I used to get both but switched to American Hunter and First Freedom(FF) . As SquirrelNuts pointed out, the big political content of FF is always present at American Rifleman as well as American Hunter. American Rifleman has also stuff about cool guns, rifles etc. It depends which stuff you care the most. If 2 Amendment is your primary focus, then FF is the magazine. If you are interested in hunting then the Hunter is a good mag, and the Rifleman is more for the shooting sports, collecting, etc. Bear in mind that if you get other gun magazines, the stuff about the guns will be redundant. When new product come out they all write about it. Let's say you get American Handgunner and Combat Handguns, then you might as well get FF since the true gunny stuff will be covered by the former, where the latter will give you a nice emphasis on the RKBA issues.