which .40 S&W is better?
- Thread starter tonytuna
- Start date
- Status
SteampunkQueen
Member
For sheer price id say the Glock. Ive been seeing a lot of used 22/23 for around 400 or so.
The SD40 is a good gun as well, although my experience is limited to handling one at a gun shop, but i know its gotten good reviews.
Those are the two Id choose for sure. Ive owned a couple .40 Glocks, a 23 and a 27, and honestly i loved them both. I never once had any malfunctions that were "user induced". I used the 23 as a "loaner" with friends on the range, and one evening we even managed to put down almost 800 rounds without stopping to clean or even lube the gun.
The SD40 is a good gun as well, although my experience is limited to handling one at a gun shop, but i know its gotten good reviews.
Those are the two Id choose for sure. Ive owned a couple .40 Glocks, a 23 and a 27, and honestly i loved them both. I never once had any malfunctions that were "user induced". I used the 23 as a "loaner" with friends on the range, and one evening we even managed to put down almost 800 rounds without stopping to clean or even lube the gun.
If its "main use" would be as a CCW...of the 3 choices, no question, go with the Glock 23. If you want to expand your search a little I'm a huge fan of the Ruger SRc(in your case the SR40c). My CCW is the SR9c(same size as the SR40C) its also become my most favorite pistol, period. I'm not going to over gush about it, except to say, its a hair smaller than the G23, much more comfortable and shootable. These compact Rugers are very versatile and reliable, making them an excellent defensive handgun in many situations...
Here's a few pics:
Side by side with a G26
Here's a few pics:
Side by side with a G26
Seven For Sure
Member
- Joined
- Nov 3, 2006
- Messages
- 437
The FN and Sig will make better HD pistols and the others are better options for carry IMO. I don't like safties or hammers for carry but appreciate them and the ability for cocked and locked without a holster for the nightstand.
I haven't seen a ruger sr40 with the black slide yet. It was on my list but the stainless slide was a deal breaker for me.
@mikepain-Is that the compact version?
The glock wasn't my first choice cause I don't like glocks much. But after some research it be came my first on my list.
@mikepain-Is that the compact version?
The glock wasn't my first choice cause I don't like glocks much. But after some research it be came my first on my list.
ColtPythonElite
Member
- Joined
- Jan 8, 2011
- Messages
- 10,475
A Glock 23 is tough to beat. Do some shopping around for a LEO trade in.
Quick Shot xMLx
Member
I have a CZ P07 and I like it a lot more than a G23. The trigger is much smoother after it's broken in and the grip is more comfortable. CZ P06 is also a great gun in your price range.
CaptAwesome
Member
- Joined
- Jan 8, 2012
- Messages
- 17
I picked the glock 23 because it met a lot of what I was looking for (lightweight, large enough to use for range or home defense, easily concealable, consistent trigger pull, pretty cheap accessories and replacement parts) but I have a buddy who loves his fnp-40 and would buy 10 more if he had the money. The only reason I would ditch my 23 would be to pick up a 19, which I'm thinking about doing now
Dnaltrop
Member
If the Glock doesn't suit you ( I can't hold them properly myself) I throw my vote behind the M&P over the SD. the palmswells really fit my big mitts perfectly. One of the most comfortable guns I've shot.
Go grope all of your prospects rapid-fire a few times and see which one feels the most natural to you. We know attractive mates subconsciously within seconds of seeing them, I find the same holds true for firearms.
Go grope all of your prospects rapid-fire a few times and see which one feels the most natural to you. We know attractive mates subconsciously within seconds of seeing them, I find the same holds true for firearms.
CZ57
member
+1 Springfield XDm or XDm Compact. 
Claude Clay
Member
my Sig P239/40 1st gen has operated flawlessly for well into 11,000 rounds.
the high count is partly practice for carry but mostly IDPA. It also gets used in the class room.
positives are the double action 1st shot followed by SA and the de-cocker for safing the gun before re-holstering and when topping off the magazine after chambering a round.
minuses in my opinion, is its only 7+1 and 29 ounces. both 'problems' go away with a good holster and good shot placement. if you feel that you must have more rounds on board, the P229 has a fatter grip to accommodate 12+1.
just be sure it fits your hand.
the high count is partly practice for carry but mostly IDPA. It also gets used in the class room.
positives are the double action 1st shot followed by SA and the de-cocker for safing the gun before re-holstering and when topping off the magazine after chambering a round.
minuses in my opinion, is its only 7+1 and 29 ounces. both 'problems' go away with a good holster and good shot placement. if you feel that you must have more rounds on board, the P229 has a fatter grip to accommodate 12+1.
just be sure it fits your hand.
AABEN
Member
I like the NP40 full size. But there is a lot that like the MP40 compact.
Mac's Precision
Member
I believe your best value will be with Glock 23.
GuysModel94
Member
You didn't list it but i think you should look at the Springfield XD 40 Tactical, bought one last year. Great gun, 5" sight radius, it handles the recoil without much barrel lift at all. My two sons like it more than our Glock or Beretta. The OD green is really nice looking.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
