Autoloader choices for bear "deterrence"?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Thanks for the replies so far (well, most of ya :D).

Still doing research, but right now I'm leaning toward (in no particular order).
1. Biting the bullet and getting a S&W 44 mag-maybe 6" barrel in a shoulder harness?
2. Glock :barf: 10mm
3. Going to do more research on 45 with +P ammo (I've never screwed with +P or +P+ as up 'til now biggest thing I've needed to stop was a BG).
4. Still doing a bit of research on 40 and 357 SIG ammo for budgetary reasons (guns presently in inventory), but doesn't look too promising?

And we all know, when it comes to defending oneself from bears the most important thing is saving money!

I'm kinda approaching this as carrying a weapon vs bells for point #4. Lots of folks say all you need is a bell etc, but I'm just not that lucky!

BTW...as I'm typing this, Greta Van Sustren has the father and son who were attacked by the black bear in Cades Cove-maybe you can catch it on the rerun later tonight.
I see the crawl across the bottom of the screen says 85lb bear-the initial reports said 55lbs.
 
For an auto loader pistol, you should be looking at two calibers:

10mm
45 super

But the best thing for bear is a shotgun with slugs.
 
Be aware that a 45 super is NOT the same thing as a 45 +P.
I’m trying to stay away from “exotic” calibers-actually to me the 10mm is a bit of an exotic (I’m a pragmatist donchaknow).

But the best thing for bear is a shotgun with slugs.
If they do start allowing CC in national parks, that’s going to rule out shotguns AFA practicality for CC, as well as probably being illegal for VA CC. Haven’t looked in a while but I’m pretty sure VA CC is for handguns only.
Guess that's why they call it a CHP in VA! :scrutiny:

Don’t forget-the original post was covering legal CC in national parks if it ever goes into effect. If so, don’t know what form it’ll take, but the push seems to be to mirror state laws for the state the park is located in, as is now the case with national forests.
 
If you are considering .40 S&W for either interim or permanent solution, then consider the Double Tap Ammo load:

http://www.doubletapammo.com/php/catalog/product_info.php?cPath=21_26&products_id=210

200 gr WFNGC (hard cast Wide Flat Nose Gas check)
Ballistics : 200gr. @ 1050fps / 490 ft/lbs- Glock 23 (4.0"bbl)
Glock 22 4.5" bbl - 1106fps
Glock 27 3.5" bbl - 1009fps

It is a pretty stiff load, nothing you want to shoot 300 rounds of all in one sitting. This is what I carry for most day hikes and is about the smallest caliber and weight I would feel confident as having a chance to penetrate and do sufficient tissue damage.

They also have an awesome 10mm 230 gr WFNGC load at about 1100 fps. This is approaching .41 magnum velocity, weight and diameter (250 gr hardcast at 1100 fps), which is a reasonable black bear hunting load in handguns.
 
45 acp-LE Bonded Ammo-

The Springfiel XD .45 [5] inch barrel for better velocity. That is 13 in the mag, one in the pipe-Seriously unload all 14 shots into the Mother!:evil: You will win that Battle. If not, Man found dead after he empty's gun into Bear is not a Bad Headline. And it teaches the rest of us a lesson;) Get some LE ammo because of the Penetration. Federal Tactical bonded 230gr +P or non+P or the Winchester 230gr Bonded. Theses loads really penetrate and Expand Excellent-Plus retain 100% of their weight.

The Best to You and Yours!

Frank

PS-I expect the Headline to read-Man Blows Away Bear! Empty's His XD into Charging Bear:evil:
 
Didn't read the whole thread. Putting on flame proof suit. I am going to carry my Taurus PT145 into the woods. Lightweight and 11 rounds of hot 45 ACP will ruin the day of any critter 2 or 4 legged found in North Georgia woods including BIG FOOT. Supposedly today there will be a news conference displaying a carcass they found here.
 
I been thinking about this a bit. As Its a worry where I live...

I will go back and say that if your worried about bear, the biggest load that you can handle is the best, .44 mag preferred.
 
Didn't read the whole thread….
Go ahead…we’ll wait…well...we’re waiting! :rolleyes:

I am going to carry my Taurus PT145 into the woods. Lightweight and 11 rounds of hot 45 ACP
Actually, I have a PT145 but only had it at the range once-only pistol I couldn’t hit squat with-I’m hoping the sights are (seriously) off. I kept getting closer and closer to the target and damn if I know where the bullets were going-don’t think I ever put one on paper! Ran out of daylight before I could troubleshoot-hopefully it’s nothing major ‘cuz I really like the gun’s features-still a little leery ‘bout Taurus quality though.
What kind of ammo are you using? Gotta dig out the owner manual, but I think it said OK for +P ammo.

45 acp-LE Bonded Ammo
Yeah…getting an order together for Ammuniton to Go and was going to load up with some +P and possibly +P+ stuff-might have to give the bonded stuff a look/see. Going to check a local gun shop/police supply place today to check out his ammo before ordering.

The Springfield XD .45 [5] inch barrel for better velocity.
Might have to accelerate my next purchase! I’ve come close to buying the XD45 Compact a few times since that ½” less grip length feels much better in my hand. My current main CCW is a Springfield XD40SC-nice, accurate guns.

If not, Man found dead after he empty's gun into Bear is not a Bad Headline.
For whom?
I trust you’ll have ‘em put that on my tombstone-after all, some folks in here are nothing if not helpful!

I expect the Headline to read-Man Blows Away Bear! Empty's His XD into Charging Bear
With my luck, I wouldn’t even go out in a blaze of glory…I can see the headline now:
“Man commits suicide in national forest-authorities unsure what he emptied his 3 magazines into”! :banghead:
 
All handguns this side of a Casull have a major handicap in velocity. The key is to have a bullet that will not expand and with a high enough SD to penetrate in spite of the low velocity.

That rules the .45 ACP out unless you can load it with a 300 grain hardcast. The .357 Sig is also out because it replicates the lowest weight .357 mag loads and cannot cope with a 180 or 200 grain hardcast.
 
Actually, I have a PT145 but only had it at the range once-only pistol I couldn’t hit squat with-I’m hoping the sights are (seriously) off. I kept getting closer and closer to the target and damn if I know where the bullets were going-don’t think I ever put one on paper! Ran out of daylight before I could troubleshoot-hopefully it’s nothing major ‘cuz I really like the gun’s features-still a little leery ‘bout Taurus quality though.
What kind of ammo are you using? Gotta dig out the owner manual, but I think it said OK for +P ammo.

BasicBlur I will get mine tomorrow. I shoot more like I am on crack more than being a crack shot so my experience probably will not be meaningful to the accuracy debate. Just from my reading I get the feeling some that say it is bad bad inaccurate do not take the time to learn the pistol with its different sights and trigger. They are all different. I do my best impression of a pistolero with my Ruger 22/45 and my worst with my Walther P1. I cuss at a new pistol, hand it to the ace of the range, shut up when he puts a tight group in an inch.

I don't think Taurus says it will handle P+ but if I am going to try to shoot a bear I want the hottest stuff available. Haven't gotten into researching yet what ammo there is consensus on it likes.
 
I don't quite understand your attitude towards Glock. If you need to defend yourself from bear, one of the most important things is reliability. That's what Glock is!!
 
If my butt was against the wall I would take my 44mag MtnGun Smith and load it with hard cast semi was cutters about 240 grainers...next would be
240 JHPs...way way down on the list would be my 45 acp autos...to me nothing less than 44...and 454 would be good...475 better....in other words
use enough gun...when face to face with the bear it will no longer be an armchair academic discussion...it will be for real...and you better be right and darn lucky...
 
FYI basicblur
SAAMI Standard
.45 ACP = 21,000 PSI or C.U.P whatever they measure by
.45 ACP +P = 23,000

SAAMI has no +P+ standard so the manufactuere is loading high pressure

.45 Super - what 27,000 ?
and I think the
.460 Rowland is higher yet.

I'll stick with .45 +P or whatever HD/SD load I can
hit something with, with my S&W 1911 5" Bbl.

I also have a S&W 686P .357 Mag. and some
180 gr. Hornady XTP JHPs probably over 1150 FPS
but I am not a very good shot iwith it, so it's
a gun to take to the range and get p.o.d with it.

Oh, I also have a 625 5" bbl. which would require a
good shoulder rig, but I have the .45 AUto Rim with the
Barnes XPB 225 gr. HPs it's the same bullet as COrBon
uses with the .45 ACP 185 gr. DPX offering. at 900 FPS+

I also have a .400 CorBon Barrel for my 1911 which is a
necked down .45 ACP case &
.400 CorBon 155 gr. Hornady XTP JHP @ 1,350 FPS
with the controlled opening of the JHP should
penetrate but I wonder about bullet weight.

Randall
 
Lots of good advice here.

Lots of really bad advice, too. <grin>

Bears are so much tougher than humans that it's just silly to compare the loads we use for people.

The best post here is the one which promotes penetration.

The best auto for bears is a good .44 mag revolver.

Loaded with very good, and deep penetrating ammo.

http://garrettcartridges.com/products.asp
 
basicblur

I see your sense of humor is a lot like mine:eek: Scary:) I have been ordering from Ammunition to go for a long time now. Never disappointed. The Federal 147gr HST +P or non+P is my favorite 9mm load, because of the Penetration and Expansion. The Winchester 180gr Bonded is my favorite .40 load [Hot Load:D] Second being the Federal 180gr HST. For my .45's, my favorite is the Winchester 230gr Bonded and the Federal 230gr HST. There are no Bears here in Omaha, so I do not use +P .45acp loads. I Hope you never have a run in with a Bear. If you do Run into one, I know the only one walking out of the Forest will be you:evil:

The Best to You and Yours!

Frank
 
Last edited:
I don't quite understand your attitude towards Glock.
Just got back from the gun “emporium” out of town and got a chance to fondl…errr…handle a lot of stuff I normally don’t see in this neck o’ the woods (at least not all in one place).
After handling a Glock 20 my attitude ‘bout ‘em has changed!
You don’t want to know… :D

At’s one fat grip on that sucker! While I still think they’re ugly (not that it matters) and early ones I tried never fit my hand (main reason I avoided ‘em), it’s on my short list-after all, at’s a lot of firepower in your hand if you got the time to empty the mag!
Guess if Yogi comes for me I could always cover my eyes as I fired so I wouldn’t have to look at it!
(the gun, not the bear) :what:

BTW…iff’n anybody’s interested, Town Gun Shop in Collinsville VA has ‘bout 10 Colt M4 Carbine’s on sale for $1200 and change (normally $1,700). Looks just like my Rock River-if I had run across a “deal” like that when I bought my RRA I might have ponied up another $150 for the Colt. Dealer said he normally has a lot of trouble getting them in but for whatever reason a load got dropped on his doorstep!

Also got to play with an FN FS2000 ($2,000 and too pricey for me), but darn if I didn’t make it out the door before handling his SIG 556es (around $1,500).
 
Desert Eagle still around? If so, then for an auto, check out 50AE or 44mag.

I wouldn't choose an auto for bear country, but that's me.

My BIL used a 44 several time to take black bear and that's what I carry in the woods, alway have. I have a 265g Cast GCSWC at 1200fps. 454 casull is a good choice too.

Step up to an S&W X frame and go 460 ot 500. Damn things are just too big IMO, but you need that to tame the recoil.
 
My two cents worth.....If your "dead" set on an auto for bear than a Glock 20 loaded with the hottest and heaviest from double tap is the only way to go. I just hope your life insurance is paid up. Personally I'd go with a DW Supermag in 445 or a 500 S&W.
 
Here's some info from Armco a Canadian company in northern B.C. about their .45-08....

A Glock 29 with pearce grip extension mag would be a nice compact package for the bush.



http://www.armco-guns.com/what's new at armco.htm

11/02/02.** More news on the .45 ACP "bear Gun" aka the .45-08 Armco.* Have been popping out 200 grain hard-cast semiwadcutters at 1450 from a 5" barrelled Para Ordnance.* The trick was to use Hodgdon Long Shot powder.* I'll tone it down to about 1350 which is lots, but the hot ones were no problem to shoot, even with a stock 18# recoil spring.* You NEED a shock buff in the gun!* More testing this winter.* Too bad the bears are hibernating...* I've been reading a bit of Elmer Keith stuff, and have concluded that a good hardcast lead bullet with a flat nose and sharp shoulders is probably the best to use.* Gee, that's the one we use for IPSC.




02/05/02.**** How about the new* .45/08 ARMCO pistol wildcat cartridge!* This is essentially a .308 case cut down to .45 ACP length and neck reamed to make room for a Nosler 230 grain FMJ flat point bullet (and as much powder as we can cram in behind it.* Alternately a 200 grain hard cast SWC bullet beautifully cast and sized by Smart Bullets is used, at higher speeds, of course.* Results?* So far, almost 1200 FPS from the 230 grain bullet with a 4 1/4" barreled Springfield Armory Defender with a 2 port compensator and a 22 pound recoil spring.* That will translate into well over 1200 with a 5" barrel (testing soon) and starts to get REAL close to what you get from a 4" Model 29 in .44 Magnum.* 50%* (at least) more rounds and twice the controllability.* Recoil is absolutely nothing compared to the big magnums, although it IS noticeable!* Testing is ongoing and will include a .40Super barrel with 200 grainers at around 1300 FPS. Should be fun. I still like the .45/08 version, and even at the speeds we've achieved, see no excessive pressure signs with Federal 150 (large pistol) primers, which are notoriously soft.* The cases, of course, are made to withstand pressures we'll never encounter without actually blowing these pistol primers to smithereens!* I really think that a standard 5" 1911 or Para Ordnance, set up with the heaviest recoil springs that Wolff makes, will push 230 grain bullets past 1250, without being anywhere near as punishing to shoot as a hot heavy bullet .44 Magnum load in a Redhawk, a much bigger and heavier gun.




The idea came from the need for a "Bear Gun" for the north where a lot of people who move about in the woods for a living are now getting licenses to carry a handgun.* Traditionally it's been a .44 Magnum or bigger, but some of these are a pain to carry comfortably all day, along with a lot of other necessary gear.




I ran into a prospector who insisted on carrying a Colt Officer's Model loaded with 230 grain hardball!* Another carries a Ruger Super Redhawk in .454 Casull and has a permanently disabled shooting hand and the biggest flinch you ever saw.* Somewhere in between there has to be a gun that has the penetration and sheer bullet weight to take down a bear, even a grizzly, and still be shootable by the average person.




There are, of course, others like this, such as the .45 Super, touted by Ace Custom .45's out of Texas, the .451 Detonics Magnum of some years ago, and the new Triton .450SMC, as well as the .460 Rowland pushed by Clark, and sold only as a compensated gun.* It gets to 1300 FPS, but probably needs the comp!** All these, by the way, are the same overall length, although case lengths differ.* The problem, as we've discovered, is to find a powder that will give us the velocity we want without compressing enough to start pushing the bullet back out.* That lets out the old magnum standby, Hodgdon H110, and actually all its contemporaries, such as N110 Vihtavuori, 296, 2400, 4227 IMR, etc.* N105 seems to compress at about 1200,* so may be OK - and as is usual with this excellent powder, shows no more pressure than an ordinary IPSC load.*** Others hit the "wall" at 1050 and 1150, and we're currently playing with Tite Group, which is compact enough, and has shown nice results in some reasonable .44 magnum loads.*




*
2/28/03** Over 1000 ft/lbs of energy from a 5" 1911!!!* It's been a couple of weeks, but I finally have time to tell you about it.* In chronographing 10 shots with 200 grain hard-cast semiwadcutters, I had 2 go over 1500 fps.* Average was 1485, and you really DO want to have a contoured beavertail on your 1911 for these loads.* Recoil spring was a 20 pound Wolff variable, with a .200" Red Buff behind it.* Shot it all left-handed, too.* Surprisingly, pretty easy to shoot fast and accurately.* Feels kinda like a REALLY hot-rodded .38Super.* Not as much muzzle flip as I thought.*
Don't try this at home, folks!* I recommend loads generating more like high 1300's/low 1400's for day-to-day carry gun use (for bears, of course.)* Plenty of power, and less wear and tear on your gun.*
I shipped some brass, powder and springs to my friend John in Prince Rupert, BC, who videotaped his testing session with his Springfield (pretty stock) 1911A1.* Really neat.** Gotta figure out how to show that on here.* The next weekend John had some friends out to try his tiger.* They loved it!* Now I have to figure out a way to ship some of these loads to my friend Wild Bill Caldwell in Louisiana who is another 1911 "hotrodder".*
 
hmmmm a pistol for bear ? No one mentioned a Desert Eagle in .44 magnum, or .50 AE.
 
To anyone seriously considering the five-seven I would present the CZ-52 as a cheaper and better option. I believe it would penetrate the bear's skull with no problem, provided you could hit said skull while it is traveling towards you at say 25 mph.

I wouldn't take a CZ-52(or the TT-33) as my first choice against a bear but if money was a problem and you wanted a pistol, it could do the job. Stay with the surplus 7.62x25mm ammo and practice like crazy to be able to make a hit on an angry bear running at you.

And try to get used to the idea of carrying a CZ-52 cocked and locked(I imagine that'd be the only way to bring it into action fast enough).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top