If he were hinky enough to have a gun pointed at him one second, even though he now claims compliance, I still look at him as a serious threat until he is fully controlled.
I can't get him cuffed with a gun in my hand, I have to do something with it, but, I have to be thinking he is feigning compliance to draw me in and, it may go back to deadly force any time.
Just reality.
Sure, just wandering around in the woods, at the house at the range, it's ok to look at your holster, but, you don't want that to become habit either. Remember the stories of officers having empty .38 shell casings in their pocket after a shoot out. It became "normal" to drop the empties in your hand and then put them in your pocket after firing a string at the range. Good for reloading, not an effective use of time in a real deal.
Usually the gun goes back in the holster without being fired. He might also have buddies that I don't want to take my eyes off of.