Just becuase there are guns smaller than a 1911, does not make the 1911 too big to carry. I was very pleased with my 5" Kimber for many years. Didn't make the move to the XD line because the 1911 is too large, just did due to other reasons.
The 1911 may not be too big...but more often than not, I find it to be far too heavy. Especially carrying while wearing anything other than belted trousers or shorts.Just becuase there are guns smaller than a 1911, does not make the 1911 too big to carry.
I find the Detective Special is slightly wider [...] and makes a bigger bulge.
You will fight as good or as bad as you train and practice.
... i am sceptical of the 1 shot drop of a 380...