jpwilly
Member
45's Hit more of the target
I'd prefer .40 S&W. But given those two, I'd prefer .45 ACP 230 gr Winchester Ranger Talons.
Black Talons were discontinued quite long ago. Why carry 10+ year old ammo that has since been outclassed by newer offerings?
True. The .357 Magnum is about 10 decibels higher than .38 Specials... and on one sight I looked at, it beat .30-06 from an 18" barrel by a hair (noisewise).though for indoor HD use I would consider loading the first couple of chambers with 38+P - apparently the blast indoor is quite impresive, flash and bang.
Id take her to a gun store and let her pick the gun she is comfortable holding, whatever caliber it is.
There is no satisfactory solution to achieving stopping power without increasing penetration. You want one, you get the other.Anyone care to comment on the misconception(?) that .357 Magnum has a tendency to overpenetrate?
Energy is proportional to square of velocity, so a lighter .357 packs more energy than a heavier .45.Also, with the .45ACP being an obviously larger round, what is it that the .357 does that makes up for lack in size?
On the other hand, a grain of unburned powder under the ejector star won't put your automatic out of action, and the cylinder won't fall off when you go to reload. (Both problems have been reported here fairly recently.)The nice thing about a revolver is, you do not have "feeding" issues and the bottom plate of the magazine won't fall off when you are shooting.