Variety - the spice of life?
They say variety is the spice of life. I'd like to add that it can also reinforce one's appreciation of what he has - namely, my 39A Mounties.
I recently acquired a Ruger 10/22 compact - Laminated stock, 16" barrel. Nice little carbine. Shoots pretty well with its preferred ammo - Federal Champion, 40 gr LRN. I'm not an auto-loading enthusiast by any stretch but I will admit that these are fun little rifles.
After a few days of getting familiar with the Ruger I decided to do a little side by side comparison with my Marlin 39A Mountie.
Ergonomics: The Ruger is youth sized so using the factory sights comfortably is a bit of a challenge. The Mountie is better proportioned to an adult. Operation of the Safety and magazine release on the Ruger is easy and intuitive. Less intuitive is the Bolt Lock, it required me to actually to read the manual to understand how to operate it.
Firing: One thing about auto-loaders is that once a shot is fired there is another ready to go right behind it. With the Levergun I can fire a shot and then manually lever one in once I am ready. I found that I needed to consciously slow myself down to get good groups with the 10-22. A little pause and a few breaths relaxes and sharpens the eyes and keeps the Heart Rate down. In the past I've not found I can hit targets any faster with the auto-loaders, though I can miss them faster. A few years back I had a little competition with a young man and his 10-22 vs me and my Mountie and we easily put down the reactive targets ahead of him and with fewer shots even though my rate of fire was slower paced. In terms of practical accuracy the lever is plenty fast to keep up with the sight picture.
Using the 10-22's preferred ammo I was able to exceed the performance of the Ruger using the inexpensive Federal Bulk ammo with my Marlin 39A, and do it consistently. I suspect that the diminutive size, heavier trigger and familiarty played a part in that. Still, the Marlin impressed me and reinforced my appreciation for this fine firearm platform more than 110 years old. Here is a picture of a few of the Ruger's best 10 yard groups with its preferred ammo. With other ammo these groups grow to 1/2" or bigger.
Marlin Mountie 10 yard Group with Federal Bulk, Sitting, unrested with open sights
Other notes: The Ruger weighs in at 4 lb. 9 oz. vs. the Marlin at 5 lb. 14 oz. The 20" barrelled Marlin gets over 70 fps faster out of the Federal Bulk ammo, 25+ fps more out of the Federal Champion ammo and the CCI Mini Mags.
Synopsis: I like the Ruger and it is a fun carbine to play with. I wouldn't trade or give up a 39A to own one but it did renew my appreciation for my 39's.
-Mo
http://myfavoritemarlin.blogspot.com/