If you're talking about the XD Service models there's an amazing new invention, maybe you've heard of it? Its called oil, tuns out that it helps prevent pistols from rusting, also the finish issues on the new ones have been resolved...so unless you're going to go back in time and buy an NIB XD Service prior to 2006 it shouldn't be a problem.
I was just trying to say the XDs are every bit as good as a Glock pistol and they're cheaper with a supported feed ramp as well and the rusting issues of the early models were resolved a long time ago. They're durable as hell to boot:
http://springfield-armory.primediaoutdoors.com/SPstory11.php
Ruger and S&W, but now I'm rethinking.....also CZ, Beretta, Springfield Armory.......?
I've had a G22 that was a great gun, I prefer the XDs for their grips and front slide serrations. The G22 I had was one of the old ones however and was made before all the improvements to the frame had been done like the texturing and contoured grip etc.I know. I'm just giving you grief.
Glock added more support to the chamber to make people feel better when the rumors started, just like Springfield changing their treatment to combat the rust problem. Glocks can have a case blowout and so can other guns. I'm sure XDs have done it too. It's caused by something else besides an unsupported chamber and guns with more chamber support can do it too.
Don't pay me too much attention and have a great weekend.
Wish we had a range like that.Here's the REAL answer.
Almost any of the guns mentioned above will give you great service. You can't go wrong with just about any XD, M&P, SR9/40 or many of the other guns mentioned.
What one works best for YOU is an entirely different story. You need to go down and fondle them at your local gun shop. Better yet, find people who own these guns so you can actually try them.
One local shop near me has a "demo" policy. $10 for 10 rounds, with any money spent on a rental applied towards the purchase of a new gun if purchased that day. I like that.
Many of these guns feel VEry different in your hand. So again, this is really a
personal decision. They will all run great.
I think that if you can get a police trade in Glock for $299 and the glock works for you, its a deal. If it doesn't work for you, then its no deal at any price.
Go out and shoot some guns and let us know what YOU like.