Long Gun or Handgun for Home Defense?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Spieler

Member
Joined
Jun 30, 2003
Messages
650
Location
McDonough, GA, USA
What is your PRIMARY home defense gun; handgun or a long arm such as rifle, carbine or shotgun? If this subject has been covered here before, my apologies for being the 'new' guy.

10-Ring's thread asking if your home defense gun was the same as your daily carry gun got me thinking about this, but his supposition was based solely on handguns.

My go-to HD gun is a Win. 1300 shotgun. I have always been more of a long gun man and find that I generally shoot these weapons better than any handgun that I have owned. A handgun is convenient to carry, sure, but how relevent is this in a HD situation? I like the hand-filling nature of the shotgun and the sense of confidence it gives me when I know I am going into a confrontation. The intimidation factor of a shotgun, rifle, or carbine, although not solely something I am willing to bet my life on, also plays a factor I think.

This last point was reinforced for me about a year ago when I confronted a violent individual in my apt. complex. A young lady, who had obviously been assaulted, came knocking on my door at the proverbial zero-dark-thirty hour asking for help. To make a long story short, while I was assisting this person her attacker appeared and began verbally threatening her and approaching us, at which time I racked the slide on the shotgun and drew a bead on the guy. He stopped in his tracks, his eyes got real big and he started stammering "...it's all cool man" and left the area (to be picked up by police a few moments thereafter).

So, yes I carry a handgun for daily concealed carry, and it backs me up in the house, but when at home my primary weapon is the shotgun. Anybody else?
 
Good job on the bad guy BTW. Wish you lived in my sister's complex..

I have both for HD. Shotguns at either end of the house and a couple of handguns in hiding places. Biggest use for a HG in the house (IMHO) is to have something to stick in my pocket when the doorbell rings.
 
For home defense I don't really have a "primary".

I often carry my regular CCW on me around the house. On the nightstand I have a 4" 629 (loaded with Speer's 44 special 200 GDHP) and the CCW sleeps on in another spot near the bed. There is a 1300 (5 rounds of buck in mag and 5 slugs in butt cuff) and a Scout rifle if needed.

Usually I will grab the 629 to answer the door or such. I don't reach for the shotgun or rifle unless I think I might REALLY be shooting. The handguns are there for "better safe than sorry".
 
Bedside table companion is the 1911-A1, there to give me enough time to fade back to closet for the Serious Artillery..The Maverick 88 Shotgun, and the US Rifle Cal 30 M-1.
 
The shotty would be my preferred choice if I had time to fetch it from the closet.

If not, I usually have a pistol within reach

Generally speaking, nothing beats a shotgun for HD. Massive damage and minimal overpenetration. Because I live in a bricked house (bricked on all walls) I keep mine loaded with 00 buck. Back when I lived in an apartment I kept it loaded with heavy birdshot on a full choke.

A handgun with expanding ammo is the next best thing, but if you live in apartments/condos a miss could still cause tragedy.

A centerfire rifle is probably the worst choice, as penetration even with SP/HP bullets is WAY excessive. Remember rule 4. If you live rural this is probably not as much of a concern.
 
I was gonna say, handguns are, well, "handy." I usually have mine on or about me if I'm in the house, the shotgun is typically upstairs. If I have the luxury of getting it, it'll be got, but I figure I can probably discourage most miscreants with the handgun alone. If it is really that bad, I'll fight my way back to the long guns.
 
Kids in the house is another consern for some people....

I would love to find a good way to lock up a shotgun close to my bed without a key, and able to be opened in the dark. I have not found this yet (have not looked extensively, but if anyone knows any please post :) )
I saw one that locked into the ejection port, locking up the action, but it took a key :(, that would have been great if it was a simplex lock...

So the 1911 goes in a simplex lock box near the bed, and the 870 in the safe. The 1911 is there to get me to the 870.
 
Welcome, "new guy".:)

Firearms are just tools (or golf clubs, depending on which analogy one prefers). It depends on what one wishes to do. If you have both, you have more flexibility.

The weapons do not fight, you do. Improving your skill in use, not skill in selection is the controlling element.:cool:
 
Handguns for me, for now, because it is what I have always had. Bought an 870 earlier this year for HD but still becoming proficient with it. One day it will end up under the bed.

yzguy
I would love to find a good way to lock up a shotgun close to my bed without a key
Something like this Long Gun Vault ?
 
YZ Guy's setup complemented by an M1A Scout for long shots on wallclimbing blue helmeted paratroopers ;)

Everythign in Simplex lockboxes or a safe. No unsecured ammo or weapons in the apartment unless I am wearing it.

Tejon:
The weapons do not fight, you do. Improving your skill in use, not skill in selection is the controlling element.
[gong sounds]? ;)
 
Do you guys think that securing a firearm at all times is that important? I mean, I grew up in a house where we all knew that the guns were loaded, and didn't touch them unless we had permission. Even when I was very little, I knew that I wasn't to touch guns or to go into my parent's room without permission.

I'm going to be getting a simplex lock box for beside the bed, and some type of system for securing my shotgun, as I have a little one on the way, but I still sometimes think that I and my forebears got along just fine without them.
 
A shotty is probably about the most intimidating ..... and so perhaps a means of ''defuzing'' a situation more easily.

For me tho .... it's always the CCW ...... it's on me all waking hours and on floor just under bed at night ...... the added familiarity of the piece (whether the summer (snub) or cooler months (P series) ..... means I am more likely to be very '' in touch''!:evil:

One other point too ... the handgun is a wieldy weapon ....... the shotgun is IMO a tad less so ..... particularly in confined spaces (tho it does make a better club!! :D )
 
Do you guys think that securing a firearm at all times is that important?

Yes, I have a roommate, and while I trust him...

"In God we trust, for everyone else, keep your paws where I can see 'em...."

Also during dryfire and cleaning I secure all the ammunition as a administrative thing as I don't want any loose ammo floating around (I find 9mm and .308 in my backpack or pockets at times) to cause me not to get my security deposit back.... ;)
 
Both long guns and handguns are available. I prefer long guns for their psycological intimidation factor if someone is truely intent on doing harm; people seem to get reeeeal small when faced with an AR.

Still, I'll answer the doorbell with a concealed pistol...makes for more positive social contact if it's the local girlscouts selling cookies and keeps the soccer moms from wetting themselves. I'll take 5 boxes, have a nice day. :D
 
Do you guys think that securing a firearm at all times is that important?
Yup, absolutely. ANy gun that I own is either under my diect control or under lock and key at all times. If I were a hermit, maybe I'd do it differently.

As far as HD goes, I have both a 1911 and a 12 gauge available to me in the bedroom. That gives me a pistol to use if I hear a 'bump in the night' that I want to check out, and a longarm to point at the door while I wait for the cops if I know someone's there.
 
Primary would be my taurus PT92 because it's accessable and loaded. It's enough to take care of most situations. Personally, i feel no need to answer the door with a gun on me as i just don't live in that type of neighborhood.

In my closet is a winchester defender which is not loaded. If i know i'm going to be up against something, it takes very little time to load it up. That's there for when you know someone is downstairs who shouldn't be. Hearing someone cycle a pump action at the top of the steps should be enough to make any robber think twice.

If i was in a different neighborhood, the winchester would probably be loaded and i might be persuaded to answer the door with something small tucked in my back pocket if the situation was suspect.
 
Do you guys think that securing a firearm at all times is that important?
This may vary according to each individual's situation. For me, ABSOLUTELY. I have teenagers that are home alone every day of the week. While I trust them, friends come over, boredom sets in, topic of guns comes up...don't even want to go there.

When I think back to when I was teenager and some of things I did or was just "around" it scares the #$%% out of me. Just because nothing happen to me doesn't mean nothing will happen to them.

Or maybe I'm just a "parent", either way guns stay secured at all times in my house.
 
"Do you guys think that securing a firearm at all times is that important?"

When I don't have room mates then the rifle and shotgun are out were I can get them quickly.

With room mates everything off body is locked up till bedtime.
 
I personally prefer handguns for discrete door answering and shotguns for serious encounters. Im currently living in a household where the youngest is my sister at 16. Even with no small children, I dont like leaving firearms unattended, especcially loaded. EVen though I trust my family, I have no desire to arm a intruder with the shotgun he found leaning up against a closet wall, while Im stuck with the handgun that was on my person. Unfortunatly, I am too looking for a way of locking up my 870 while still having quick access to it. Ive found a few possibles but all work by locking around the trigger assembly/reciever portion of the gun. My 870 has a sidesaddle on it so It doesnt work in those type of long arm safes.
 
I have been thinking of shotgun behind a locked glass door. Either one of those cheesy gun cabinets or built into the wall, if I need it in a hurry, don't think the noise of the glass braking will be much of a factor. If I have time, I could use the key.
 
lock-up for the shot gun

My local dealer has a 870 locked up in the back room and all of us "more than customers" know the combo. You only have to push 1 to 4 buttons turn latch and your in, it does latch on the reciever area though.
Tony
 
yeah that does look promising... I'm going to have to look into that.



I was thinking of something smaller for shot guns only that fit into the ejection port (like one I had found using a key) for a bit more simplicity (no electronics) and probably a bit cheaper, but this may work out for me... :)

litman252,
any more info on this? name? web site?
 
I stopped in this morning to look at his lock, The unlocking "wing=nut" says "simplex". I did not find a web sight in a quick search, the employe that was working thought they might be out of bussiness.:mad: I'll keep looking..........
Tony

Here is the best I can seem to do, I think the long gun model has ben discontinued, I'll talk to the dealer on Tues.Simplex Gun Locks
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top