Best revolver for CONCEALED carry

Status
Not open for further replies.
My dress up, go-to-town CCW gun is a S&W M&P series 340 with XS Sights front tritium night sight. This is a 13 oz Scandium alloy Century frame DAO revolver chambered in .357 Magnum. I replaced the small factory boot grips with Pachmayr Diamond Pro grips. I have large hands and this grip is just large enough that I can wrap my hand around it, but is still easy to conceal. Because firing this light weight with 158 grain magnums borders on a profound religious experience, I carry it loaded with 158 grain .38 Special JHP for anti-personnel use. In a pinch, this little gun is doable with full house magnums with these grips. This is an easy gun to both carry (it's light) and shoot, the shape allows a high grip that brings the hand up to the bore axis to minimize muzzle flip. The M&P 340 rides on my strong side in a leather OWB open top pancake holster. The 158 grain 38's shoot to point of aim with the fixed sights.

image.jpeg
M&P 340

Since I live in the woods, my EDC CCW revolver during the spring/ summer months around the property is a 23 oz S&W .357 Magnum 640 Performance Center Pro Series Century frame DAO revolver with dove tail three dot tritium front and rear night sights and a fluted 2-1/8" barrel. The cylinder is relieved for full moon clips and the trigger breaks cleanly without stacking. I replaced the factory wood grips with Pachmayr Diamond Pro grips. It rides in a longer strong side leather OWB open top pancake holster. My EDC loads for this one are Buffalo Bore Outdoorsman .38 Special +P hard cast Keith SWC along with a Speer shotshell. If bear or hogs are out in the woods, I dump the 38's in a pocket and drop in a moonclip full of Grizzley or Buffalo Bore hard cast 180 grain RNFP heavy .357 Magnums.

image.jpeg

640 PC Pro Series

image.jpeg

Both of these Smiths are a bit more expensive than standard production ones, but I won't quibble over price to get what I consider essential features right out of the box. I do not like S&W's standard j-frame /c-frame production sights. Can't pick them up quickly enough. I'm getting to an age where my vision is not what it once was, so I demand excellent sights right out of the box. These sights are fast to acquire and great at night.


image.jpeg
 

Attachments

  • image.jpeg
    image.jpeg
    53.9 KB · Views: 5
Last edited:
For a carry/defensive revolver, I wouldn't be concerned about recoil. In a defensive situation you won't remember any recoil & people who have had to shoot in such situations frequently don't remember hearing any noise, either. You can practice with light target loads - maybe only a few rounds per shooting session. My personal favorite is the Ruger LCR.
 
I keep thinking I want a revolver for concealed carry (even though I have perfectly good 9mms that work fine...) and was looking for ideas.
Kimber K6s is an ultimate concealed carry piece. It's well beveled and has a 6-round cylinder in the space of J-frame. You're just not to like its price. If you're a 9mm man, skip LCR and get a Chiappa Rhino.
 
This is my Model 638 along with it's DeSantis SOF-TUCK holster. Conceals very easily, holding the gun close to my body, while remaining very comfortable to wear.







 
Last edited:
I love that 640pc pro. I generally carry a 9mm now but originally had intentions to carry a dao Ruger SP101 which quickly morphed into an LCR. For my style and comfort revolvers just don't work as well for ccw but the LCR has been excellent for what it is.
 
This might be a tad against the grain, but I say that the best revolver for CCW is a K frame sized with fixed sights.
Something like a Smith and Wesson Model 65 or some such.

The little J frames are great and all but they bring some drawbacks to the table along with their small size. The biggest one for me being shootablility (is that even a word?).

I like a full sized grip and a gun that I can shoot well over a lighter, smaller gun.
OP mentioned he carries IWB so that means he can carry a slightly larger gun.

SO my vote is K frame with at 2-3 Inch barrel.
 
This might be a tad against the grain, but I say that the best revolver for CCW is a K frame sized with fixed sights.
Something like a Smith and Wesson Model 65 or some such.

The little J frames are great and all but they bring some drawbacks to the table along with their small size. The biggest one for me being shootablility (is that even a word?).

I like a full sized grip and a gun that I can shoot well over a lighter, smaller gun.
OP mentioned he carries IWB so that means he can carry a slightly larger gun.

SO my vote is K frame with at 2-3 Inch barrel.
I would want a round butt grip though. My 19-4 is square butt and with grips that extend squarely beyond the frame pokes out quite a bit.
 
I would want a round butt grip though. My 19-4 is square butt and with grips that extend squarely beyond the frame pokes out quite a bit.

You mean something like these?

mEotHNI.jpg


They're great carry guns. Plenty "shootable" with Special or Magnum level loads. They hide plenty well enough for me, but I don't pocket carry.
 
You mean something like these?

They're great carry guns. Plenty "shootable" with Special or Magnum level loads. They hide plenty well enough for me, but I don't pocket carry.

Not exactly. I need those grip frames on a 4" gun, and I would not be interested in the look of Tyler-Ts.
 
I am quite fond of my 360 chiefs special (357 magnum). It's an airweight but weighs 2 oz more than the 340. It proven 100% reliable and I find it manageable even with magnum loads. All 5 inside of a fist size circle at 7 yards in under 3 seconds. Not as fast as some but I consider it pretty good.
Fits in my pocket with a leather pocket holster I made for it, and it's small enough and light enough you usually forget it's there.
(I never forget I am armed, but you get the idea)
 
For a carry/defensive revolver, I wouldn't be concerned about recoil. In a defensive situation you won't remember any recoil & people who have had to shoot in such situations frequently don't remember hearing any noise, either. You can practice with light target loads - maybe only a few rounds per shooting session. My personal favorite is the Ruger LCR.

While I have to technically agree with your statement, I think it also misses two important things.

1. While you are not likely to notice painful recoil under stress, physics doesn't care if you notice it or not. A gun with more recoil will still be harder to control, probably less accurate, and produce slower follow-up shots than one with light recoil, regardless of whether you are conscious of this in the heat of the moment.

2. Painful shooting equates to less practice for most people.
 
Well parts availability being what it is, if one of these crack a forcing cone, my only spare barrel is a 4" but I'm glad to have it.
That would make a great project...a 4" K-frame with a round butt grip for a carry gun. In their day, I think the 4" guns were intended for open carry by law enforcement and the 38s for security personnel. The detectives got the shorter, concealed carry, round butt guns.
 
Last edited:
That would make a great project...a 4" K-frame with a round butt grip for a carry gun. In their day, I think the 4" guns were intended for open carry by law enforcement and the 38s for security personnel.

Well, you're in luck. The new 4.25" M66-8's have a round butt and a beefier forcing cone.
 
A 2 1/2 in Charter arms pit bull in 45 ACP works for me. or my LCR 357 loaded with warm loaded wadcutters and even my Sig p 238 at times
 
I've got S&W snub nosed revolvers (2.5" or less) in .38 spl, .357, and .44 magnum. Also a custom 1917 Colt snub in .45 acp.

1.5 years ago I bought a new Charter Arms Bulldog .44 special. I've since replaced the spurred hammer with a DAO only spurless one.

It is the perfect carry revolver for me...lightweight, no snag points, accurate at defensive ranges and plenty potent. It has become my favorite revolver of all times. At my age that represents more than a few.

I still like and have S&W, Ruger, and Colt revolvers but this CA one is with me daily.

Bulldog power...

413286492.jpg


413239754.jpg
 
Also, some of the S&W model 66 .357 revolvers (pre-lock) were made with a 4" barrel and round butt grip frame.

Don't see them often though. I used to own this one but traded it off to my brother. Still in the family though. :scrutiny:

383390000.jpg
 
The best gun for concealed carry is the one YOU can draw and shoot accurately using one and two hand holds, in a variety of body positions and light conditions.
Find that gun, and then learn how to conceal it on your body.
 
The best revolvers I've ever owned/own have said S&W on them, but IF I was buying a CCW revolver today, I'd be looking HARD at a Kimber.

DM
 
Weight and concealability are the 2 most important factors for me. For maximum concealibiity in summer I prefer a S&W 36. For winter carry with heavy clothing I prefer a S&W Model 10 or Model 19. For the in-between months, an old Colt Detective Special is a good choice. Top to bottom: top: S&W Model 10, middle: Colt DS, bottom: S&W Model 36.

3%20guns%20right-3_Fotor_zpspajs5fsi.jpg
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top