I've got two Springfield 1911 A1 "Loaded" models (see below) and I can honestly say they have been great guns for the money. Other folks may have had issues with their particular Springers.
My OD Green/Black Springer has been an absolute gem from the get go. I have used it in all of my shooting qualifications and I can't get the darn thing ta choke on any ammo I throw through it. It has been exceptionally dependable and remains my favorite sidearm for non-concealed use. The Stainless model Springer was a bit of a "problem child" in the beginning. She was built in Springfield Armory's Imbel plant and had a scored breech face and the ambi slide safety was touching (barely) the slide. I bought her knowing she had these issues and even managed to get a decent price reduction on the purchase.
I notified Springfield Armory of the issues and sent the girl off for repairs. In less than ten days, they had her all fixed up and shipped back to me postage paid. It cost me not one red cent for all this. On that point alone, Springfield will get my support. Their customer support is excellent.
The Stainless is as accurate and dependable as my other 1911 A1 "Loaded". I most often use her to test out new loads or as a sidearm for practice drills, but I have used her as a carry in the winter.
Now, all that bein' said, me EDC is...
I bought the Commander with the specific intent of concealed carry. It is a fairly heavy sidearm bein' all steel, but once I got the Crossbreed Supertuck holster and a dedicated carry belt the Colt just doesn't feel like it's there anymore. The secret to good carry is in the holster and the belt.
My vote goes to the Springfield as a first 1911 as it will give you a good reasonably priced firearm that you can go to the range with or carry. Later, you can always pick up another 1911 (and believe me you will want many more) like the Colt. Whatever you get, if you decide to carry,
invest in a good belt and holster.
Do not go cheap on these. Good luck, nephew!