Joe Demko
Member
The wound channel of the projectile should figure into the analysis. Elmer Kieth reckoned the lead round ball to be then best killer of man or beast for a reason. Round lead balls make wicked wound channels.
I've seen this claim of Keith's before. My personal experience doesn't bear it out. I've killed deer with .45 and .50 caliber flintlocks using round lead balls. I've seen a bunch more killed by others using .55 round balls. The wounds were nothing spectacular. Typically, there was less tissue destruction than on deer shot with centerfire rifles.
Can anybody link to post-mortem photos or gel photos that back up Elmer's claims?