What do you think about a Presa Canario for a home defense dog?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Lots of good suggestions here on picking the right dog for your living situation/lifestyle, training, and lots of good breed alternatives to Presas.
Everybody has an attachment to their own breed(s).
Personally, my next dog, and I prefer big dawgs, will come from the pound.
It may take more than one trip, but I know I'll find a 'good' one there. I know of several cases where people have found pure-bred dogs there, a St. Bernard, several Rotties, and Dobies, and even a Great Pyrenes (sp?).
The best trained and most protective dog I currently know is an American Bulldog/Pitt cross, he nailed a car burglar and held him on the ground til the daughter of the house could call 911 and during the 11 minute wait for LEO. When said BG was cuffed and raised off the ground there was a big wet spot on the front of his pants:D . I just wish I could talk his owners into giving him to me.
Folks will also post notices in Vet's offices for free dogs, so that's another resource.
And as stated above, PLEASE have your dog spayed/neutered, we destroy too many unwanted animals already. Please don't let your dog breed irresponsibly.
Mods, thanks for keeping this thread open. I think dogs figure largely in strategies and tactics as a good, protective dog can be your back-up or give you time to get to your weapon.
 
Is there anything inherently wrong with the breed? No, not at all. But I would caution strongly against using one as a guard dog unless you're really big. I have a lot of experience with European line GSD guard and police dogs from the kennel at the Cosmo Compound, and it's tought me one big thing. Never have a dog you can't carry and hold down. Some dogs are well trained enough and calm enough they won't put up a struggle for minor repair work. But there are times when even a well trained dog will be out of control. The classic case is male vs. male fighting. They can't help it, it's primal. YOu have to be able to haul a biting, angry dog out by the tail and pick it up by the scruff. Not too many men, even strong men, can do this with a dog the size of the one you're talking about. A 90 lb. or 100 lb. GSD is as much as I can manage, esp. when he's fighting and kicking.

Besides, the size isn't needed. The best guard dogs I've ever been around are FEMALE GSD's from good European lines. No bigger than 70 lbs at most. The females are smarter and more alert than the males, and believe me they can get the job done if needed. They are FAST, really fast. And their jaws are more than strong enough to kill or injure a grown man as needed. Thanks to their size they can leap, and they hit faster than you can swing a stick. There is no bluffing, growling or posturing. There's just the blur, the fangs, the screams and the blood. That's why I love them so. T:D
 
Igor has it right about gunshy dogs. It's 90% inheritance. And to make it harder, it's not always something you can tell with pups. Most young pups, if healthy and alert, WILL run away from gunfire back to mom or into their den. It's not necessarily a bad sign at all. They are pups, after all. They are *supposed* to be afraid of potential dangers.

Some dogs are going to be worked up, some aren't. Whatever you do don't reinforce any fear by comforting the dog. But they're all different. One of our females is not only not afraid of guns, she CHASES THE FRICKING BULLETS! I'm not making that up. She can hear them snapping through the air and runs out to see where they went! I have to keep her locked up when I shoot.
 
Never have a dog you can't carry and hold down.
When she grows up, I'm in trouble. I'll BARELY outweigh her if she reaches the upper end of the breeds weight range.

At least I did get a female, so I shouldn't have to worry about dog fights too much. I'm trying to socialize her alot too.

I am kind of getting worried that she might not make a good guard dog. She has associated the front door with friends coming over and anytime it sounds like someone might be coming up the front porch, she gets VERY excited with the tail wagging and all. I catch her all the time sitting at the top of the stairs just staring down to the front door.
 
A Puma can be effective. Also, cheetahs are quite receptive to teaching, I've heard. ;)
But as for canines, the ones you mentioned are good watchdogs that I've heard.
 
Although I have never owned a Presa I know a few guys that have. I have owned a few Neapolitan Mastiffs (Mastino Napolitano) over the years and they have some similarities in temperment and personality. They are a lot of dog to handle. The Mastinos that I have owned would guard a rock if they thought it belonged to me. My first Mastino was a female that weighed abot 135, not particularly big for the breed. However, she was a throwback. She was actually quite sweet and even tempered unless she believed that either my wife or I were being threatened. I have always spent a lot of time obedience training my dogs and she was no exception. When she was about a year old the trainer I was working with asked if I had ever considered doing any bite work with her. I told him that I had not and really did not think it was necessary in her case. He suggested we do some temperment tests to check out her potential. At the end of one of our obedience sessions my wife and I stood with the dog, Sheba, sitting between us. A young handler in training put on a soft sleeve. A soft sleeve does not have any hard reinforcement and is usually used in beginning bite work to encourage the dog to really bear down. The trainer explained that we should not expect much as, according to him, most dogs don't usually do much on their first go round. The handler walked up with the sleeve on and a crop tucked under his arm. He shook my hand and my wife's hand and talked pleasantly, Sheba wagged her tail and had a big happy grin. The handler turned and walked away about 12 feet then whirled around and with crop raised and yelling rushed straight at us. I was totally unprepared when Sheba went airborne. She turned into a snarling demon . The handler stuck out the sleeve and Sheba bit very deep and very hard. The response was so hard and so fast that the leash was yanked out of my hand. Sheba shook the handler like a rag doll and proceeded to drag him around the room while he screamed incoherently. I was able to grab the leash and get her off, she had not been trained on the out command and it was pretty hard. The poor guys arm was swollen and purple. So as I said earlier these type of dogs are a lot to handle. My wife and owned a couple of these monsters and loved then dearly. However, we do not have children and we had to constantly be alert and cautious. At the time we lived in a boderline bad neighborhood and I could walk the streets day or night, but she always had to be on a leash. If someone with children came over I would put her up. She could not be crated as she did not like it and destroyed every crate I ever tried. Seriously, I tried at least 3 different types of crates that were "guaranteed" and I got my money back on each one because she destroyed them. One time my wife got a speeding ticket and the dog smashed the side window trying to get the police officer. Luckily she was also tied into the car. From her perspective my wife was being threatened. I do not want to paint a negative picture as Sheba was a great dog, but she required a lot of work and patience and I would not recommend the breed for most people. Presas are very similar dogs. Perhaps not quite as aggressive or headstrong, but a lot to handle. I would also add that I agree with Cosmoline about European line GSD's. I have a good friend that imports them and competes in Shutzhund and ring sports. A 70 lb. female GSD with drive is a sight to behold and unlike Presas and Mastinos can be trained and is very stable. Just my .02.
 
Had a bunch of dogs (all pure breds until the current one) of all the bad-??? breeds of the old type. A Skipperke and a Bouvier make a good team! But every pure bred large breed I've had had a tragic flaw of a genetic nature. The current Ridge back/mastiff mix I've got was on the way to the pound when he started to outgrow the apt the lady had him in as a puppy. He looks exactly like the one posted in the picture with less ridge and a bigger head. He was casrrated a little early and was goofy until he hit 3years. Now at 4 he is the best ranch guard I've had, bar none. He is VERY sweet with children, but knocks over toddlers with his tail. I am not Schutzhund training him, been there and done that. Just basic obdience and OUT when he attacks is all he needed, my guns do the rest of the talking. Genetically much better unit IMHO.:)
 
Another point--*genuine* guard dogs, the kind which take no prisoners, are very hard to come by. Most dogs of all sizes will back off when faced with a determined foe. Even among the European-line GSD's I've been around, there are some who would back down in a fight. They look *great* on the schutzhund field, and they're happy dogs, but I would not trust my life with them.

The dogs I would choose are all females with a certain attitude. They are fiercely loyal to one or two people, and trust nobody else. They will never bite their "pack." But they WILL bite strangers and they must be crated if company comes over. Most Americans are not willing to do this. They want their dogs to be friendly with everyone and never bite. Well got news for you, this desire produces dogs which SUCK at genuine SHTF protection work. Even the giant Presas suffer from this breeding.

The more I'm around dogs, the less I want my dogs to be stand-ins for children or "members of the family," who will love everybody who comes into the house. I want my dog to hate and distrust everybody but me and my core group of friends, and to love me without condition. This attitude is closer to the way guard dogs were 100 years ago when the GSD breed was invented. Only very rare dogs with exceptional bloodlines still have these traits, though, and most people simply are not prepared to cope with them.
 
I have a 110 pound male Cane Corso. Highly socialized, obedience and PP trained. Take his with me when ever I can. He gets along great with other dogs unless they show dominence. He loves all kids and people, and on walks he just stops in front of other people so they will pet him. However, he is a fierce guardian of the home and yard. He can sense my feelings, and just seems to know the good from the bad.

Now my wife has a 5 pound female Yorkie. SHe is a great little watch dog, does not like strangers or kids, and keeps my Corso in his place. She rules.

As far as the San Francisco Presa maulings, those dogs were not pure bred, but mixed. A well bread and trained Presa will make a great companion.
 
We have a boxer/Pit mix named bruno, he is almost 12 now. A friend of ours gave him to us, as he would not stay in a pen. We live out of town so this isn't a problem. He looks really intimidating, until he "smiles" at you, He would seriously need dentures to bite anything. Our 5 year old rides him around the yard. He loves everybody, but most people hearing "PIT" mix are really leery of him, until he walks up and trys to hug them. He is the laziest, most laid back dog iv'e ever seen. As far as a watch dog, I honestly think that he barks if a mouse walks by an farts. Barks at anything and everything except when someone shows up .

Our other dog OTOH is a totally different story, she is friendly if she knows you, but if not she barks, growls and the hair on her back and neck automatically stands on end. She is a Mutt thruogh and through, lab, bordercollie, chow, possibly heeler, and ridgeback mix. She is definitely odd looking, most dogs don't have amber colored eyes. And if someone pulls into the driveway, you bet she lets us know that someone is there. She meets them at the vehicle. She is great with kids though, sometimes a little hyper but great nonethelss.


If I could get my husband convinced, our next dog would be a bloodhound or a mastiff.
 
I would give a serious look to American Bulldogs. My wife and I got a one from a rescue recently and we couldnt be happier. While willfull and in need of a firm hand a good training, they are generaly sweet dogs and not likely to eat you pets or relatives. At the same time they are very defensive of their packs when the need be. Mine regularly wakes me up when things are not as they should be (mostly teenagers running through my front yard at 2am).

Here is a link to more info: http://www.dogbreedinfo.com/americanbulldog.htm

Here is a of picture of mine:

odin-hello.jpg


Loch
 
Another BIG vote for the S. African BoerBoel...they are the closest of family i could have ever hoped for with perfect temperments. AND devastating in the role which they were meant!...seriously. Not for everyone BUT worth every moment of effort, must say :). long Life expectancies...high heat tolerance...overall DAMM good heath. Enjoy the babies almost 500lbs of luvin...

Loandr.
 
Last edited:
The Presa Canarios that killed Diane Whipple in San Francisco were mis-bred by all accounts. Bane was lame and Hera was only kept as a breeding bitch. However, when two large mastiffs decide to attack it would take a very large and strong handler to hold them back.

Prior to being kept in the apartment by the lawyer couple, Noel and Knoller, they were kept on a farm. While there they consistently escaped and killed all the livestock. Atypical for a livestock guarding breed. The owners were breeding them for profit, pure and simple.

There are only two breeds of dog that were bred expressly for defensive work against humans. The Bullmastiff and the Doberman Pinscher. The Bullmastiff was bred to work with English foresters protecting game. They were trained to NOT bite, as a bite from a dog this large and powerful could break bones. Dobermans were bred to protect German tax collectors.

Get whatever sort of dog suits you. Train it well, keep it in the house instead of chained in the yard and treat it well and it will reward you with loyalty that legends are written about. Some breeds that can be surprisingly capable are Weimareiners, Standard Poodles, Standard Schnauzers, Boxers, and any true terrier. I like mutts, but get a dog you will bond with instead of whatever is popular at the moment.
 
I have a 110 pound lab. Good with kids and company, great early warning system for bear, nice deep window rattling growl for strangers. Never hurt anyone . . . . and I trust him with my back.
 
Hardware said:
Get whatever sort of dog suits you. Train it well, keep it in the house instead of chained in the yard and treat it well and it will reward you with loyalty that legends are written about. Some breeds that can be surprisingly capable are Weimareiners, Standard Poodles, Standard Schnauzers, Boxers, and any true terrier. I like mutts, but get a dog you will bond with instead of whatever is popular at the moment.
We have a winner! Actually, two winners: dog and man.
 
I've never been afraid of dogs

I worked at a private animal shelter and had the big dogs, I've been bitten few times. I take care of my friends really big rotties from time to time...the only dog that ever frightened me was a presa canario.
I had a glock on me at the time, 40 caliber and a 15 round mag, a big knife
and two extra mags and pepper spray....I felt like I would need a 45/70 if that dog had gotten riled...it was like a bear...only scarier
 
Get your BoerBoels young (approx. 8 wks) raise them by hand, treat them as family (granted, not an EZ task) And the rest will WORK itself out. Trust me :) And yes lots of fenced acerage is a big plus

Loandr.
 
Last edited:
If you want home defense get ADT - wrong reason to get a dog.

If you want home defense get ADT - wrong reason to get a dog. Oleg has a cute poster on the topic as well.

If you want a Presa Canario do the research, have the space, make the committment to spend the time and effort, don't try to find the cheapest one out there, then get one. Be sure you really really want one - think about the way Juan Rico was rejected for K9 in Starship Troopers. I have known people who had trouble sleeping with a big dog active in the bedroom.

Myself I've worked with a Boxer, nice temperment adequate size and strength and not as bright as I'd want.

Next dog was a very well bred German Shepherd, great animal with ample size and strength (once you get past taking a duckpin ball sized knuckle bone in the jaws chewed and swallowed in a chomp seems to me anything more is overkill?), and incredibly bright (did I say expensive?). Good hips and long lived but ended up retired with arthritis.

Most impressive dog I've ever seen or heard about personally was a German Shepherd K9 who was a real symbiot with her handler - over 300 individual commands for voice, hand or whistle. Smaller than my dog but maybe a lot quicker. Start putting them together and most every situation was handled. Notice that's not a pet that's a lifestyle.

ADT does fine for home defense and actually helps with insurance.
 
Clark, I couldn't have said it better. I think of a dog as more of an early warning radar.
 
We shooters spend a lot of time and energy telling folks that a gun is an inanimate object that doesn't get up and shoot people all by itself.
This is exactly the point to consider when getting a dog. A dog is not inanimate, it thinks and acts for itself. This is the weapon that will get up off the nightstand and "shoot" someone all by it's lonesome.

I spent 6 years handling dogs for the military, some of them old style sentry dogs, that were considered lethal force as opposed to the newer trained patrol dogs that are considered less than lethal. If you know how to train and handle dogs as well as you can handle a firearm, consider a big agressive dog. Most folks do not have that ability. I do and won't have one. My rifles, shotguns and pistols are under perfect control. When I chose my 8 K9 pals, I stuck with early warning mode.
You make your own choice, but when your weapon gets up and "shoots" someone of it's own volition, you accept the responsibility.

Sam
 
We decided on a Brazilian Mastiff or Fila Brasileiro several years ago, and waited until we had an adequate place to raise a puppy before we got one. To us that meant five acres in the country, double fenced and gated. We also joined the breed association, learned everything we could about the breed, attended "working weekend" meetings where adult dogs were put through their paces so we could see what we were getting into. After getting the puppy and raising her, we are grateful to have her with us. But it really IS a lifestyle, not a pet. We've done the socialization, we continue with the training always to reinforce what we've taught. We make certain sacrifices because we have the dog we chose. It's part of the deal.

Anyone who decides to get a member of one of the few breeds left which are genuinely protective needs to know what they are getting into. We KNOW we have a 'loaded dog,' and we don't ever forget it nor do we take for granted that no matter how well we think she is trained, the time may come when SHE decides that someone is a threat. We have seen these dogs in action and we know what we have. These dogs aren't for every family or every situation by any means. But we are glad to have ours.

lpl/nc

http://www.thefbca.com/
http://workingweekend.southlandfarms.com/
http://www.aphelionart.com/filaindex.html
http://www.eanlo.com/index.htm
 
Sounds like a LIABILITY not worth taking on

Buying a dog with a known "killer" reputation is just plain bad news in my opinion. Particularly if this is your first dog. Me, I just cruise the pound until I find a dog I like. Every dog I have owned has taken a tough stance when things went bump in the night. Usually I wake up to the raccoons passing through the yard.

However, I feel it's more important for the dog to bring it to my attention, not just handle it on his own. I did have a dog capable of handling it on her own, and she thwarted a returning prowler when I let her out the back door and she pursued him. She came back in about 10 minutes, the prowler moved on to a different neighborhood.

And later in life, I woke to her diving for the window at some dark shadow prying at the window screen. He never returned either, but man were those teeth white and bright in the pitch dark.

Purchasing a dog with a known bad rep is just plain dumb in my opinion, it puts you at a big disadvantage should it ever nip someone, or even bark at your neighbors with that loud deep woof. And apparently, these dogs are known to turn on their owners. You have to be a very on top of it as an owner in this case. I do not put that much effort into my dogs personally. I love them, no doubt, but I'm at a point in my life that a "killer" dog would just be a hassle and frowned upon in my community. And I would frown upon one also because it's usually the dirtbags in my area that I see the "tough" breeds with. And dirtbags are not know for properly training their pets in my opinion. They concentrate on making them mean, and that is bad for everyone.

If you buy dog with this reputation and it becomes a problem by nipping a kid that is tugging at his ears, you will likely have to destroy the dog for it. Whether the dog deserves it or not, the law is always on the side of the abusive kid that instigated the dog, not the dog that got fed up and finally threw down a "that's enough" nip.

I would not buy one of these, but I would get a pitbull. I had a lab-mixed one once, great family dog, good temperment, loads of companionship. She also woke me at every raccoon or squirrel invasion.

jeepmor
 
jeepmor,

"Buying a dog with a known "killer" reputation is just plain bad news in my opinion."
========================================
Take a look at the costumed "killers" here- http://www.aphelionart.com/fco.html . From the top: Elsie The Cow, The Great Pumpkin, Elton John, The Cowardly Lion, Mardi Gras. Filas are an old breed that came into being several hundred years ago in Brazil from a combination of mastiff, bloodhound and others. Their historical uses were as cattle herders, farm guard dogs, trackers, hunting dogs for jaguar, etc. 'Filar' in Portuguese means 'to hold.' Filas are legendary in Brazil and in circles in other countries where thay are known, where the byword for them is 'Faithful as a Fila.'

"And apparently, these dogs are known to turn on their owners."
===============================================
Not at all. A properly bred Fila will tolerate ANYTHING from its people, to include having food literally taken out of its mouth. Filas have been bred for centuries to be stable with their owners and responsible breeders today will instantly put down a dog that shows any degree of instability. Yes, some Fila _crosses_ have been known to be dangerously unstable, that's why anyone who knows anything at all about them strongly discourages crossing Filas with other breeds. Filas are loveable goofballs at home, as companionable a breed as I have ever seen. They don't want their people to be out of their sight. Filas don't lie at your feet, they lie ON your feet.

"I do not put that much effort into my dogs personally."
==========================================
We do.

We WANTED a dog that does what Filas do. Filas a born with an innate distrust of strangers, that being anyone they don't pretty much live with. They are protective of their people and their place. Filas have to be socialized, as does any dog, and they have to be obedience trained. But they DO NOT have to be trained to be protective- that is instinctive with the breed. It's not necessary to do 'attack dog training' with a Fila. Depending on the dog's individual temperament, which is mostly based on its breeding, a Fila is going to be protective to the point of being willing to bite an aggressor by the time it's about a year old. Some pups start earlier, and a few much earlier. Some never develop or display proper temperament, they may be fear biters but they are not protective, and some few are in fact outright cowards. These Filas should not be bred. The breed standard calls for Filas to pass a temperament test if they are to hold a championship title. Filas are not trained for a temperament test except for the normal socialization, obedience training and exposure to the wide wide world that any Fila owner who wants to have a well rounded dog will provide.

A temperament test (TT) is a judged affair, which presents the dog with a number of stages that range from passing close by a group of disinterested strangers, to encountering odd noises made by people nearby (marbles or pebbles rattled inn a plastic bottle is a favorite, as is someone shaking out their newspaper), to walking on uncertain footing (bubble wrap sheets, tarps, sheet metal, etc) to unexpected intrusions in its space (often a spring loaded umbrella), to gunshots (starter pistol), to a genuine agitator in a bite suit who makes threatening moves toward the dog (restrained for this stage on a steel cable) and its person. You can see some TT pictures at http://www.aphelionart.com/ftt.html . Very rarely do people do bitework with Filas in the traditional sense- it just isn't necessary (and, it's hard to get trainers who want to repeat the experience). Owners DO want to know their dogs' temperament, so they are tested in both basic TT and 'High In Trial' (HIT) events. HIT is sort of like IPSC or IDPA for dogs, presenting them with scenarios far beyond the basic TT like multiple agitators, even more uncertain footing, distractions an order of magnitude larger than the basic TT etc. Pictures from the HIT at last year's FBCA Nationals in Charlotte, NC are at http://www.aphelionart.com/fit.html . Note that what is happening in the pictures is not training- it is testing.

"...I'm at a point in my life that a "killer" dog would just be a hassle and frowned upon in my community."
=================================================
I hope I've adequately addressed the 'killer dog' language already.

I'm old and tired and retired, but my wife still works- so I am home most of the time. We both spend lots of time with our dogs (we have a Brittany too). Ours is the only Fila in the area we know of, she was the first one in our vet's practice and he has been in business for a long time. No one we've encountered locally knows what kind of dog she is, but lots of people think she is really pretty (for some folks Fila looks are an acquired taste, admittedly).

Granted we live in an extraordinary place ( http://www.armedpolitesociety.com/viewtopic.php?id=2438 ) but it is a place where thieves and outlaws are refered to as 'rogues' and are apt to get shot at, a place where people genuinely like working dogs, hunting dogs etc. For example, the white-truck delivery man (as opposed to the brown truck delivery man) came up to the (locked) gate a few weeks ago. Both dogs were in the yard, the first time they had been outside when he made a delivery. The Brittany (all 35 pounds of her) was barking her head off, reared up on the gate. The Fila was shadowing me and not saying much, just a WOOF! once in a while.

There's a hard-to-miss Beware Of The Dog sign on our gate (and others around the fence, combined with Posted No Trespassing signs) at our attorney's advice.

Mr. White Truck passed my my package over the gate, indicated the Fila with a motion of his chin (physical gestures are very low profile around here, you should SEE the road repair crews directing traffic with waving fingers held waist high) and asked, "That the dog the sign is for?" as he was leaning on said sign.

Yup, I said.

She bite?, he asked.

I'd bet on it, I replied.

He looked her over for a long moment, nodded approval, and said GOOD DOG- to her, not me. Then he wished me a good afternoon and went on his way.

"...the law is always on the side of the abusive kid that instigated the dog..."
=========================================================
The only kids around our dogs belong to our next door neighbors (our only neighbors, about 300- 400 yards away). They have been around the dogs since both were puppies. The neighbor's little girl (who just turned seven) is one of our Fila's people, just as if she were family. The child has always spent a lot of time here. She always calls before she comes over- the 8000 volts in the electric fences (theirs and ours) discourage casual visits from anyone (or it has so far anyway). That kid could do anything she wanted to the Fila and not get hurt, and she knows not to bring anyone else here the dog doesn't know. NO ONE the Fila doesn't know quite well comes around her here in our home or on our property while the dog is out of her kennel- we wouldn't let that happen because we know it might go badly if that stranger made what the dog interpreted as a wrong move toward one of us. Yes, it does require attention on our part, but it's worth the tradeoff. By the same token, there's a loaded pistol in my pocket as I type this, and a loaded shotgun around the corner behind the bedroom door. Those require the same level of responsibility and attention on our part as the dog does as far as I see it, I didn't call her a 'loaded dog' earlier for nothing. We pay attention to who's around when the dog is out of the house, because most of the time we are out with her. That's how she wants it anyway, Filas generally don't stray too far away from their people- it isn't in their nature.


By the way, I am not trying to 'sell' the breed to anyone, this definitely is a breed that needs a lot of forethought and dedication on the part of owners, and they are not for everybody. But a lot of people have the wrong impression about various breeds (note that I'm not picking on you for saying you'd like to have a pit). Too much of the wrong sort of attitudes show up all too often in breed specific legislation (BSL) aimed at certain breeds because of misinformation or misunderstanding. I don't want to see that sort of thing happen to Filas, because I don't ever want to be without one or more Filas for as long as I can handle them. Read what responsible breeders say about the breed, read the breed standard and you can better understand these remarkable dogs.

Regards,

lpl/nc (proudly owned by a Fila and a Brittany)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top