The Little Carbine that Could

Status
Not open for further replies.

Geno

Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2005
Messages
15,740
Hi-Point 9mm (or other) carbine. A couple of weeks back, Dunham has had a sale on Hi-Point 9mm Lugar and 40 S&W carbines. Now, I have long found these carbines to be rather odd-looking ducks. In fact, I really did not know what to make of them. I have wanted a 9mm carbine, for the family farm, for dispatching woodchucks at 50 yards and less around the barn. In these situations, a high velocity 5.56 or other similar cartridge would be inappropriate. But I can’t bring myself to expend between $1,000.00 and $1,399.00 for a Bushmaster, Rock River or Colt 9mm carbine.

I also thought it would be both fun and cost-effective to fire a 9mm carbine rather than firing high-cost 7.62s, and even the 5.56s. That aside, when I saw the Hi-Point carbines advertised for $159.00, I figured, I can’t go wrong. If it functions well, I’ll have that close-quarters woodchuck dispatcher. If it turns out to be junk, well, at least it cost only $159.00, and I see them listed for sale, used, at about that same price range, so I could sell it for little if any loss. So, I bought it.

First, I was surprised by the fact that it came with 3, 10-round magazines. I am used to receiving only 1, sometimes 2. There are also after-market 15-round magazines, and after-market stocks that take out some of the ugly-duck syndrome of the factory stock. Loading the magazine was really odd. One has to press the front of the cartridge downward to insert it into the magazine. I hoped that the way they were loaded, and by default, the way they must then feed into the chamber would not lead to FTFs.

After a through cleaning, I loaded up 100 rounds of 9mm Luger ammunition and headed to the in-door range. I ran the target to 25 yards, the farthest distance available, and fired 10 shots off hand. I inserted a fresh magazine and fired ten more shoots off hand. The attached pictures are that group of 20, off-hand shots at 25 yards with iron sights. I have little doubt that had I been firing off of a bench, with sandbags and a scope or red dot, that the little carbine would have grouped far more accurately than my sorry eyes were able to hold. The trigger was sluggish, not crisp, but it was consistent. The target attests to the fact that it is sufficient quality to be able to maintain a respectable group.

With the remainder of the 100 rounds of ammunition, I shot down steel targets at 25 yards, having fun popping four down, and then popping them back up with the fifth shot. The little carbine had zero failures of any form. Given that the little carbine maintained this group off-hand with iron sights, I rest assured that this coming summer, when the woodchucks try to out-fox-me around the barn, I will easily be able to dispatch them. Best of all, look how many rounds of 9mm I can purchase with what I saved.

Edit to add: The Hi-Point also came with two sight-options: iron sights, and a scope rail. The following website shows an after-market stock made by Advanced Technology. They show the Hi-Point with both sight options:

http://www.atigunstocks.com/installation/HIP-9000-install.html

So, I have three questions to pose to those who have, and those who have not purchased Hi-Point carbines:

1) To those who have purchased Hi-Point carbines, what has been your experience?


2) Would you recommend that others purchase one?


3) My question to those who have looked at the Hi-point and not purchased it, why did you not purchase it?

Thanks for your participation,

Doc2005

View attachment 293174

View attachment 293175
 
Last edited:
I've owned a 9mm carbine since they first came out---5000 rounds later it STILL works great (and I've never dissasembled completely for cleaning). NEVER a malfunction. None. Zero. Zip. And much of the shooting was done with the cheapest ammo I can find (Wolf or Blazer). It also handles +P+ just fine.

Probably the best money I ever spent on a gun (actuallly, a close tie,to my SKS-M and un-issued Yugo SKS).
 
Nice range report. It sounds like a winner.

I've always believed that Hi-Point's biggest problem is aesthetics. If they made the guns look a bit more pleasing to the eye, they'd be well received.
 
I've thought about buying one.

I've tossed around the idea of buying one for the safe room. Sure, there's a 12ga and a 1911 in there, but my wife isn't very confident with them. The Hi-Point has a short enough length of pull for her to use, yet will afford the pointability of a longarm at "room broom" distances.
 
1911 guy:

I'm glad you said that. My daughter likes to shoot carbines, and she loves the 9mm. The "recoil" of this little carbine is quite similar to a .22LR...seriously. And, so my thinnking, and hoping, is that my daughter will also enjoy it.

One aspect of the Hi-Point carbine that really set me back in my seat, impressed me, is the fact that the action is so robust. I do not see how one could wear-out this carbine's action.

By the way, Advanced Technology sells an after-market stock that is not too bad looking:

http://www.atigunstocks.com/installation/HIP-9000-install.html

Doc2005
 
Last edited:
EVERYBODY loves mine, because it's so easy to shoot accurately, even for first-timers, with the red dot sight. I also have the ATI stock, and I bought extra magazines so I can load a full box of 100WWB. I bought a bunch of cheap nylon knife sheaths, and I string them on a belt and make a bandolier...
 
Clipper:

Sounds awesome! If you can, please post a pic of it in the new stock. I think it would be awesome to have one of these in .45 ACP. I have never seen one the .45 ACPs, but I do know they were manufactured at one point. At present, I see only 9mms and .40 S&Ws. By the way, the .40 S&W version of this carbine costs about $30.00 higher, but they also come with a free red dot sight mounted (rings of course are included).

By the way, have you noted that there are not very many of these for sale here on THR? That stuck me odd. I guess people must buy them like them and keep them. Go ahead...ask me how much I want for mine to part with it. :D Not going to happen.
 
I got mine recently and plan on shooting it often, even like the original stock. Even though I like the original black I wanted to try something different to set it apart from everyone else's so I went with a Khaki color.

DSC00694.jpg
 
No doubt the Kel-Tec carbines are sharp, but I was going for "point-of-rationality", which means to get the most for the least. As I already have an AR, the high-cap factor didn't mean much. Also, as I said, I want it for short-range varminting around the barn. In that situation, I cannot use high-capacity. Lastly, the Kel-Tec warned against aluminum cased ammunition and failures. I'm not knocking the Kel-Tecs, I simply wanted to keep the thread about why people did purchase a Hi-Point, and why yet others did not purchase the Hi-Point.

What did you like about the Kel-Tec over the Hi-Point, just the high-cap, or was there more? Thanks for the post.

Doc2005
 
Just answering question #3...

Compactness makes it MUCH nicer IMHO.
If you can have Hi cap why not...?
Ability to use Pistol mags that I have is a +
I've shot ALOT of Blazer Al through it. They say not to shoot it in Glocks also...
In that T.R. pistol class I think all of us shooting Glock 9mm's had Blazer Al. (Over 800 rounds each in 2 days)

It'll (Al Blazer) jam every once in awhile in the Kel Tec, a quick tap, rack bang clears it... works for plinking.
 
Guy at the range brings his Hi-Point carbine and
lets anyone interested try it out. I will not guess
how many rounds have gone through that gun.
It is accurate and reliable, even if it looks homely.
 
Great info...thanks. It just dawned on me too..since the Kel-Tec uses Glock magazines, one can use the 10, 15, 17, or 33-round Glock magazines, and so the high cap becomes a mute point! The Kel-Tec is both. The compactness, oh yeah, right there. I am surprized that Kel-Tec prices are taht low. Any time I have seen them, the dealer didn't seem to want to deal. Do you have any pics? A pic would be a nice addition to the thread.

Doc2005
 
Last edited:
I love mine!

I actually ended up breaking off part of the charging handle in the bolt threads, so I squirted some super glue into the hole in the bolt that the charging handle is inserted into, and glued what was left of the handle in there.

Not a single malfunction, even with excess super glue on the bolt rails.....this thing is tough!
 
lesgeaux:

That looks so awesome. Where did you get that coating? Is it "Duracoat"?

Doc2005
 
No offense, but that thing looks like someone's prosthetic leg.


I'm really leaning towards getting the 9mm carbine and the ATI stock, as I cannot see paying $600 for the Beretta carbine, which seemed to have an alarming number of plastic parts...

I don't need a 9mm carbine for anything really, having two perfectly good AR15 carbines, a .357 marlin lever, a Winchester 44 magnum lever. But it just seems like something I gotta have to round out my collection. That and a 1911, a Browning Hi Power, and a .308 DPMS, and I will be done. That's what I tell myself.
 
Doc,

I bought a 995 a while back when my mom complained that her cut-down 20 ga. SXS seemed to be kicking too hard for her to handle any more. We experimented with it for a while as a replacement house gun for her. It worked pretty well in most regards but I wasn't happy with the magazine capacity.

So I got a KelTec Sub2000 in 9mm. It worked fine too- but she couldn't manage to run the bolt easily, the bolt handle was in an awkward place. And the cross-bolt safety operated backwards from the one on her Marlin .22- not good.

So we went on to the Beretta Storm carbine in 9mm. And it is fine in all regards. She can run it easily enough with the bolt handle moved over to the right side. She really likes it, and with the Streamlight TLR-2 LED light/laser switched on, she can brace the stock under her arm and easily hit what she shoots at. The Beretta 20-round magazines solve the magazine capacity issue.

That means I still have the HiPoint, though. And the KelTec too. Poor me...

I'll be keeping them both, the HiPoint because almost everyone who sees it wants to shoot it and then raves over it. Also because it is an excellent trainer and a 'sample' for people looking for an HD gun to experience shooting before they make up their minds and buy their own gun. The price is quite reasonable- most anyone can afford it. Since it's a long gun, no NC pistol purchase permit is needed to buy it (that makes up some peoples' minds). It shoots inexpensive widely available 9mm ammo and is easy to manage- the manual of arms is pretty simple. It is as reliable as rocks. Yep- it's yougly. No getting around that. But ugly is as ugly does... and it takes a genuine gunnus snobbis to kick dirt at an ugly duckling that doesn't cost a ton, that works, that costs little to shoot, and is easy to run.

lpl/nc
 
The concensus seems that the Hi-Point is as-ugly-as sin, and as-reliable-as a Rolex! Yet, a few of us also find it oddly attractive for that same reason. Here is a pic e-mailed to me by a friend displaying his Kel-Tec and others. Very nice collection...gotta love those SAs!

View attachment 293268

Thanks everyone!

Doc2005
 
Last edited:
I'm a commie bastard who bought a Beretta Storm. Arguably it does exactly the same thing the Hi-Point does (and about as well) but I liked the mag interchangeability with my pistol and the way it breaks down for cleaning.

But it costs more. A lot more.
 
Had a chance to shoot one of these a couple of days ago, and I was pleasantly surprised. Recoil is odd, I'd imagine because of that massive bolt sliding back & forth; but the sights line up beautifully as you shoulder it, they are decent sights, and it was more accurate than I'd expected. And it ate every type of ammo used without a burp.

It's kind of ugly, but that kind of performance for the price I could put up with a bit of ugly.
 
OK, so here's a (bad) picture of mine, and yes, that cat doesn't have a tail (she's a Manx).
 

Attachments

  • MVC-004S.JPG
    MVC-004S.JPG
    44.9 KB · Views: 610
Evil-Monkey:

Dang, you are evil...monkey! Evil-monkey! Bad monkey! :D No, I posted that pic for a friend. He sent me the pic by e-mail attachment, then I uploaded it for him.

I actually think it's a darned good idea. You know that's how the original "mag-pulls" were made...with tape by the mailitary guys. Then, some smart business person came along and started over-charging $6.00 for .02 cents of plastic that doesn't work any better. Maybe not even as good.

No, I wasn't smart enough to have made some homemade ones for my M1A...you can bet I'll give it some thought now.

Have a good day!

Doc2005
 
No offense, but that thing looks like someone's prosthetic leg.

LOL! That's exactly what it looks like, all right - and the black stock looks like a charred and mangled leg. The thing truly is hideous. :D

As for why I haven't bought it: I've only seen one, and aside from feeling like the stock was made out of eggshell (due to weight and rattle when bumped) and grotesquely hideous contours, the only reason I haven't bought one is because I don't really see a need for a 9mm carbine, and the metal also seemed kind of cheap and thin.

Even if my guns are made out of plastic, I prefer that the fit and finish is nice on them. The Keltec sub2000 is a little better in all respects, and is significantly more stowable for storage. Additionally, it can take a variety of handgun magazines, which I find immensely appealing.

If HiPoint can fix their ugly stock (even something more contoured like the ATI upgrade, without the draganov grip 'connector' piece, which I think is ugly) and make it mag compatible, I'd buy one simply for utility/vehicle. But currently I think I'll end up getting a sub-2000 for the car...
 
That has to be the greatest thread title I have ever seen "the little carbine that could" Perfect.....my little carbine that can is a little older, she was born in 1944 and has a sweet tooth for .30 carbine rounds :D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top