Gun shows and Nazi paraphernalia

Status
Not open for further replies.
those who take offense at merely viewing a swatstika or german war relics, are not much different than those who take offense at merely viewing a picture of a firearm.

having an interest in WWII relics is a far cry from actually believing in the idealogy of the Nazis. i find myself impressed with german engineering and machining. i am also impressed by how close they really came to winning WWII. still doesnt make me a sympathizer with them.

with that said, i can understand that some people really do have just cause for hating anything german related. just like some people to this day still hate anything to do with the japanese. sometimes hatred can't be let go of easily.
 
Some folks are WAY to sensitive.

I like CSA items very much, and collect more every chance I get. My Great Grandad was the only one of 10 brothers that did not serve the South, and that was due to his age. I am a member of the Sons of the Confederacy, and frankly, I look askance at those that are as disrespectful as some here.

Nazi stuff I can take or leave, but I have no proboem with those that like to collect that type thing. I have never met a collector that set the stuff up in a shrine to the Third Reich.
 
After the Oklahoma Bombing these Neo-Nazi types went back under their rock but I have noticed that they are starting to peek back out. Gun shows should run them out. I would tell them; "Yes you have free speech now go start your own gun show you silly little Nazis."
 
I have absolutely no problem with the actual war stuff. If anyone of you do, then I'd sugest never buying a WWII Mauser, because guess what? The little swastika (or at least the eagle) is stamped on it.

I don't really care for the guys selling newly manufactured Nazi stuff, though, UNLESS sold strictly as a replica for use in a collection. I know some wartime stuff can be hard to find, and I have no problem with replicas designed to replace missing parts or fill a hole in a collection. What I do have a problem with, is $5 Chinese pocket knives with swastikas, minature Nazi flags, newl Nazi literature, etc. Stuff that isn't geared towards a collection.

As for Confederate stuff, I have no problems whatsoever. I'm smart enough to realize that the Civil war wasn't about slavery (at least, completely). And I'm sure the North has their share of faults in that war, too. Sherman seems to pop into mind.

Speaking of faults on both sides, you may as well forget collecting American WWII stuff, if you are one of those people, too. Seems to me that we had a bunch of Asians in internment camps.

My stance is that the promoters should be the deciding factor on what is there and isn't.
 
It's collecting a little piece of history. No different than buying any other antique.
 
I collect all kinds of military items from all sides fighting in WWII. That includes Nazi era firearms and daggers, bayonets, medals and other insignia. I also collect USSR memorabilia and they have murdered far more people than Nazi Germany ever considered.

I find it hypocritical that many folks would/do happily own 98 Mausers, Lugers, Walthers and other Nazi marked firearm related items and then say it is disgusting for me to collect SS Daggers and Knight's Crosses.
 
of course i feel people can sell whatever.
BUT= i think of it this way= buying , selling Nazi or Confederate junk =

having pride in that history. others are gonna see you the buyer or seller as someone who values that history, with enough pride to spend mnoney on it.

i would have no part of it, and selling these items is going to put more antis against the gun society.

think about it.

how would you guys feel about Satan worshippers who were into guns setting up a table full of black magic accessories ???
(heheh i dunno, penatgram sights? who knows?)

guns made by other armies, sure, after all they are tools.
but flags, insignias, stuff like that, it only promotes the ideology it was created for



I'm smart enough to realize that the Civil war wasn't about slavery (at least, completely).

OK= i buy about 1/5 of that. sure its partly true, as much as the war in Iraq is about oil, or WWII was about getting us out of depression.
all wars have economic overtones that are the ultimate driving force, that to me does not diminish the true cause. (ie, freedom for iraq, slaves in south, Jews).

WORSE= in today's world, to think that the confedrate flag has anything to do with trade NOW??? come on.

find me ONE black person who is not deeply offended by the confedrate flag.
(heh- if one is out there, they are probably on this site), and i will change my opinion, but as it stands, that dixie flag stands for racism, to the vast majority, and most importantly, to the people it was used to oppress.

and oh, right, the South was all set to retire slavery on its own right?
the "trade" had nothing to do with the fact that the south was enjoying near free labor? what was the TRADE dispute again? extra tariffs on the south for using slave labor?

hmmmmmmmmmmm. trade. i love it.
 
.

I really, really hate those !@#$%^&*() Illinois Nazis... If I see a "new nazi" table at a gun show, I _will_ go find the person running the overall show, and grouch 'em out. Same with the tables selling klucker crap, the turner diaries crap, etc.

I am glad I live in the USA. Did you know the Turner Diaries are banned in Europe?



Works for heroin, meth and kiddy porn.

Don't you enjoy seeing capitalism at work?
 
Originally posted by El Tejon
I am shocked and disgusted by the Nazi and Confederate stuff

I'm disgusted that you are disgusted by Confederate stuff... thems fighting words!!!

Originally posted by an extremely clueless Californian
OK= i buy about 1/5 of that. sure its partly true, as much as the war in Iraq is about oil, or WWII was about getting us out of depression.
all wars have economic overtones that are the ultimate driving force, that to me does not diminish the true cause. (ie, freedom for iraq, slaves in south, Jews).

WORSE= in today's world, to think that the confedrate flag has anything to do with trade NOW??? come on.

find me ONE black person who is not deeply offended by the confedrate flag.
(heh- if one is out there, they are probably on this site), and i will change my opinion, but as it stands, that dixie flag stands for racism, to the vast majority, and most importantly, to the people it was used to oppress.

and oh, right, the South was all set to retire slavery on its own right?
the "trade" had nothing to do with the fact that the south was enjoying near free labor? what was the TRADE dispute again? extra tariffs on the south for using slave labor?

hmmmmmmmmmmm. trade. i love it.

I know the Civil War is a sore topic that is constantly debated in here, but I've got to set this guy straight...

The war was about States' Rights. In other words, the Confederacy KNEW what the constitution was about and wanted to protect it, whereas the Union wanted to continue to exploit the south.

Slavery was on it's way out. Who needs to feed 40 slaves when you have machinery that can do the work of them, cheaper?

But of course, you're in a completely unbiased area of the country, that knows ALL about the Civil War... how many Californians were involved in that again?

And as for Blacks who are offended by that flag, I've got two comments for you:

1)There are just as many who aren't offended as there are those who are offended. It's not really a big deal here in the South.

2)Last time I checked, there is nothing in the Bill of Rights that guarantees freedom from being offended.
 
how would you guys feel about Satan worshippers who were into guns setting up a table full of black magic accessories ???

If the promoters let them, OK by me. I don't have to stop and look at the stuff.

The responsibility lies in the promoter. I'm suprised how many people would be offended that someone proposes a law saying that all private gun show purchases have to be 4473'd, yet say that others should have no right to sell what they want, and would complain to the police that something is being sold that they don't like.

To be blunt honest with you, the last gun show I went to was kind of boring. The promoters cut out almost all non-guns/knives stuff. No military surplus, even if it were gun accessories. No wartime memoribilia. Not even much in the way of surplus rifles, except for all the M1's. The promoters didn't want anything non-gun there, and nothing non-gun was there. Like I said, looking at table after table of commercial deer rifles got boring. I was kinda wishing for something interesting to pop up, but no, just more guns.

And EVIL got my point pretty good. My buddy has a shirt that says 'If this flag offends you, you need a proper history lesson' with the picture of the Confederate flag.

Come to think about, if we wiped out everything from every culture that ever comitted an atrocity, I think the antique market would be small indeed.
 
I am shocked and disgusted by the Nazi and Confederate stuff
What's wrong with Confederate stuff and why would you even equate it to Nazi stuff in the same sentence?

I thought you were educated. Apparently I was mistaken.
 
KSFreeman believes that all adherents of the Confederacy should have been executed after the Civil War for treason. And he considers us who revere our Confederate ancestors in about the same light;)


ind me ONE black person who is not deeply offended by the confedrate flag.

:D Sure wish I had a picture of it but I haven't seen him for years. There used to be a black farmer here who drove around in an orange Chevrolet pickup wearing a Treflan baseball cap. His Chevie pickup had one of those Confederate flag decal things that covers the entire rear window. I don't reckon he was offended by the Confederate flag.

H.K. Edgerton is reportedly an ex-president of the Asheville, N.C. chapter of the NAACP, a black, and a member of the Sons of Confederate Veterans. Reckon he's not offended by the flag, it this is fact. Apparently fact: http://www.ncpress.net/mayoral.html
 
Last edited:
i would think that black people should be more incensed at those who bought the african slaves and sold them over here.

its like hating coca-cola products because thats all you can get at mcdonalds.
 
I like militaria, I like historical relics, I have a few 'intersting items' myself. I am a son of the South. My daddy earned 2 Purple Hearts and a DSC in WW II (all I got is a VN service medal). Granted some gun show offerings are tacky and tasteless, but I can change the channel (i.e. walk away). Some gun shows are better than others, know whut I mean.

Mostly, I come to buy guns, ammo, and supplies, if they don't have what I want, I don't come back. Occasionally, I find other neat stuff, but mostly, I come to buy guns, ammo, . . . . . Get over it. Censorship sucks, the market will out, eh?
 
I don't have a problem with real Nazi war trophys, that stuff is history. And that is a time period mankind cannot afford to ever forget.

I too hate the newly manufactured Nazi and some Confederate stuff. That stuff sells to white power morons, for the most part. But I've learned to accept the fact that being in the "big tent" of gun owners there will be people whose beliefs I don't agree with or even hate with a passion. But its America and you can do and think what you want.

I do think alot of Nazi vendors make the rest of us gun owners look bad to newbies at gunshows. When you are trying to gain second ammendment converts its best not to look like a bunch of crazies.
 
Confederate Flag?? Havent gandered at to many of those...OHHHH you mean the BATTLE FLAG...

Guess I am not a good southerner...I do not have a single "Battle Flag" any where in my home or in my truck...Well of course I do have a holster with the image of the flag in it, so I guess that counts...If I new that people were so easily offended by it, I would have had one on my truck YEARS ago! :neener:


Well I do not take offense at any of the Nazi stuff...History is history...IF ya wanna collect it fine...It isnt my thing, although I do have a certain LOVEEEE of Mausers..

For those that LIKE to "poke the bear"..I gotta suggestion for ya...Last year I went to the local "head" shop and bought 2 t-shirts

First one says...I am NOT GAY!! But my girlfriend is!!<~~Wear that one with SWMBO...She thinks it's funny :D

Second one says...I AM NOT GAY!!But my boyfriend is!!<~~~wear that one to the range and gunshow's to annoy my buddies (they dont see the humor) :evil:
 
find me ONE black person who is not deeply offended by the confedrate flag.

just for the record there WERE small a number of Mixed and even ALL black confederate units. and no i am NOT referring to labor units, but to units that in at least one case saw extensive combat.

unfortunately at this time i am unable to pull the unit numbers from the deep recesses of my memory.

the one unit that i KNOW saw combat was a Texas Cavalry unit (21st Texas?? some similar designation) the personel of this unit ran the gamut of nationalities that could be found on the texas gulf coast at the time of the war, Whites (including germans/"dutch" that had not yet fully learned english), Blacks, Mexicans and Even Filipinos (sp?) (listed as "Chinese" in unit rosters). decendants of the men of this unit and others of all walks and races are at this time active in a re-enactment group based on the men and history of the unit.

Nor do we hear much mention of the Unit raised soon after secession In New Orleans, that had a fairly large number of Black officers (to be completely clear Black Slave owners) my understanding though is that this unit stayed in and around N.O. as part of the defensive units for that port.

the decendants of these men are not very likely to be as vehemently against the display of the Confederate battle flag as you seem to think ALL non-white americans are/should be.

It's a shame they don't teach ENOUGH about the Civil war to give not only or children but a larger portion of US in general a better idea of what really did occur in that war.

YES the war was about slavery..... Economic slavery.

Slavery in the south didn't die out, it was simply renamed "Sharecropping" all that really changed was that now the profit margins were down and the poor whites were just as much fair game to be exploited as the blacks.

i do not agree with a large portion of how i see the CSA battle flag used in modern Amercian society. No to a modern america the "rebel flag" does not stand for states rights, a prolonged and it seems continuing propaganda campaign started after the war, and it's use by such groups as the Klan have demonized it into a symbol of oppression. yet i'm willing to bet that most HS kids today can't identify the other flags used by the confederacy.

this does not keep me from remembering what it stood for to MOST of the men who fought under it, ie freedom from having the will of an industrialized North forced upon the agrarian based economies of the south.

now i better shut up before i get wound up and someone thinks things of me that are not true.
 
find me ONE black person who is not deeply offended by the confedrate flag.
(heh- if one is out there, they are probably on this site), and i will change my opinion, but as it stands, that dixie flag stands for racism, to the vast majority, and most importantly, to the people it was used to oppress.QUOTE]


The man behind the Rebel flag

by Clint Parker

The Asheville Tribune

Sept 26, 2002

An interview with local Southern heritage activist H.K. Edgerton on his
upcoming march to Texas, on his critics, and more

Editor’s note: On a fall afternoon Confederate flag waver and concerned Southern
historian H.K. Edgerton sat down with Tribune reporter Clint Parker for
an interview about his October walk to Texas.

H.K. Edgerton is a man of strong opinions, who is not afraid to speak his
mind. This was the case this week when Edgerton was interviewed about his
October walk from North Carolina to Texas.

Edgerton, the former head of the Asheville branch of the NAACP and for the
last five years a defender of the Confederate flag and other related causes,
plans to leave for Austin, Texas Monday, October 14th by foot. When asked
what he was doing, Edgerton responded with a big smile, “Walkin’ across Dixie.â€


The official title of the project is “March Across Dixie†and,
according to Edgerton’s press release, has three purposes.

First, Edgerton says he wants to expand the awareness of the need to defend
Southern heritage, history and the rightfulness of the Confederate cause
here in the South and across the entire United States. The south had every
legal right to secede and never should have been attacked for wanting to do so.

Second, Edgerton views the walk as part of an educational effort to show
that Southern symbols are part of a proud heritage that should be defended,
not scorned, as many liberal politicians, media and special interests would
have you believe, he says. Southerners have a cultural experience of their own,
and that culture needs to be defended from historical revisionists. The current
‘segregation’ of Southern culture, and particularly the Flag, by the uneducated
liberals is no different from the ‘segregation’ that the blacks faced earlier.

Third, he plans to raise money and gain support to build a permanent heritage
defense fund to be split between the Southern Legal Resource Center and the
Sons of Confederate Veterans to guarantee “...our heritage and history
survives and prospers despite the current attacks.†“Lying about the south and
re-writing history so the people remain ignorant of what really happened only
continues to separate the races.†Edgerton says he hopes to raise $2 million.

According to Edgerton, the Southern Legal Resource Center, a non-profit law
firm that defends Southern heritage cases such as the flying of the
Confederate Flag, currently has 12 cases that are about to go before the US
Supreme court with hundreds of cases being phoned in “...all the time.â€
“I’ve influenced a lot of babies across the south land to stand up,â€
explains Edgerton, “Now they’re being sent home from school or forced to
remove their Cross of St. Andrew (the original name of what’s now known as
the Confederate Flag).†They’re calling on legal help from the center and
Edgerton wants to help raise money for their defense.

The 1,300 mile walk is a tall order for the 55-year-old man. He’ll be
carrying a Confederate flag the whole way. Edgerton plans to take the
journey 21 miles a day, six days a week. He plans to attend a local church
on Sundays, give speeches and “kiss a lot of babies.†He thinks the journey
will take about four months to complete.

Edgerton considers his crusade a “fight for civil rights†and says, “I’ve
fought for civil rights all my life and it doesn’t get any worse than this.
It’s high time to have education for black and white folks about Southern
history.â€

Edgerton’s knowledge of the Civil War era differs greatly from what the usual
textbooks, which he calls northern propaganda, teach.

Edgerton instructs that secession was an act provided for in the U.S.
Constitution. No state had ever agreed to enter into a perpetual Union when
it ratified the Constitution, and the South was not the first to discuss the idea.
According to Edgerton, the New England states talked about secession during
the War of 1812, and in 1814 the New England Federalists even held a secession
convention in Connecticut.


Here are a few other insights Edgerton presented about the Civil War:

“Blacks fought for the South.â€

“Lincoln fought the South to keep all the Southern tax money.â€

“Southern generals have been made out to be traitors when they were very
honorable men.â€

“Blacks could certainly walk around the south, but not around Lincoln’s
Illinois.â€

“America will never ever be great until the truth (about the Civil War) is
told.â€

“The only thing Lincoln did was to pit black and white against each otherâ€

"The Constitution is what started the Civil War - taxes and states’ rights -
not slavery.â€

“Many blacks were free and they even owned slaves.†(This was documented in
an Asheville Tribune article about the 1800s Sulfur Spring Resort in West
Asheville.)

“Most white folks didn’t even own slaves.â€
“The first legalized slave was owned by a black man.â€

According to Edgerton, the greatest Union desertion rates occurred just after
Lincoln announced his Emancipation Proclamation. Edgerton asserted, “Union
Soldiers said they didn’t get into to this war to save the *******.â€

He believes the United States did a great disservice to the South after the
war. Edgerton points out, “We (the United States) rebuilt Germany and Japan
(after World War II), but we never rebuilt the south land. We need a
Marshall plan for the South and we need it now.†“If you want to understand

today’s race problems, you have to understand what went on during the
‘reconstruction.’ Anyone who knows nothing of that era is simply ignorant.â€
Edgerton has his own ideas about reparations too.

“The idea of reparations (for slavery) is a joke. It’s a way to drive a
wedge between blacks and whites. The only hope they (the blacks) have is to
hold their white southern brothers’ hand and join in calling for Southern
reparations,†explains Edgerton.
“My ultimate goal is to seek reparations for all Southerners.†Edgerton is not
just talking about money either, but the South’s history that Edgerton says
has been rewritten by the victors - the North.

Edgerton talked about some of his exploits and told of when he was standing
on a bridge in Alabama with his Confederate Flag. He said a black woman
stopped, jumped out of a car, hugged his neck and told him that she could
now bring her grandfather’s uniform down out of the attic. It was a
Confederate uniform.

He notes that when his zeal was put to work in the black community, he was
called “a radical, loose cannon,†yet when he turned his attention to
defending his Southern heritage he is called a “lackey and Uncle Tom.â€
“It’s ridiculous that a Nazi, Ku Klux Klan skinhead would use the Cross of
St. Andrew to try and intimidate anyone. That’s my flag,†states Edgerton.

Edgerton says that in the Southern heritage circles he’s been affiliated
with, “I’ve not run into one person who believes slavery was a good thing.â€
When it comes to defending Southern Hertiage, Edgerton admits “Southerners
always will try to accommodate people because we are kind-hearted, but we’ve
backed up too far,†he says.

Edgerton, who says he’s been made a member of the “White Trash Society,â€
says with a laugh, “It’s hard to be a white man 'cause we’re guilty of
everything bad that happened.â€

One of Edgerton’s detractors, Monroe Gilmour, who was named as a

Coordinator with the Western North Carolina Citizens for an End to Institutional
Bigotry, recently made comments about Edgerton in a national CNSNews.
com story.

Edgerton was asked to respond to Gilmour’s statement that when Edgerton
attended the Martin Luther King peace march with his Confederate flag that
“It feels as if he is there in defiance of what we’re doing.â€
“See, here we go again,†responded Edgerton, “I’m there following Martin
Luther King’s dream.†What dream is that? Edgerton says it’s the one where
the son of a slave-owner could sit down with the son of a slave.

The Tribune contacted Gilmour to get his reaction to Edgerton’s response.
Gilmour said that Edgerton was not marching with the parade, but standing on
the side and, “It just felt as if he was there in defiance.†In the CNS article Gilmour
said that Edgerton was “a pathetic soul who’s searching for love and has found it with
white supremacists.â€

Edgerton responded to Gilmour’s statement by saying that he had found love
among the white supremacists and that Gilmour was the “pathetic soul.â€
Edgerton went on to say, “Monroe Gilmour speaks like he’s a black man. What
is Monroe Gilmour? Mr. Gilmour is a liar and I have no respect for him. I
don’t expect a man like that to know anything about history. Gilmour is the
worst bigot I’ve ever met.â€

“I don’t think there’s any need to respond to that,†said Gilmour when told
of Edgerton’s response. In the CNS story Gilmour also compared Edgerton to a
Holocaust denier who can be presented with evidence of slavery and its brutality

and just dismiss it. Edgerton says that he’s never denied that slavery happened or
that slavery was a bad thing.

“Well, that’s not the impression that he gives a lot of people,†Gilmour
says, “It seems inconsistent.â€

Gilmour further stated in the article that Edgerton has convinced himself
that masters and slaves actually labored together to improve the South.
Edgerton responded that after the Civil War former slave-owners offered freed
slaves pieces of property to work, since Confederate currency was worthless.
“I think he needs to go talk to some real historians,†says Gilmour.

Gilmour stated in the CNS piece that, “It’s our opinion that he is being
used as camouflage for the white separatist and even supremacist use of
folks like [the Southern Legal Resource Center’s] Kirk Lyons.â€
Edgerton responded, “I’m tired of people talking about Kirk Lyons. I’d give
my life for Kirk D. Lyons.†To back up his claim that Lyons is not a racist
he points to Lyons’ taking as clients blacks in Waco, Texas, a black man who
was beaten by police in Hendersonville, and his legal help to the NAACP
while Edgerton was president of the local chapter.

“He (Lyons) has always told me to turn the other cheek; damned if I’m going
to turn the other check,†exclaims Edgerton.

Gilmour was asked by the Tribune about his group, Western North Carolina
Citizens for an End to Institutional Bigotry. Asked who was on the board of
directors, Gilmour replied that there were no board members. Asked how many
members the group had, Gilmour said that it wasn’t a membership
organization. Asked how the group was funded, Gilmour said by private
individuals and small grants

So far, Edgerton has had to defend his beliefs with his blood. He was
attacked by black men on two different occasions. Both attacks occurred here
in his hometown of Asheville, NC.

So he continues to march to raise money to educate folks with the truth, to promote
‘heritage, and not hate,’ and to take the fight to the courts when it becomes necessary.
 
+1 to the unfair grouping of Nazis along with Confederates.

I find it more irritating that they allow beanie baby and cell phone accessory vendors taking up valuable space at the gun show....

Just my two cents...
 
H.K. Edgerton is a man of strong opinions, who is not afraid to speak his
mind. This was the case this week when Edgerton was interviewed about his
October walk from North Carolina to Texas.

Edgerton, the former head of the Asheville branch of the NAACP and for the
last five years a defender of the Confederate flag and other related causes,
plans to leave for Austin, Texas Monday, October 14th by foot. When asked
what he was doing, Edgerton responded with a big smile, “Walkin’ across Dixie.â€


The official title of the project is “March Across Dixie†and,
according to Edgerton’s press release, has three purposes.

First, Edgerton says he wants to expand the awareness of the need to defend
Southern heritage, history and the rightfulness of the Confederate cause
here in the South and across the entire United States. The south had every
legal right to secede and never should have been attacked for wanting to do so.

Second, Edgerton views the walk as part of an educational effort to show
that Southern symbols are part of a proud heritage that should be defended,
not scorned, as many liberal politicians, media and special interests would
have you believe, he says. Southerners have a cultural experience of their own,
and that culture needs to be defended from historical revisionists. The current
‘segregation’ of Southern culture, and particularly the Flag, by the uneducated
liberals is no different from the ‘segregation’ that the blacks faced earlier.

Third, he plans to raise money and gain support to build a permanent heritage
defense fund to be split between the Southern Legal Resource Center and the
Sons of Confederate Veterans to guarantee “...our heritage and history
survives and prospers despite the current attacks.†“Lying about the south and
re-writing history so the people remain ignorant of what really happened only
continues to separate the races.†Edgerton says he hopes to raise $2 million.

According to Edgerton, the Southern Legal Resource Center, a non-profit law
firm that defends Southern heritage cases such as the flying of the
Confederate Flag, currently has 12 cases that are about to go before the US
Supreme court with hundreds of cases being phoned in “...all the time.â€
“I’ve influenced a lot of babies across the south land to stand up,â€
explains Edgerton, “Now they’re being sent home from school or forced to
remove their Cross of St. Andrew (the original name of what’s now known as
the Confederate Flag).†They’re calling on legal help from the center and
Edgerton wants to help raise money for their defense.

The 1,300 mile walk is a tall order for the 55-year-old man. He’ll be
carrying a Confederate flag the whole way. Edgerton plans to take the
journey 21 miles a day, six days a week. He plans to attend a local church
on Sundays, give speeches and “kiss a lot of babies.†He thinks the journey
will take about four months to complete.

Edgerton considers his crusade a “fight for civil rights†and says, “I’ve
fought for civil rights all my life and it doesn’t get any worse than this.
It’s high time to have education for black and white folks about Southern
history.â€

Edgerton’s knowledge of the Civil War era differs greatly from what the usual
textbooks, which he calls northern propaganda, teach.

Edgerton instructs that secession was an act provided for in the U.S.
Constitution. No state had ever agreed to enter into a perpetual Union when
it ratified the Constitution, and the South was not the first to discuss the idea.
According to Edgerton, the New England states talked about secession during
the War of 1812, and in 1814 the New England Federalists even held a secession
convention in Connecticut.


Here are a few other insights Edgerton presented about the Civil War:

“Blacks fought for the South.â€

“Lincoln fought the South to keep all the Southern tax money.â€

“Southern generals have been made out to be traitors when they were very
honorable men.â€

“Blacks could certainly walk around the south, but not around Lincoln’s
Illinois.â€

“America will never ever be great until the truth (about the Civil War) is
told.â€

“The only thing Lincoln did was to pit black and white against each otherâ€

"The Constitution is what started the Civil War - taxes and states’ rights -
not slavery.â€

“Many blacks were free and they even owned slaves.†(This was documented in
an Asheville Tribune article about the 1800s Sulfur Spring Resort in West
Asheville.)

“Most white folks didn’t even own slaves.â€
“The first legalized slave was owned by a black man.â€

According to Edgerton, the greatest Union desertion rates occurred just after
Lincoln announced his Emancipation Proclamation. Edgerton asserted, “Union
Soldiers said they didn’t get into to this war to save the *******.â€

He believes the United States did a great disservice to the South after the
war. Edgerton points out, “We (the United States) rebuilt Germany and Japan
(after World War II), but we never rebuilt the south land. We need a
Marshall plan for the South and we need it now.†“If you want to understand

today’s race problems, you have to understand what went on during the
‘reconstruction.’ Anyone who knows nothing of that era is simply ignorant.â€
Edgerton has his own ideas about reparations too.

“The idea of reparations (for slavery) is a joke. It’s a way to drive a
wedge between blacks and whites. The only hope they (the blacks) have is to
hold their white southern brothers’ hand and join in calling for Southern
reparations,†explains Edgerton.
“My ultimate goal is to seek reparations for all Southerners.†Edgerton is not
just talking about money either, but the South’s history that Edgerton says
has been rewritten by the victors - the North.

Edgerton talked about some of his exploits and told of when he was standing
on a bridge in Alabama with his Confederate Flag. He said a black woman
stopped, jumped out of a car, hugged his neck and told him that she could
now bring her grandfather’s uniform down out of the attic. It was a
Confederate uniform.

He notes that when his zeal was put to work in the black community, he was
called “a radical, loose cannon,†yet when he turned his attention to
defending his Southern heritage he is called a “lackey and Uncle Tom.â€
“It’s ridiculous that a Nazi, Ku Klux Klan skinhead would use the Cross of
St. Andrew to try and intimidate anyone. That’s my flag,†states Edgerton.

Edgerton says that in the Southern heritage circles he’s been affiliated
with, “I’ve not run into one person who believes slavery was a good thing.â€
When it comes to defending Southern Hertiage, Edgerton admits “Southerners
always will try to accommodate people because we are kind-hearted, but we’ve
backed up too far,†he says.

Edgerton, who says he’s been made a member of the “White Trash Society,â€
says with a laugh, “It’s hard to be a white man 'cause we’re guilty of
everything bad that happened.â€

One of Edgerton’s detractors, Monroe Gilmour, who was named as a

Coordinator with the Western North Carolina Citizens for an End to Institutional
Bigotry, recently made comments about Edgerton in a national CNSNews.
com story.

Edgerton was asked to respond to Gilmour’s statement that when Edgerton
attended the Martin Luther King peace march with his Confederate flag that
“It feels as if he is there in defiance of what we’re doing.â€
“See, here we go again,†responded Edgerton, “I’m there following Martin
Luther King’s dream.†What dream is that? Edgerton says it’s the one where
the son of a slave-owner could sit down with the son of a slave.

The Tribune contacted Gilmour to get his reaction to Edgerton’s response.
Gilmour said that Edgerton was not marching with the parade, but standing on
the side and, “It just felt as if he was there in defiance.†In the CNS article Gilmour
said that Edgerton was “a pathetic soul who’s searching for love and has found it with
white supremacists.â€

Edgerton responded to Gilmour’s statement by saying that he had found love
among the white supremacists and that Gilmour was the “pathetic soul.â€
Edgerton went on to say, “Monroe Gilmour speaks like he’s a black man. What
is Monroe Gilmour? Mr. Gilmour is a liar and I have no respect for him. I
don’t expect a man like that to know anything about history. Gilmour is the
worst bigot I’ve ever met.â€

“I don’t think there’s any need to respond to that,†said Gilmour when told
of Edgerton’s response. In the CNS story Gilmour also compared Edgerton to a
Holocaust denier who can be presented with evidence of slavery and its brutality

and just dismiss it. Edgerton says that he’s never denied that slavery happened or
that slavery was a bad thing.

“Well, that’s not the impression that he gives a lot of people,†Gilmour
says, “It seems inconsistent.â€

Gilmour further stated in the article that Edgerton has convinced himself
that masters and slaves actually labored together to improve the South.
Edgerton responded that after the Civil War former slave-owners offered freed
slaves pieces of property to work, since Confederate currency was worthless.
“I think he needs to go talk to some real historians,†says Gilmour.

Gilmour stated in the CNS piece that, “It’s our opinion that he is being
used as camouflage for the white separatist and even supremacist use of
folks like [the Southern Legal Resource Center’s] Kirk Lyons.â€
Edgerton responded, “I’m tired of people talking about Kirk Lyons. I’d give
my life for Kirk D. Lyons.†To back up his claim that Lyons is not a racist
he points to Lyons’ taking as clients blacks in Waco, Texas, a black man who
was beaten by police in Hendersonville, and his legal help to the NAACP
while Edgerton was president of the local chapter.

“He (Lyons) has always told me to turn the other cheek; damned if I’m going
to turn the other check,†exclaims Edgerton.

Gilmour was asked by the Tribune about his group, Western North Carolina
Citizens for an End to Institutional Bigotry. Asked who was on the board of
directors, Gilmour replied that there were no board members. Asked how many
members the group had, Gilmour said that it wasn’t a membership
organization. Asked how the group was funded, Gilmour said by private
individuals and small grants

So far, Edgerton has had to defend his beliefs with his blood. He was
attacked by black men on two different occasions. Both attacks occurred here
in his hometown of Asheville, NC.

So he continues to march to raise money to educate folks with the truth, to promote
‘heritage, and not hate,’ and to take the fight to the courts when it becomes necessary.


:rolleyes:
 
I have three items of Nazi/German war souveniers, A dagger, a luger and a iron cross, all returned from the War by an uncle. I see items like this as history and legitimate War booty.

I can understand the guy who sells WWII artifacts as just that artifacts.. I can not understand repro's or new production as i find the Nazi concept so reprehensible as to make my stomach turn at the concept. Same with Confederate or Japanese War relics.

I make sure the guys who sell the new stuff understand that i had an uncle, my moms first husband and my wifes extended family killed by the SOB Nazi war. I tell them that just because the Constitution allows them to have such views, does not mean they should excercise those rights. And i make sure the operator of the show understands my position.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top