I would like to get a pistol for home defense and it will see A LOT of range time. Ruger GP100?? Smith 686?? I would like 38/357 and a 4" barrel that can stand up a lot of practice time even with magnum loads. Other suggestions????
The 686 has a more graceful and refined look. However, many people (including myself) refuse to buy S&W guns because of their politically motivated decision to install trigger locks on their handguns. In the case of the 686, the result is a beautiful handgun with an ugly keyhole on the side of the gun. Kinda like a beautiful woman with a big zit in the middle of her forehead.
The GP100 has been referred to as a hand held Sherman tank. Not real pretty, but built to last. I have one and it's nice.
Either will meet your needs with no problem. Handle each and see which one feels better in your hand.
However, many people (including myself) refuse to buy S&W guns because of their politically motivated decision to install trigger locks on their handguns.
Unlike Bill Ruger, who supported the Assault Weapons Ban and 10 round mag capacities. Just as bad in my opinion.