Sorry for all the opinion requests, guys, but... now, Glock or XD-9?

[Steelharp]

Sorry, guys; I'm just trying to get the most varied opinions before a decision. I asked before about a Glock 17 or 21; I really think I want this one to be a 9mm. I mean, .45 just doesn't get better than in my Colt (I think, anyway). Since I will have two .45's after my Series 70, and I'll only have one 9mm (my '69 BHP; not counting my Pocket Nine in this), I believe I want a second nine for shooting out back. I think I might prefer an XD, though; those that have experience with the Glock 17 and the XD-9... which would you choose first?

Thanks, Mikey D...

 

[Mylhouse]

I'm not even a Glock kool-aid drinker and I say that this is totally a no-brainer...get the Glock. Full caps, spare parts, aftermarket parts and even racing parts are widely available.

 

[10-Ring]

I'd go w/ the XD 9. Good shooters & the XD 40 mags are readily available and fit the 9 mm well

 

[Min]

I own both the XD9 and the Glock 19. Both are fine pistols. But based on a side-by-side comparison, I determined the Glock to be the superior pistol. True, the XD9 offers features the Glock doesn't - ambidextrous mag release, cocking indicator, loaded chamber indicator, excellent grip ergonomics, cheap high-caps (XD40 mags), and grip safety.

HOWEVER, the XD9 is also quite top-heavy. That forged slide is HEAVY. Hold one in relation to the Glock 19 and you will see. The G19 has great balance. The grip ergonomics, though good, does not match the XD9's, but it DOES put the hand closer to the bore axis, which improves handling (speed in bringing gun to target).

All the extra features the XD9 offers are not necessary if the gun is in the hands of a skilled operator, which is what the Glock was designed for - down and dirty combat shooting. Glock is built on the KISS principle. You're not going to notice how comfortable the grip is when you are in a gunfight. Plus, you can use G17 mags in the G19, giving you a total of 18 rounds of 9mm in a compact pistol!

 

[Kahr carrier]

GLOCK

 

[Gusgus]

Some prefer Glock, and some like I, prefer the XD. The only way you are going to know which YOU prefer, is to try to find a range where you can shoot both side by side.

 

[9x19mm]

OK one word only: Glock

Stay Safe

 

[Gary G23]

XD

 

[Baron Holbach]

I have shot a Glock 34 and XD 9. Both guns are great shooters and totally reliable.

 

[Longbow]

Glock gets my Vote!..

...proven reliability and durability. Lots of after market parts/accessories.
The XD?...who knows!

 

[Longbow]

Oh, BTW..

Someone might mention the Glock recall (E serial #'s?), the affected units are really in the low percentage, most of them are just fine. If they have problem Glock will fix 'em. Or just avoid the E prefixed Serial #'s at all.

I know its comming, ' just want to be ahead of the game!

 

[Jesse H]

First time I shot a Glock I disliked it, couldn't hit crap. I eventually purchased an HS2000 (XD before Springfield took over) and started shooting that. Got to try more Glocks and decided that I preferred my HS's grip angle and trigger break more.

After having my HS for 2 yrs and becoming a better pistol shooter than before, I got to try a Glock21 last week. The moment I picked it up I thought, "blah." After I shot a mag full into a slightly larger than .45acp hole at 7 yards, I figured I needed a Glock.

I still dislike the sproingy trigger and awkward grip angle, but I like the shorter trigger resets and whatever it is that allows me to shoot it well. Right now I'm torn between the compact XD9 or a Glock 26.

 

[Correia]

$90 preban magazines vs. $25 post ban .40 mags that happen to hold 15 rounds.

 

[Brad Johnson]

Go to the range

Find a range that has both guns for rent. Try 'em out and buy the one that fits your hand the best.

Both are accurate and reliable. True, there are more accessories available for the Glock, but it's also about $100 more.

As far as high-caps go for the XD9, just use XD40 mags. They will hold 15 rounds of 9mm and cost from $20-$25 (including shipping). Glock high caps can cost upwards of $100.

I have both and will heartily recommend either. I have come to shoot the XD far more simply because it fits my hand better and points much more naturally for me.

Brad

 

[jem375]

Like the guy said....a no brainer......get the XD

 

[762x51]

Definitely the XD.

 

[flinch]

Having had Glock 17 and then 19 and the HS2000 (XD) there is no comparison : for safety, grip ergonomics, equal accuracy get the XD. The Glock is dated, the XD is the future. Glock better be taking a good look at the XD before it passes them by.

 

[chris93473]

get the XD

 

[Marko Kloos]

The Glock is a good gun, but the XD is equally good and has a lot going for it. Better ergonomics, better sights, nicer trigger, and dirt cheap brand new factory hicaps for the 9mm XD...as mentioned, the XD40 mags will hold 15 rounds of 9mm, and cost just over $20.

Based on all those criteria, I'd go for the XD if it was my choice. Throw in the $100 price difference in favor of the XD, and it's a no-brainer.

 

[bad_dad_brad]

I have a G19 and G17 and have been very happy with both. But the XD9 does tempt me. And if I were in the market for a compact 9mm, and I didn't already own a Glock, I would seriously consider the XD9. It is a very good value, points well, has a good trigger, and I like that loaded chamber indicator, although, if my Glock trigger is forward, I consider it chambered. The grip safety? It is a gimic, but does not detract from the gun other than you have to depress it to rack the slide - what is with that?

I think time will tell however, that the Glock is more durable. Either way, I don't think you can lose. All are good pistols.

 

[.45FMJoe]

Definately XD.

 

[emann]

I confess I traded one of my Glock's to get an XD. Never thought I'd do that but when Glock gave me lot's of different stories as far as my recalled 26 went I thought it time to ditch it and try something new. This is not a no brainer question though as both are good gun's but if someone offered me my new 26 back with the new rails installed for my XD I'd have to tell them NO! I really like the XD's but the Glock's ain't to shabby either. Try both then decide. This is the best advise you'll get.

 

[Dave Markowitz]

Both are fine pistols, get whichever one feels best to you.

I happen to prefer the handling characteristics of the XD, even though it seems to have a little more muzzle flip than a Glock.

 

[Ikari]

See what feels best to you. Find a rental range where you can get a chance to feel up both choices. I chose the XD over the Glock. The only Glock that feels good in my hand is the model 36, and that's not exactly my idea of a range gun, which is this one's primary use for now.

 

[triggertime]

When you take the Glock frame rail debacle into consideration along with the current price of pre-ban Glock standard capacity magazines, the Springfield XD9 is the obvious choice, hands down.