Glock 17 or XD .45

Status
Not open for further replies.
The Glock 17 without a doubt.
You will not shoot the 45 as much because of ammo costs.

Plus the Glock 17 is like the Model 10 of this generation. Everyone should have at least one. :)

JK. Seriously though, these are excellent guns that will last you a lifetime of shooting enjoyment.
 
I Decided

Well guys, I met another guy at the range who had an XD .45 and a glock 22 in .40. I was sceptical at first of the glock, because it didnt feel right in my hand at the store. This all changed when I shot the G22. The glock felt like It was made for me when I put some rounds down range. I shot a box out at 50 yards and hit it about 7out of 10 times. I'm no marksman, and I was truly amazed that I could put that many bullets on target with an unformiliar platform, unformiliar caliber, and at a range that I never shoot at. I generaly keep all my shots at 25 yards or less, with 80% at 15 yards.
Illbe getting a G17 in the next few days. I also plan on getting a 10mm for carry while hunting ealy next year. I like the idea of staying with the same platform as I use at the range.
I didnt expect to like the glock after holding it in the shop, but now I knowhich is the right pistol for me. It was love at first shot lol.
 
I've owned both and like both. If I were you, I'd pick up both and see how they fit/feel in your hand. If one doesn't feel good, get the other. If neither feels good, don't get either...keep shopping. Why do I say this? Because if you don't like the way it feels when it's just sitting there in your hand, then you'll definitely not like it when it's firing/recoiling.

If they both feel good in your hand, then start looking at features. Decide whether you like 9mm or .45 acp better. 9mm is cheaper. The Glock is probably a bit lighter. It almost certainly will be when both weapons are fulled loaded to their capacity. The Glock 9mm does have a sterling reputation. The XD does to, but has only been out a few years vs. the Glock's 20 + years. The XD has a grip safety (much like a 1911). The Glock pretty much has no manual or otherwise physically affected manual safety to speak of. That won't matter to someone who knows his/her way around firearms and has common sense. If neither applies, trust me, you will defeat every "safety" known to man and enact that negligent discharge. Notice I didn't say "accidental" discharge.

The Glock has a ton of aftermarket parts, both for replacement and enhancement. The XD has neither. Glock mags are cheaper. Keep looking, there are more differences.

Don't let anybody bother you with how many rounds of whatever caliber. 18 rounds of 9mm is just as good as 14 rounds of .45. Parties who swear by either will tell you x number of rounds of x caliber won't matter because x caliber is worthless. If that's the case, and capacity means nothing, then we should all be carrying .50 AE derringers with only one round capacity, as well as Crimson Trace Laser grips and a finely tuned scope so that we don't miss with our one shot. God only knows what we'll do about the second, third, or fourth assailant.......I guess revert to the tactical sharp stick or rock in the road....


Happy hunting!
 
Of the plethura of officers that I know, none carry 9mm.

To a man, they all carry 40's or 45's

Our cops carry 9 mm and .40 S&W... :neener:

Madison: 9 mm G17 and G19

Milwaukee: .40 S&W G22 & G23

Others:

NYPD: 9 mm G17 & G19

--Ray
 
XD 45 all the way.

Before you buy you should shoot both I have Glocks that are sitting in my safe, once I shot the XD 45 service model I bought two and thats all I shoot at IDPA, IPSEC and steel matches I love the XD. The only thing better are my CZ's.
 
Judas: Congrats on your decision. The Glock 17 is the pistol that changed many people's minds about polymer use in firearms. It is an instant classic. I think you are going to like it.
Be sure to let us know how you like it when you get it.

Don't mind the caliber war that has started. These things happen in all threads that compare calibers. The 9mm for self defense is carried by 10 times the police forces world wide vs the 40 or 45. Not to mention the militarys that carry a 9mm.

I like your choice of the 10mm for hunting. When time has passed or money accumalates again they sell a 6" barrel for the Glock 10mm too. This could be of interest to you for hunting reasons.
 
The 9mm for self defense is carried by 10 times the police forces world wide vs the 40 or 45.

Most police drive Crown Victorias too.

As to the G17, it is an excellent pistol. I have a 19 and it is as reliable as gravity.
 
I too would like to put my commentary in context ...

I have a GLOCK 19 on my hip at this very moment loaded with 124 Grain Federal HST.
 
Good choice. I was going to suggest comparing the Glock to the XD9 instead of the XD45 because 9mm ammo is much cheaper, then suggest you pick the gun that you most like to shoot. Looks like you did just that. Enjoy yoru great gun.
 
I've had a XD 40 and a glock 23 (40SW). I bought the XD first, but didn't like certain things about it. I don't like the back safety on it. I don't need more then 1. And now you can't buy an XD40 with out a thumb safety. So you have a safety in the trigger, the slide, and the frame. I'm sure that adds quite a few more parts (more parts = more stuff to break or wear). I like how the glock was simple. It breaks down to like 5 parts, and I bet I could switch parts from other similar glock pistols and still make it work. The glock also has one safety. I think this is great, less to remember if you ever need to use it. People carried revolvers for a long time, and it was safe for them. I also didn't like the balance of the XD, it looked and felt top heavy. I like the glocks low profile. The XD wasn't a bad gun at all, but my glock is better in my opinion.
 
That's not the first time I've heard and read people saying "In the gunshop I didn't like the way the Glock felt in my hand; however, after shooting the Glock, it was a totally different story."

In the end, it's not how comfortable a gun is in your hands, but how well you shoot with it! When that criminal is running and bobbing all around, you're not going to think in your head after accurately shooting him down "Man, this gun felt weird in my hand! I mean, I was dead on accurate with it, but *uhg* I hate the way it feels!" LOL!

That's why I don't go by the "Go to the gunshop and see how they feel first, then make your decision" type of answer anymore, when someone is seeking a new pistol to buy. I say "Go to the gun range and see how you SHOOT with these guns first, if anything."

True, I'll still suggest to go for one gun over another, if that's all you want as an answer. But, in the end, it really is how you shoot with a pistol, as long as the other in comparison is close to equal in reliability and durability.

If you shoot great with a very unreliable gun (usually mouseguns aren't known for reliability) but crappy with a very reliable brand, then I'd suggest not getting the unreliable gun, and keep practicing with the reliable brand until you've become a good shot with it. So there're certain things to weigh when picking a gun you need to rely on to help save your life one day.

It's not just how a gun feels in the hand, but rather how you shoot with it, that really matters in the end.

We'd be amazed at how many people use their bias to pre-judge Glocks before even shooting them, and think "They look blocky, I won't like that!" Or even more "I even held it, and it's too blocky, and doesn't feel right in my hands."

Then they just put it down and go for another gun; never knowing that a gun can shoot different compared to simply how "it feels" in your hands alone. Ah well, they're missing out on a great pistol brand, and don't even know it. ;)

Anyway, good choice my friend. I'm getting a Glock 29 (sub compact 10mm platform) for woods protection and CCW for defense against two-legged criminals, as well. It'll be a multi-tasker pistol! :)

If hunting with a Glock, then yes, you'll most likely want a Glock 20. Yes, the grip is bigger than usual, but others (like Ted Nugent) have no problems using their Glock 20's to hunt with at all. :)

Check www.Georgia-Arms.com for 10mm canned heat. Buy in bulk from them, and it's roughly $14.70 for every 50 rounds.

Check www.DoubleTapAmmo.com for good "hotter than usual" 10mm defense rounds! I'm going to be using the 200 gr. FMJ for bear defense, and most likely 180 gr. JHP for two-legged BG defense. ;)
 
XD45 Service Model, If you can believe it I carry it concealed. Shoots like a dream, feels great in your hand, 13+1 45acp (tough to go wrong there). I shoot mine all the time. I have or have had almost every Glock made, but the XD feels better in my hand.
If you want to go 9mm (cost and capacity), get an XD9. The ergonomics of the XD just make it a better pistol in my hand and I have never had any problems with either.
 
When anything is compared to the Glock. Take the Glock everytime, especially when regarding the G17 or 19.
glockmodel19homedefender.jpg
 
Judas530
I was sceptical at first of the glock, because it didnt feel right in my hand at the store. This all changed when I shot the G22.
The glock felt like It was made for me when I put some rounds down range.

Northalius
That's not the first time I've heard and read people saying "In the gunshop I didn't like the way the Glock felt in my hand; however, after shooting the Glock, it was a totally different story."


The same happened to me when I was looking for a compact gun.

The Glock 19 felt weird in my hand at the shop but proved to be an accurate, comfortable, low recoil platform at the range.
I ended up buying a M&P9c because it felt a little better to me and was cheaper than the Glock (I rented and shot both).
I also felt the Glock's cheap sights needed to be upgraded thus increasing the price difference between the G19 and the M&P9c.

Regardless, I was very impressed with the Glock 19. I don't think you can go wrong with a G17/G19. They're very good guns IMHO.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top