Movies with proper gun handling

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ummm...

If you're basing what you would do in reality off of Hollywood features produced for entertainment, then I submit to you that the real fault is the failure to suspend belief for the duration of what is entertainment and not instruction.

In real life, anvils don't spontaneously materialize over people and drive them into anvil shaped holes in the ground, from which they later crawl out with nothing more than a lump on their heads. Yet this knowledge does not hamper my enjoyment of Bugs Bunny/Road Runner shows.

In real life, transporters don't exist and cross circuiting to B and reversing polarity doesn't solve anything. Yet this knowledge does not hamper my enjoyment of Star Trek.

In real life, submarine CO's do not bring their dogs underway with them, fighter jets do not shoot down the enemy with blue tipped training missiles, sonar screens do not have little dots on them representing the enemy ships, the bleeping reactors do NOT have clear plexiglass vessel heads with removable control rods in them, submarines do not launch torpedoes to the command "Fire!", and they most certainly do not engage in high speed maneuvers while launching torpedoes right and left at Godzilla in a shallow harbor.

If you're viewing Hollywood movies and TV shows meant for entertainment with a mind for technical accuracy, then I submit to you that you've missed the point of the shows.

Sit back, relax, enjoy the show and, if you must, play MST3000 to your heart's content while doing so!

(Just don't do that while your spouse is watching, too. My wife hates that.)
 
So, to what command DO you launch a torpedo??


All I know about subs I learned from watching "Voyage to the Bottom of the Sea" as a kid.:eek:

At the end of a string of preparations, the final command to launch the torpedo is "Shoot". The other command is "Snap-shot, tube 1, Mark-48 ADCAP" (or whatever tube/weapon they have preloaded and ready to go).

As you probably suspect, the second command is in response to a need for a rapid launch without the usual procedures being followed for a firing solution on the target. Typically, it's trained as a response during a another maneuver which is called "Torpedo Evasion", which is a shipwide announcement that triggers an automatic, coordinated crew response.


"Fire!" is not used because it can understandably be confused with that other meaning, which is...well, fire. "Fire" means "something is burning" and is not to be confused with anything else to a submariner.
 
Everyone hates watching TV/movies that contain firearms with me. Just the other night I was watching Sherlock with the wife and I very detailed went over why when the bad guy pulled the trigger it would be a cigarette lighter and not a real gun. Clues like seeing the fuel reservoir and seeing the plastic seem from the two halves when it was assembled.
 
Well said, Chief! Sometimes, that pesky disbelief just refuses to stay suspended...Need a stronger rope, I guess! ;)
One teeny quibble; at least one aircraft has been shot down by a 'blue' missile. Back in '78 a Skyhawk got itself in front of another plane that launched a training 'Winder off the NC coast. Fortunately, the pilot was recovered; don't know about his career, though...
 
Well said, Chief! Sometimes, that pesky disbelief just refuses to stay suspended...Need a stronger rope, I guess! ;)
One teeny quibble; at least one aircraft has been shot down by a 'blue' missile. Back in '78 a Skyhawk got itself in front of another plane that launched a training 'Winder off the NC coast. Fortunately, the pilot was recovered; don't know about his career, though...

To this day, my wife still does not want to see any Navy movies with me.

I gotta learn to keep my yap shut once in a while...

;)
 
Yeah I understand, I don't do firefighter movies either "Backdraft" sucked. On the matter of guns& movies, Tombstone, Open Range, and the best TV series just about has to be Criminal Minds, Followed by NCIS LA.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top