Empty hand skills - which one's right for me?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Spacecoast, you're killing me. I would've thought the training incorporated less self-harmful techniques than that. That's a warning I'll definitely heed.

Oh, and 56, old? Jeez. 56 is young. And it's seeming younger and younger to me every year.
 
Spacecoast, good advice. Folded fingers and busted ankles and knees and a busted nose (damn thing still wants to bleed sometimes) all take their toll.

Training "hard" means with effort not getting busted up.

Turning 50 in a couple of months doesn't mean much to me personally, but the cumulative damage done to this body sure does.
 
I would've thought the training incorporated less self-harmful techniques than that.
Some techniques taught can be directly self-harmful if done full force like ridge hands (elbow prone to hyperextension) or stomping/kicking with your foot turned out like your kicking a soccer ball (femur wants to go past the tibia in that case). Other training is harmful as well such as hand hardening work like in kung fu movies where they punch into sand progressing to harder objects. It works...at a high cost.

Most often though it is just repetitive use injuries from doing high repetitions of strikes/techniques year after year. I always think about risk vs. reward in my training. It doesn't make sense to injure yourself in training (or in combat) in order to avoid getting injured by the other guy. I've certainly had my share of contusions (get bruises every session), inadvertant groin whacks and mild tweaks/sprains. Nothing more serious though.

It's hard to paint this with a wide brush, but I'd say traditional MA, especially those where you do lots and lots of striking repetitions in the air and on bags and/or combat sports will be more likely to result in overuse injuries. The reality based arts (Krav Maga, Haganah, TFT, Jim Wagner, SPEAR (Tony Blauer), Southnarc ect.) would be less likely to have a long term toll like that in my opinion.

As spacecoastguy wisely said, moderation and think about what you are doing. Lots of stuff out there doesn't make any sense biomechanically...the Chinese systems are big offenders with stuff like striking with your wrist! (no thanks:eek: ). Yeah, you can ring someone's bell by whacking their temple with your wrist...but you can get the same result with a hammer fist and no downside. Same with the ridge hand mentioned above, just turn your palm up and strike with the blade edge of your hand or ulnar side of the forearm...same result, no biomechanical downside.
 
Have you looked into krav maga? By all accounts it appears to be a very no frills selfdefense technique that is all about stopping your opponent no matter what it takes.
 
Boxing, western and/or Thai, for the standup game. It is simple and effective -- exactly what the body requires when operating in condition red.

As for pajama dancing, it is safe to say that the sort of training you're likely to get at a typical pajama dancing McDojo is complete ineffectual nonsense compared to what you get a typical boxing gym.

Heavy bag work for power and wrist strength. Sparring for fight dynamics, and most importantly learning to take a punch -- stress inoculation via controlled combat.

If instead you spend your time pawing air doing kata, you may break your wrist the first time you hit someone for real. If you aren't used to taking a hit, you will be at a huge psychological disadvantage when you feel that sting and are reduced to a quivering mess.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top