I own both,plus smith shield ,I carry my sig more than any, the smith next.Just my preferance tho. All are dependable well made guns.None are better than the other.I just like the feel and the way a sig or smith feels and shoots better than my Glock 19.It's like Ford and Chevy..I own both and like both,never a problem with any I have owned..Some people are just die hard one brand or the other,fact is you can get bad in anything man made..man is not perfect nor is anything man has made..