Big bore fighting revolvers - a picture thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
View attachment 913738 Here is a S&W Model 1917 that was shortened for carry purposes.

Kevin
Kevin, I'll see you and raise!

I found a S&W 1917 with a model of 1950 barrel on it and the lanyard loop already removed. I always wanted a Fitz type revolver in .45 ACP and had a local gunsmith build me this. He also custom made the grips:
1917_right_after.jpg
 
I lament the passing of the Speer short bbl 44 magnum Gold dot. 200gr. gold dot @ 1,150 fps was a good revolver load for defense against human attackers.
 
Kevin, I'll see you and raise!

I found a S&W 1917 with a model of 1950 barrel on it and the lanyard loop already removed. I always wanted a Fitz type revolver in .45 ACP and had a local gunsmith build me this. He also custom made the grips:
View attachment 914168

Nice looking revolver. Had several 3” barreled revolvers and found, for me on N frames, the 4” was preferred.

Kevin
 
Last edited:
I set out to build the Ultimate big bore fighting revolver 30 years ago . I had a decent US postal service 1917 Colt New Service .45 acp and sent it to Cylinder and slide after using it for about five years and "only if" thinking because it ran so nice on steel plates and the bowling pin rage. Cylinder & Slide gave it a complete rebuild and blueprinting . They have a 10 pound DA and a 2.5 pound SA and the pull thru is amazing ly smooth, like a big Python. They replaced the barrel with a 4" Douglas Air gauged heavy barrel with a little faster than normal twist (1-14" ) for .45 acp at my request. They talked me into a custom shroud for the ejector rod and crane to lock into ball detents. They fabricated the gold flat topped bead front sight and welded and set the rear sight notch to put 230 grain .45 acp mill spec ball to be dead on at 25 yards . They then sent the pistol to Colt's custom shop engraver who did minimal Bank Note engraving and polished gun for a Royal Blue finish . Then Roy Fish Paw got the gun before I got it back and he fitted to my hand drawing 4xxx exhibition French walnut grips that fit seemlessly and points like my thoughts. I fitted up this French case and it is a wonderful joy to shoot the moon with my cast 250 grain Keith hollow points at 900 fps +_ into an inch at 25 yards sand bagged . It is retired now allways faith ful. I have another (few) .45 New Service Colts and one is a super smooth old reblued 1917 that Armand Swenson put some S&W adjustable sights on and tuned the action . That is not quite as accurate as the C&S Ultimate Pin revolver , but I carry it around in a full flap Lawrence holster banging around remote Oregon :)
Falbums%2Fi203%2Fgordonhulme%2FMobile%2520Uploads%2F2017-04%2FIMG_20170401_102332200_zps070f1c8c.jpg
 
Last edited:
I tried to love these Scandium Smith L frame hammerless jobs for years, I used the 242 7 shot .38+P for practice with the cheap .38s and only shot the hard kicking (harder than a Charter Bulldog ) .44 spl. a little to sight in with defensive loads . I had these clip rigs on them that were quite sturdy to clip into jogging suits ect. I sold them at over $1000 each a couple years ago. For a hidden defense heavy concealment revolver they were promising. but I went back to the very slightly heavier longer barrel Charter Bulldogs .
P1010501_zpsa63b6156.jpg
 
Last edited:
I set out to build the Ultimate big bore fighting revolver 30 years ago . I had a decent US postal service 1917 Colt New Service .45 acp and sent it to Cylinder and slide after using it for about five years and "only if" thinking because it ran so nice on steel plates and the bowling pin rage. Cylinder & Slide gave it a complete rebuild and blueprinting . They have a 10 pound DA and a 2.5 pound SA and the pull thru is amazing ly smooth, like a big Python. They replaced the barrel with a 4" Douglas Air gauged heavy barrel with a little faster than normal twist (1-14" ) for .45 acp at my request. They talked me into a custom shroud for the ejector rod and crane to lock into ball detents. They fabricated the gold flat topped bead front sight and welded and set the rear sight notch to put 230 grain .45 acp mill spec ball to be dead on at 25 yards . They then sent the pistol to Colt's custom shop engraver who did minimal Bank Note engraving and polished gun for a Royal Blue finish . Then Roy Fish Paw got the gun before I got it back and he fitted to my hand drawing 4xxx exhibition French walnut grips that fit seemlessly and points like my thoughts. I fitted up this French case and it is a wonderful joy to shoot the moon with my cast 250 grain Keith hollow points at 900 fps +_ into an inch at 25 yards sand bagged . It is retired now allways faith ful. I have another (few) .45 New Service Colts and one is a super smooth old reblued 1917 that Armand Swenson put some S&W adjustable sights on and tuned the action . That is not quite as accurate as the C&S Ultimate Pin revolver , but I carry it around in a full flap Lawrence holster banging around remote Oregon :)
View attachment 914300

That .45 Colt Charter arms, if it is well put together and reliable and accurate and shoots to sights is very close to "it" as the ultimate compact fighting revolver IMHO. I'm very interested with your range experiences with it !
 
Not much to offer up by me. My preference would be not to get in a gunfight. Especially with one of the singles actions

S&W 1917 .45 ACP

166278259.jpg

Colt 1917 .45 ACP

414242652.jpg

Pietta Frontier .45 Colt

414285396.jpg

Rossi .44 Special

413973049.jpg

CA Bulldog .44 special

413286492.jpg

S&W 629-5 .44 magnum/special

406740100.jpg

S&W 29-3 .44 magnum/special

412339783.jpg

Uberti Cimarron .45 Colt.

411496796.jpg

Ruger Blackhawk .45 Colt

409808882.jpg
 
Not much to offer up by me. My preference would be not to get in a gunfight. Especially with one of the singles actions

S&W 1917 .45 ACP

View attachment 914717

Colt 1917 .45 ACP

View attachment 914718

Pietta Frontier .45 Colt

View attachment 914719

Rossi .44 Special

View attachment 914720

CA Bulldog .44 special

View attachment 914721

S&W 629-5 .44 magnum/special

View attachment 914722

S&W 29-3 .44 magnum/special

View attachment 914723

Uberti Cimarron .45 Colt.

View attachment 914724

Ruger Blackhawk .45 Colt

View attachment 914725

That 1917 sure is purdy!
 
I honestly am not sure why these "fighting revolvers" appeal to me. Something about the history of the Southwestern border and the men who patrolled it, I suspect. I certainly have no desire to use these guns - or any others! - in a fight.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top