Should I sell one to buy another, help needed!

Status
Not open for further replies.

MikeJones9mm

Member
Joined
Sep 8, 2005
Messages
1
First, I have guns I shoot and guns I collect. I want to be kind of vague on the brands I am talking about here. I know people have strong opinions solely based on brand names alone, so I am intentionally being vague about brand name.



I collect a certain line of rifle. There is no real collector value in them like say a Parker shotgun, but I collect these rifles. I have several of them, most of which are safe queens - my choosing. I like these rifle, and just having them and shooting them here and there is enough for me. I have plenty of other guns to shoot and hunt with. This line of guns are no longer made, and haven’t for about 20 years. There is one I use in the fall for hunting season that is nice, but has some bluing wear and a few minor scratches. But I found an unfired with slightly different woodwork and this one is MINT and UNFIRED! Thing is I can’t quite swing the asking price at the moment, unless I sell another gun.



Which brings me to…

I could part with a certain 1911 I have. It’s a good shooter and has had some custom work done to it that I really like. Thing is I never shoot it, and I don’t collect 1911’s. I am thinking I can buy another 1911 like this anytime I want to. But the rifle, well, its the only unfired one I've really seen like this. While I really like this 1911, my only issue would be is one day my kids would maybe like to shoot/use/have it. Or I could use it for a bullseye match or something. My interest in pistols is for self defense, so I figure if I'd shoot IDPA or something like that I'd rather use my carry gun.



Here are my issues:

1) do I trade a gun I no longer shoot for a gun I probably won't shoot?

2) the gun I will trade for is very similiar to one gun I already have

3) I'd probably shoot my rifle more since I'd have a nice version in the safe

4) should I really worry about the "kids" issue? I have no idea if they will ever even be interested as they are pretty young yet. But, with 3 kids I'd think one maybe would?



What do you think? Any opinions or comments?
 
No contest

Sell the 1911. You have no attachment to it, and kids are unpredictable. Get the gun you really want. A 1911 shouldn't be that hard to dispose of.
 
I say do it quick for a few reasons
A. Its the only one like that you have ever seen.
B. Good chance you wont find another
C. 1911s (dont burn me at the stake, I love mine) are a dime a dozen.
D. You dont use either but from what you say the 1911 isnt a collector.
E. God forbid later down the line you have to sell it, a rare rifle I believe would be worth more/
F. That makes a better heirloom than the 1911.
Just my opinion though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top