Banning pitbulls: the slippery slope?

Status
Not open for further replies.

DeadCalm

Member
Joined
Jan 7, 2003
Messages
119
Location
MT
This may have been covered elsewhere, so please refer me to another thread if you know of it. On NPR last night—maybe, I like to hear the range of radio politics—was mention of a proposed ordinance in San Francisco big surprise that would ban all pit bulls. There are something like 7K of them, 6% of that population representing 50+% of all dog bites in the city. There was omething about CA law allowing neutering requirements already, but I missed that.

Banning and controlling dog breeds has always made me a little jumpy for its distinct parallels to gun control. For instance, in some communities where pit bulls are vilified, the incidents of dog bites from other breeds exceeds theirs. (Rotts, German Shepherds, Dobies, etc.) Turns out that some major cities do already have bans on pits, including Denver.

And then there's the lousy breeding factor, where you just end up with junkyard dogs. Are their owners more liable, and should you have to show your AKC papers to get a pit bull license? There are better reasons to lie awake at night than this, but it's a vexing issue. Any thoughts?
 
If you have seen me in some dog threads you know where I stand and what I think about pit bulls so it isn't worth repeating. That said as much as I think people need to stop trying to erase the breeds history and that it was bred to be violent and unless you buy from a breeder who has done a lot of selective beeding they just might hold onto that. Now that said no the goverment shouldn't be telling people wht beeds of dogs they should and shouldn't be allowed to have. As stupid as I find keep a pitbull others find keeping a fully automatic weapon equally stupid even though one has a brain and the other doesn't. So awarness YES, ban? No.
 
Not gun-related, even if there were parallels. (Which there aren't; a gun doesn't have a life or a will of its own.)

Closed.

pax
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top