My home invasion last night. What are the odds?

Status
Not open for further replies.

BigBore44

Member
Joined
Feb 11, 2013
Messages
4,265
Location
Oklahoma
So this actually happened last night just before I was supposed to go to work at 21:15....I call it a “perfect storm” for many reasons. But I can’t even fathom the odds. First, a little back story. Fair warning: This will be a long post so I can give an accurate representation of the events.

My girlfriend and I are both nurses. Before that I worked 8 years at a psych facility primarily as a tech but we were also our own security. I have a history of wrestling and MMA (I’m no Bas Ruten or Royce Gracie but I can and have held my own against much larger and stronger opponents) and my threat assessment skills are way above average. She was an aide for 10 years in Alzheimer’s/Dementia/Psych at the VA. So she’s seen a lot too. Currently she is a nurse at small facility.

About 3 weeks ago she got a phone call at work (nightshift) from some guy who said he was going to be a resident at her facility and wanted to know some information about the place. The longer he talked, the more sexual the conversation became. Eventually she hung up but it freaked her out to the point she came home and woke me up in a panic and sobbing. Not a good way to wake up. There has also been a guy sighted outside the facility a couple times. Long story (it will get longer) the police are involved. And she has a G2C in her purse until her Glock 19 gets here. That was her decision but I supported it. She’s a good shot but needs practice for real life scenarios.

So last night at ~20:45 I’m in the garage having my daily energy drink and a cigarette before getting ready for work. I usually have the garage door open about a foot or so to circulate the air. This night was no different. I hear a vehicle pull into the drive and someone gets out and walks by the garage. I can see he’s wearing pull on work boots. Well, we have three kids but I’m not the father. The dads both wear the same style of boots. I figured one of them had shown up for various reasons. It’s not uncommon for them to come by but it is a little late. Regardless though, I get along great with the dads. So them being here doesn’t concern me. The boots are still standing by the garage and I hear a voice that doesn’t sound like one of them say “Well would you go get her for a minute”. So now I think it’s the one of the neighborhood dads looking for his kid. We have kids over all the time because we have a big trampoline and our dogs (Male Catahoula and a female Saint Dane) have 8 week old puppies. So of course we’re popular. But again, it’s late for kids to be over. So I decide to go see what’s going on. Walk into the kitchen where my girlfriend is making my lunch and asked what neighborhood kids are here. She turns and says no one. Red flag. About that time I hear the door open and hear a guy call out “Hey where are you” Red flag 2. I come out of the kitchen and see a man standing in my living room. Immediate threat assessment kind of like Robert Downy Jr in Sherlock Holmes: Older male, no weapons because I can see one hand is open and the other is mostly failing at holding his pants up, he’s wearing 3 pairs of glasses, open denim shirt revealing tabs still stuck to him from a recent ECG, not standing in an aggressive or elusive posture. Instantly I know this is a psych patient. But he is in my home and shouldn’t be. I’m heading towards him deciding what to do and asked in a command presence voice “can I help you!?” Just then I heard another man’s voice “Jimmy (real name withheld) you don’t live here!?” I look up and see a younger (early 30’s) deputy sheriff standing at my door with a look of horror in his face. “C’mon get out of there. Let’s go. I’m so sorry.”

Now the pieces are starting to come together. I’m no longer in defend/protect mode. We get the guy outside and I walk back in to let everyone know everything is alright. My girlfriend is FREAKED out. Our oldest is in her room balling. Middle and youngest are in their rooms with the door shut. I tell my girlfriend everything is ok. She’s not listening. Ok. I’m going back outside. Deputy drives away. Go back inside. Girlfriend has burnt my dinner all to hell. Oldest can still be heard balling. I’m going to be late for work (I don’t miss work) so I call and let them know. A few minutes goes by and there’s a knock at the door. It’s the deputy and a city officer. He had come back to apologize again, explain what happened, and offers to have me fill out a complaint. Knowing he’s a psych patient, I know the DA will never prosecute. I’m pissed at the situation because I know the officer should always make first contact when taking someone to a home they’ve never taken them to before. Especially if it’s a psych patient. But I also know from experience that psych patients can take a completely random object and make up a vague yet believable story about that object without missing a beat. Turns out, that’s exactly what happened.

Jimmy had gotten into a domestic with his mother. Apparently this happens a lot but the mother always refuses to press any charges. The deputy responds and upon refusal to press charges asks if there is anywhere he can take him for the night. Jimmy says he has a place he can stay so they load up and start driving. Jimmy gave him directions to our house. Didn’t drive around and randomly pick one. He told him what specific roads to take and which specific house. When they arrived here, the deputy inquired about the vehicles in the driveway. Jimmy instantly said one was his sisters and the other was her boyfriend Jeremy. He also said they had crazy dogs. Well, my Catahoula and St. Dane were barking like crazy. We have a lot of coyotes around because we live in a rural area so it’s not uncommon for them to bark at night. And they have puppies so they’re extra territorial. We have been keeping the puppies outside at night if the weather is nice, or we wake up to a mine field and small lakes each morning. After 8 weeks we’re tired of mine fields and lakes. And they’re big puppies so you can imagine. So the adult dogs were outside protecting the pups.

The deputy also offered to get me in contact with his supervisor if I wanted to file a complaint against him. I declined. I could have. And I would have been completely justified in doing so. But I declined.

Here’s why I declined and why I said it was a perfect storm.

1. Had my male been inside, he would have torn Jimmy apart. He’s 105lbs of solidness and has no fear. But he wasn’t and therefore didn’t.

2. Had I not had a history in psych and good threat assessment skills, I would have either grabbed my pistol (that was within 8’ of me) and possibly shot him or beaten him to a pulp. I was on my way to put hands on him when I heard and subsequently saw the deputy at the door. But I do have those attributes, and I did hear and see the deputy. So, I didn’t.

3. The deputy knew he screwed up. And he was genuinely remorseful. But had I or my dog engaged Jimmy, there would be no way to avoid the report of injury to Jimmy and possible firing of this deputy. As it stood, no one was hurt. The females in the house were freaked out. But no injuries. So I saw this as a teachable moment for the younger deputy about dealing with psych patients and following procedure when taking someone to a residence. I’m still debating about calling the actual sheriff and having a meeting with him. Not to get the deputy in trouble. But because I know how perfect this storm was and how easily this could have been bad for everyone. And so he could use this as a lesson for his deputies in the future.

4. I am the grandson, son, brother, and best friend of police officers. I know how stressful the job can be. Especially today. And I don’t want someone’s career ended over a mistake that didn’t end in injury when it could instead be used as a valuable lesson. We’re all human.

But seriously, what are the odds? What are the odds my girlfriend gets these calls, has someone around her facility, that I have the background in psych and threat assessment skills, that my dogs were outside, that a psych patient comes in my house, delivered by a deputy, and that the deputy calls out at just the right moment, and that no one was hurt, or worse?
 
My home invasion last night. What are the odds?

I don't know, assume 50-50 (P=.5) for each event including having your garage door open just enough and the kids leaving the door open, I'd say 32 to one, best guess.

(1 / .5 X .5 X.5 X .5 X .5)
(1 / .5[sup]5[/sup])

You can change those individual probabilities (I'm sure some are too high, some too low) according to your household habits and experience.

Not a grinnable post, but you asked.

Good decision on letting the Deputy learn and apply his lesson in future.

Terry "Totally on topic for once," 230RN =D
 
Last edited:
WoW! Scary stuff! Apparently this sick bastard followed your girlfriend home from work one time to know where she lived. Now you have a twisted stalker on your hands. I too question in this day and time why the front door was open allowing someone to breech your families inner sanctum. Sounds like the effect it had on the girl friend and the children were immediate and lasting. That's a shame. I really feel bad for them.

I also live in a rural area and have had a couple incidents that have titillated my spider senses and has caused me to keep the doors locked at all times. The days of trusting strangers are long over for us as we go thru the day on heightened awareness. My guess is this is long from over. You working in that field probably know better than the rest of us how those twisted minds work. So, where do you go from here? Restraining order? Something on record that you view this man as a danger to you and your family.
 
I guess my question is why was the front door unlocked, especially at that time of day?
Bingo.

And not trying to be “Johnny Monday Morning QB” here.

I’m confused though. How did the patient know where you lived? That’s an even bigger worry on this whole story.
What got my attention is how Jimmy knew exactly where to go, given your job history.... kind of scary.
No offense taken by any of these questions. Well we live a small “town” with basically zero crime. It’s a country town in rural Oklahoma. We don’t lock the doors if we are home until we go to bed. We have kids in and out all day. You’d just have to know this town. It literally has one flashing 4 way red light. It’s a farming town. The teenagers say “yes sir yes ma’am thank you sir, thank you ma’am” on instinct. You’re as likely to meet a horse or Massey Furgeson at the light as you are a vehicle. My grandparents lived here for forever and my girlfriend lived here her whole life. They don’t suspect her caller to be local either. And he isn’t the guy that came in.

This actually gets even weirder. Turns out the guy who came in, is our oldest daughter’s great grandfather’s, crazy cousin. We’ve only lived in this house a year next month. And we’ve never met this guy. Even our daughter hasn’t met him. He’s the side of the family that was shunned by the “normal” side. He was absolutely off his medication. It was pure blind luck he chose this house. He had no way of knowing who lived here. Even the previous owners didn’t know him. We asked.

I know for certain I never took care of this guy when I worked psych. I don’t forget faces. Ever. I wasn’t a hide behind the desk guy when I worked. I was out in the general population hanging out and if need be, keeping the peace, unless they were asleep.

I still don’t consider this a crime even though technically it is. It’s just beyond comprehension the series of events that had to have played out so perfectly. Had he chosen the house before ours, it wouldn’t have turned out the same. Our neighbor is a Marine who did 3 tours in Vietnam. He was very lucky he gave directions to our house. He was lucky my Catahoula wasn’t inside. He was lucky I am the type of person I am and have the background I do. And the deputy is lucky for all the same reasons.

Nice not throwing the Deputy under the bus if you're certain he learned too.
I’m certain he did. I know when people are remorseful and when they’re faking remorse to save their own arse. The gravity of the situation was written all over his face and he made no excuses. I personally know the actual sheriff. The deputy didn’t know that and I didn’t tell him. I also know several of the deputies including his supervisor because my best friend was one until 2 years ago before he went to the city PD. So we have all hung out multiple times at each other’s homes. A simple phone call from me and he’s fired. I can’t do that. He learned his lesson.
 
I’m certain he did. I know when people are remorseful and when they’re faking remorse to save their own arse. The gravity of the situation was written all over his face and he made no excuses. I personally know the actual sheriff. The deputy didn’t know that and I didn’t tell him. I also know several of the deputies including his supervisor because my best friend was one until 2 years ago before he went to the city PD. So we have all hung out multiple times at each other’s homes. A simple phone call from me and he’s fired. I can’t do that. He learned his lesson.
Outstanding!

Todd.
 
Definitely a crazy moment. I’d hate to think what might have happened if you’d wanted to get to work early that night, or the deputy took a little bit longer to get to your house. The bad guy could have just walked in, told the deputy “thank you” and closed the door.

I’m not sure I’d let this go that easily. If the deputy is young and was legitimately remorseful, I wouldn’t want him fired, but this could have gone really badly with just one or two of those things not lining up perfectly as they did.

I’d recommend setting up a meeting with the sheriff. Again, like you said, not to get the deputy fired but to make sure that this kind of thing never happens again. This was absolutely the best outcome that could have possibly happened. Could you imagine the headlines “deputy drives psych patient to the home of a nurse and let’s him in the house, husband ventilates intruder”. Or even worse “deputy drives psych patient to the home of a nurse and let’s him in the house, nurse and her children raped as deputy drives away”.

I’m sure that kinda stuff has already been going through your mind and I’m not trying to be overly dramatic, but that police procedure is in place for a reason. Hopefully your sheriff isn’t dismissive of what happened.

My ex wife used to work in mental health and the thought of this kind of thing happening scared the crap out of me (even more so when I learned that somehow a convicted murderer was let into the program she was working for). You can’t expect a psych patient to behave rationally, even beyond what’s normally rational for a criminal. You just don’t know what they’ll do.

I’d try to get a complaint filed against the psych patient. Even if a prosecutor won’t take the case, it creates a paper trail in case he comes back. He already knows your address (which is concerning in and of itself). You might also be able to get a restraining order on him so he can’t just wander into the hospital your wife works for and if he does, security will have a heads up about him.

Good luck. Crazy people don’t give up on things easily, especially when there were no repercussions for them. I’d stay alert for a while in case he decides to come back.
 
WoW! Scary stuff! Apparently this sick bastard followed your girlfriend home from work one time to know where she lived. Now you have a twisted stalker on your hands. I too question in this day and time why the front door was open allowing someone to breech your families inner sanctum. Sounds like the effect it had on the girl friend and the children were immediate and lasting. That's a shame. I really feel bad for them.

I also live in a rural area and have had a couple incidents that have titillated my spider senses and has caused me to keep the doors locked at all times. The days of trusting strangers are long over for us as we go thru the day on heightened awareness. My guess is this is long from over. You working in that field probably know better than the rest of us how those twisted minds work. So, where do you go from here? Restraining order? Something on record that you view this man as a danger to you and your family.
Actually none of the above. See my reply above yours. That’s part of what makes this whole thing so crazy (pun intended). Also restraining orders mean next to nothing, especially to a psych patient off their meds. You’d have to prove he knew he was breaking the restraining order. And I guarantee he wouldn’t know. I’ve seen hundreds like him. They can get lost in an lit, empty room.

FYI, everyone is perfectly fine today. No lasting effects.
 
I’m sure that kinda stuff has already been going through your mind and I’m not trying to be overly dramatic, but that police procedure is in place for a reason. Hopefully your sheriff isn’t dismissive of what happened.
Ten thousand things went through my mind after. But I assess and compartmentalize. And I deal with facts. If you don’t, especially in a situation like this, it’s very easy to work yourself into a state of anxiety and fear. Yes, you’re absolutely right. Things could have gone very differently if only one small thing had changed.

I’m going to talk to my best friend in just a little bit when he comes by and get his take on this deputy.

My hesitation to call the sheriff is my family name. That sounds elitist. But I don’t mean it too. Law enforcement runs in my family. Let me put it this way. The chief and sheriff of my home town 14 miles away from here are family friends. The chief in the town I live in is a family friend. The sheriff in the county this happened in is a family friend. The deputies and officers in my home town 14 miles away, know my mother because she was the head ER nurse for 40 years and many of their wives were nurses under her. She also took care of the suspects or prisoners when the officers brought them to the ER. And she took care of the officers when they got hurt. Well, those officers go to different departments or sheriffs offices, or even the highway patrol. The chief here used to be an officer in my home town. The sheriff came from the city my father worked for. Well I was raised in dad’s cop car and the ER. So I got to know them also. So we have friends all over and my last name means something. I would hope the sheriff wouldn’t discipline him if I asked him not to. But I can’t guarantee he wouldn’t. And since I told the deputy I wouldn’t throw him under the bus and didn’t fill out a report, he might not have put it in his report. If I go to the sheriff now and he pulls the report and there’s nothing in there, then he is going to go to that deputy and demand why he didn’t put it in the report. So basically I just lied to that deputy and my word means nothing. See what I mean?
 
Wow. Such a lucky outcome with so many scary factors normally aligned.

And a tragic gunshot (by you) into that Intruder easily could have scared a Deputy (at the door) into shooting you ... mistakenly perceived as being in the Deputy's self-defense, or the mental patient's defense.....could it not?

Why didn't the Deputy anticipate a very deadly response?
 
This may be a bigger story than what we've read so far and what I mean by that is, shouldn't there be guidelines in place so that deputies and/or police officers will not depend on a psych patient's word but instead their instructions should be to rely on a third party ( and only a third party) as to where the patient should be taken. Further, once they get to the destination, confirmation should be obtained before releasing the patient to that facility or person. To do other than this is lunacy! Big Bore, you should meet with the police chief to make sure of what guidelines are in place in that department.
 
Wow. Such a lucky outcome with so many scary factors normally aligned.

And a tragic gunshot (by you) into that Intruder easily could have scared a Deputy (at the door) into shooting you ... mistakenly perceived as being in the Deputy's self-defense, could it not?

Why didn't he anticipate a very deadly response?
Well had my male been inside, he would have, without question, attacked Jimmy. Extremely possible scenario:

Deputy sees Jimmy getting attacked by one of his sister’s crazy dogs and shoots the dog. My dog. Now I have my dog attacking an intruder and I hear a gunshot(s) and my dog falls. Pistol is maybe 8’ away. AR maybe 15’. Well now I’m going for my pistol and I’m going to shoot the intruder without question. He’s shot my dog, in my home. He’s a threat. He’s a dead man. So as I’m putting or about to put 10mm holes in Jimmy, I hear someone either make entry into the house (the deputy) trying to save Jimmy or yelling at the door for him to get out of the house. Now I have two perceived threats. There is a 12’ entry hallway from the front door to the opening to the living room. I can clearly see Jimmy. But I have to slice the pie to see 2nd suspect at the door. Either way, Jimmy is dead. But now I’m in a standoff with a threat that is actually a deputy at the door. If the deputy makes it to Jimmy, I cannot guarantee that at the distance I’m at, I won’t take a head shot on intruder number 2 if that’s all I can see in the entry way.

He didn’t anticipate a deadly response because the story was believable. But small variance changes and this whole thing becomes an absolute disaster.
 
Last edited:
This may be a bigger story than what we've read so far and what I mean by that is, shouldn't there be guidelines in place so that deputies and/or police officers will not depend on a psych patient's word but instead their instructions should be to rely on a third party ( and only a third party) as to where the patient should be taken. Further, once they get to the destination, confirmation should be obtained before releasing the patient to that facility or person. To do other than this is lunacy! Big Bore, you should meet with the police chief to make sure of what guidelines are in place in that department.
There are procedures. The officer should at the very least accompany the person to the door of the residence and make first contact. But many Officers and Deputies don’t understand the dynamics of psych patients. It took me years of 6-7 days a week and 12 hours a day with them to learn. And I was always paying attention. I actually listened to their stories, and was fooled more than a few times for the first few years. Like I said, some psych patients can take a random object and give you a vague yet believable story about it at the instant they see it. He gave directions to my house. He had names for the owners of the vehicles in the driveway. Even mentioned the crazy dogs. All in a matter of seconds. All believable. It’s possible the officer did accompany him to the door. I can’t say he didn’t. But where he screwed up was allowing Jimmy to walk in without making contact with the homeowner first.
 
Actually none of the above. See my reply above yours. That’s part of what makes this whole thing so crazy (pun intended). Also restraining orders mean next to nothing, especially to a psych patient off their meds. You’d have to prove he knew he was breaking the restraining order. And I guarantee he wouldn’t know. I’ve seen hundreds like him. They can get lost in an lit, empty room.

FYI, everyone is perfectly fine today. No lasting effects.
The whole intent of the restraining order is to have something on record. If this escalates, let's pray that it doesn't, and something does happen.. you'll be able to at least show you took steps to ward it off.
 
The whole intent of the restraining order is to have something on record. If this escalates, let's pray that it doesn't, and something does happen.. you'll be able to at least show you took steps to ward it off.
I don’t disagree. But he had zero idea where he was, directions or not. I’d bet you my next years pay he doesn’t even remember last night. But let’s say he does. A PO won’t stop him. And as far as the paper trail, our courts that have been basically closed for a years don’t have the time to deal with this. I can tell you unequivocally they don’t. But let’s say I filed one, and he did violate it. And they did somehow get him on a docket. They won’t put him in jail. They will put him in a short term psych facility to get his meds leveled out and get him to what is known as his “base line” which means normal for him. Then they will discharge him. And the cycle will repeat itself. I know how this game is played. I saw it for 8 years. And apparently he’s lived it for much of his life.
You and your wife both working around mentally ill people , that should make you lock your doors , even in a rural county , I would think .
You would think. But actually it’s the opposite. When you’ve worked psych, everything else becomes easier to deal with. And it would stun you the number of people you interact with on a daily basis that are actually psych patients. They aren’t all crazy. Again, it’s something you have to have worked in to understand. Stories from friends or even spouses don’t give you experience. You have to be with them.

If we lived in an actual city, the doors would be locked. But our kids wouldn’t go to the neighbors house two or tree streets over, they wouldn’t ride their bikes in the road, they wouldn’t have over an acre of backyard to play in. I hate the city. She does too. So we bought in the country. It’s well over 20 miles to where I used to work. Same for her. He patients had zero chance of ever finding out where she lived because they can’t get out. Mine was a crisis center. Short term. But they could get out. Some of them were from my home town. Some of them I knew. In 8 years and after rolling with well over a hundred psych patients (because I absolutely had to) I only had one guy threaten to find me on the outside. And he’s dead now. No, I didn’t kill him.

I treated those patients like people. Not patients. They weren’t a name and room number. They were a person. And I treated them like I hoped someone would treat me. I laughed with them. I joked with them. I played games with them. I even cried with them sometimes. I prayed with them. I helped them with normal things they might not be able to do. I called their families for them. I just sat and listened to them talk about their problems. And even if I had to use my skills to protect others from them, when it was over, it was over. They were always treated with dignity. And so I never did, and still don’t, worry about them looking for me. I’ve seen some on the outside. If we see each other and they avoid me (99.9% of the time it’s women who do that) then I let them go. If they approach me, I will stand there and talk to them and see how they are doing. But I never say how we know each other. Usually, if they approach me and they have someone like a spouse with them, they will introduce me to them and tell them where we met.

When I was doing nursing clinicals we went to a forensics psych hospital. This housed people who had been found not guilty by reason of insanity. Being a male, they put me on the floor with the “most dangerous” patients. They made it explicitly clear that there were some murderers on the unit and if we ever felt uncomfortable or threatened, what to do to call for help and help would be there in seconds. It was very unlikely there would be problems but they wanted us to know what to do. When I walked on the unit, I looked every patient in the eye. I started picking out who I thought the murders were based solely on their eyes. I made a list and took it to the nurse. I was right with every single one. I spent the next 10 hours hanging out, playing cards, and getting to know them while the other students hid behind the nurses station. I had a great time. They offered me a job at the end of the first clinical. I still had 8 months of school left.

I say all that to say this. Psych isn’t what you see on TV. Psych is what you make it. Yes, psych can be dangerous. But there are always cues and clues if you know what to look for. But there’s only one way to do that. It doesn’t come from tv, books, stories, or gun forums. And it doesn’t come fast.
 
I believe you handled it well. Wife has worked public/mental health for thirty years, she reminds me that almost half the population has been or are being treated for mental issues. Courts protection means little, funding for this type of police training, especially in small communities, is virtually nonexistent. I guarantee the officer will never forget this incident.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top