandstanding questions coming from former prosecuting attorneys. Appearing righteous and accusatory is a facade. The goal is to undermine an opposing political party, more about gaining and retaining power. Of course, some of them are running for [higher] office and have to be critical. Few that succeed actually make any substantial changes.

What you propose would require either a revolution or a nationwide campaign to promote the idea of voting against all incumbents and why that is justified. The problem there of course is that you have to be careful what you wish for, dependent upon good candidates as challengers.
 
Last edited:
What you propose would require either a revolution or a nationwide campaign to promote the idea of voting against all incumbents and why that is justified. The problem there of course is that you have to be careful what you wish for, dependent upon good candidates as challengers.

The unlikeliness of my proposal is precisely its charm: we need a general consciousness-raising to save this nation. I suspect it will come from the Web and talk radio, a true "new age" revolution.

What I know, and I think you know, is that if we continue on the current course, as hapless and helpless bystanders to what becomes more of a political circus by the day, we are finished. Suffrage--I mean regular elections--is just the last opportunity for rank mischief by the pols; that way does not lie salvation.

Not every incumbent needs to go. What we need is to make those who have subverted and lacerated this nation with impunity--the legislators and judges--afraid of the people's righteous wrath. We should try to do this using the legitimate vehicles of redress that exist. And see what happens.

Something like this, if it caught fire, just might really turn things around. It may be our last real shot before our options dwindle to nothing.
 
Not every incumbent needs to go. What we need is to make those who have subverted and lacerated this nation with impunity--the legislators and judges--afraid of the people's righteous wrath. We should try to do this using the legitimate vehicles of redress that exist. And see what happens.

In my 60+ years I have never seen so much corruption(my opinion) in our political system,it appears greed and corporate america rules our overnment. The change now may be painful but if something is not done the long term outlook will be worse.
 
Are countries such as the Netherlands, Switzerland, Great Britain, and the Scandinavian nations "failed experiments"? No. They may not be perfect, but they all seem to be acceptable places to live. They all once had their moments in the sun, but eventually yielded their place to other nations. Those responses that talk about the natural life and death of countries are on to something. Just because the United States cannot be the greatest superpower on earth forever doesn't mean that it's a failure. It only means that the burden of being the Mommy-Policeman-Conscience-Enforcer-Cultural Lodestone for the whole world gets to be too heavy. We'll have to set down that burden someday and hand it over to someone else.
I hope you all like Chinese food.
 
All the libertarians and objectivists voting third party are hastening the state looking more like the one in her book(s).

You guys, we need to get in control of the existing party structure.

Yeah hows that workin for the Conservatives in the GOP these days.:rolleyes:
 
Are countries such as the Netherlands, Switzerland, Great Britain, and the Scandinavian nations "failed experiments"? No. They may not be perfect, but they all seem to be acceptable places to live. They all once had their moments in the sun, but eventually yielded their place to other nations. Those responses that talk about the natural life and death of countries are on to something. Just because the United States cannot be the greatest superpower on earth forever doesn't mean that it's a failure. It only means that the burden of being the Mommy-Policeman-Conscience-Enforcer-Cultural Lodestone for the whole world gets to be too heavy. We'll have to set down that burden someday and hand it over to someone else.
I hope you all like Chinese food
Well said, well said indeed. China has had both ends of the stick several times over its history. Though it has changed governmental systems several times over its history, it has endured culturally. Perhaps it is time to consider pawni^H^H^H passing the honor of being GlobalCop to another while we get our own house in order, recoup our strength as a people and take a few lessons.

Oh, and I LOVE Chinese cuisine.
 
There are times when I wish this country would set down the burden of being Global Cop and let someone else deal with that headache.

I thought that perhaps we were going that route in the 90's, but it seemed that the rest of the world would not let us put it down. Reminds me of that line from Godfather III. I'm paraphrasing here.

"Just when we thought we were out they pull us back in."

It seems that while the rest of the world hates this country they won't let us step off the so-called world stage. To look at my Roman analogy in a different light I wonder if this was one of the reasons why Rome became an Empire. The Med was a mess and Rome found itself being pulled into various cesspools at the request of friendly and not so friendly monarchs, dictators etc. Of course there are many other factors, but it is a possibility.
 
"In my 60+ years I have never seen so much corruption(my opinion) in our political system"

Seems to me they've always been with us. How about the whole Billie Sol Estes scandal as one example? I won't even get into the theories tying him to knowledge of 8 murders - the last being JFK's.

Here's a bit of what Barry Goldwater had to say www.spartacus.schoolnet.co.uk/JFKestes.htm

"(3) Barry Goldwater, speech reported in the New York World Telegram (24th September, 1964)

The Billie Sol Estes case is more than just a scandal. It is more than a sordid picture of favoritism and fraud. It is a study in the operations and attitudes of some of the top officials of government - many of whom are still with us....

This isn't rumour; this isn't speculation. This is on the record, tying the office of the man who now lives in the White House with Billie Sol Estes.... The interim President whose office dealt with Billie Sol Estes does not press for exposure. His power is used for far different ends, and the White House has been turned into the whitewash house."
 
Everyone on this thread is way more optimistic about the state of our republic than am I. I think its deader than a sack full of hammer handles. The titular heads of the buracratic beast (which is completely uncontrolable at this point) are an oligarchy of attorneys that give lip service to the idea of democracy thru the popular vote. Anyone who has ever run thier own business can tell you how arbitrary and oppressive the govt is. land of the free??? you can be thrown into prison for filling out a DOL form wrong and have all your assets confiscated and your wife and kids thrown into the streets. With no appeals proccess.:barf:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top