And a revolver that shoots 45 LC & .410ga wouldn't be good home defense Why?
My response was excessive, in hindsight I misread the sentence, and attributed the word "only" as applying to "only a Taurus Judge"...or something like that...but obviously you were saying "for home defense only - a Taurus Judge...".
Which is not unreasonable.
I personally couldn't choose such a firearm for defense, nor would I probably recommend one to anybody, but I wouldn't tell you that it's a bad choice, if you decide upon it.