Five Centerfire Cartridges for the Rest of Your Life

Status
Not open for further replies.

marksman13

Member
Joined
Oct 3, 2006
Messages
3,464
Location
Mississippi
I’ve got extra time on my hand during my Coronacation, so I’ve had time to think about the rifle cartridges that I like the most. I’ve decided I could live with about five chamberings and be able to do anything that I want to do. I honestly would have some consternation about having to narrow the list to less than five and those five do not include 22LR. I own rifles in several different chamberings because I like variety, but if I had to downsize tomorrow the following five rounds are the ones that would stay in the stable.

1. 223 / 5.56 - Mostly because my defensive rifles are set up in this chambering. Secondly, I’ve got a good sized pile of ammo.

2. 6.8 SPC - I realize I may be the only person whom has this round in their Top 5, but I’ve killed a lot of pigs and deer with this round and I have the rifle set up EXACTLY the way I want it. For a handy rig set up to kill pigs at night, I don’t think it gets any better than my 6.8 and my results in the field have been great. Gotta keep that round in the stable.

3. 6.5 Creedmoor. I’ve got a couple rifles chambered in 6.5 CM and one of them is my favorite rifle. It does most anything I want to do out on the range and in the woods and fields that I hunt. Great all around cartridge for the southeast region that I call home. Ammo, and good ammo, is available every where.

4. 257 Weatherby Magnum. Another outlier here I’m sure, but I love the Ruger No 1 I have chambered in 257 WM. Extremely flat shooting, easy on the shoulder and absolutely flattens deer. With a 185 yard zero I can hold dead on a deer out past 300 yards with the Hornady Precision Hunter 110 gr load. Yes, it burns barrels. Yes, it’s loud. Yes, it’s expensive to shoot. No, it’s not going anywhere.

5. 300 Win Mag. This one is probably the toughest for me. I always said I’d never own a rifle chambered in a hard kicking, obnoxious round like the 300 WM. Then, I found myself wanting to shoot pigs further and further out in the bean fields. I bought a Bergara Ridgeback in 300 WM, topped it with a Zeiss Conquest V4 6-24x50 and bought several types of ammo to try. I stopped after I shot the first box of Federal Non-Typical 180 gr soft points. This rifle shoots the absolute snot out of this ammo.

That’s my five. What’s yours? We’ve had a bunch of contentious conversations about cartridges lately. I thought it would be fun just to see what everybody likes without a bunch of bickering back and forth. I think it’s good to see how varied our taste in cartridges can be without trying to convince each other that one is better than another. I’m looking forward to seeing who else has an oddball in their top five and why. Might just find a new favorite.
 
I could do five,
1- 223 for the dreaded defensive rifle
2- 45-70 for thumping anything within 100 yards
3-30-06 or 308 for shooting things a bit further out
4-50 bmg for bigger things further away
5- 30-30 because I needed a #5, I guess I could use an elephant gun - 416 ruger? But elephants are not common in illinois, either are grizzly or water buffalo.
 
.223 for all basic utilitarian purposes
6 creed for more advanced utilitarian purposes
6.5 leopard cuz I has to haves one
.270wsm only in my Benelli r1 configuration otherwise scratch it out
7stw cuz that 162 eld is pretty way out there
If the r1 is nixed, .375 Ruger cuz the world beckons.
This cannot also include handgun cartridges but I could live with 5 rifle cartridges if needed.
 
223 and x39 for plinking.

270 for deer and elk hunting (the 223 could handle varmints as well).

45 ACP for autos. I just like my 45s more than my 9s. I have a BHP I'd miss, but my Glocks and Taurus 92 leave me cold.

357 for revolvers. Would also consider 38 Spl, but if I'm limited to 5 calibers forever and ever, might as well add a magnum to complement the 45.
 
Last edited:
Thinking about it, I've got a lot of overlap.

.223/5.56 Hunting, TGT, SD
.260 REM, mostly due to the M7 platform, could easily swap for a 6.5C, but this is my in the blind deer rifle, also is my idea of a good woods rifle.
.270 Win, my primary deer rifle, set up for open country.
.300 Win Mag, anything larger than deer, although I have killed a couple deer with it.
.45-90, just cause someday I will get back into BPCR matches and the .45-90 isn't ridiculous for silhouette, but it shines out to 1000 for the buff matches and long range.
 
Last edited:
I thought I could reduce my cartridge count 13-14yrs ago. I liquidated my collection (realized I’m not a collector and sold off a few hundred guns), and I was dead set on simplifying my life with only significantly less firearms and less chamberings. It held out for about a year.

Admittedly, I do lament the situation my wife and I are in - we have used many firearms for many purposes, so there’s a bit of confusion if we are asked our favorite, or asked which one means the most to us. I hate selling a firearm I have hunted with, but keeping a hundred different firearms which have all been used to hunt only one or two animals out of sentimentality is kind of a burden. I’ve made two additional attempts to simplify my life and commit to using ONE bolt action with 3 barrels and ONE AR with 3 uppers, but neither stuck.

I also feel as if the world has passed me by when I consider this type of question, as my default logic-path starts considering various classes of huntable game. But most shooters are not hunters in the modern world, so I’m not so sure such thinking is apt. There are a great number of shooting sports, and each has their niche firearms and cartridges. But I’m a hunter, fortunate enough to travel out of state and out of country often enough to have need for various chamberings to pursue various game - and I simply have not seen sufficient advantage to subscribe to a “one rifle to hunt the entire world” paradigm.

I also consider my varied taste in firearms. Specialty pistols, revolvers, shotguns, rimfires, semiauto rifles, leveractions, and bolt actions - that’s already 7 unique classes of firearms, let alone starting to whittle that down to only 5 chamberings among them. I’m hard pressed to say I could live on 5 centerfire rifle cartridges, certainly not only on 5 total cartridges.

Personally, I shoot far more than I hunt, but I hunt a lot.

My minimum list then becomes:

22LR Pistol
9mm Pistol
44magnum revolver
475 Linebaugh revolver
22LR Specialty Pistol
6.5 Creed Specialty Pistol
300WSM Specialty Pistol
410 shotgun
12ga shotgun (2-3 of these)
22LR Rifle (at least 3 of these)
223rem Rifle (End up with at least 4)
6mm ARC AR
6mm Creed Rifle (probably 3 of these, light, heavy, and AR)
300 PRC rifle
416 Rigby rifle (hard pick for me vs. a 458 Lott)
45-70 levergun

So that’s 14 cartridges. Each sufficiently different within their firearm class that I can’t say they are redundant. Those would keep me well served for everything I’m currently doing with firearms. Would have to add a 44mag levergun if I went back to cowboy action shooting, but with that list, I could hunt anything I’ve ever hunted or wanted to hunt, compete in a lot of different shooting sports, defend myself, home, family, and livestock, and simply enjoy shooting for the sake of it.
 
.308
.308
.308
.308
.308
I am old school and extremely comfortable with this caliber - this would be enough for me in any situation.
I’ve got a buddy whom has hunted all over the US and Africa and he shares your sentiment other than for hunting the absolute biggest, meanest creatures in Africa.
 
Thinking about it, I've got a lot of overlap.

.22LR, TGT, small game gun as I kill probably 20 times more squirrels than I do deer. I'm kind of surprised when I see that guys don't list the .22LR
.223/5.56 Hunting, TGT, SD
.260 REM, mostly due to the M7 platform, could easily swap for a 6.5C, but this is my in the blind deer rifle, also is my idea of a good woods rifle.
.270 Win, my primary deer rifle, set up for open country.
.300 Win Mag, anything larger than deer, although I have killed a couple deer with it.
I went centerfire only with this post mainly because I feel like 22LR is a given. Lol
 
308/7.62x51.
223/5.56. I think this one is on everyones top 5.
8mm Mauser. I have several great shooters in this caliber, and loads of brass and bullets.
30/06. Another no brainer for everyones top 5
7.62x39. This one..is my toss up. Which do I grab in a SHTF scenario? M1A or the trusty AK?
 
I thought we were doing rifle calibers only.
My revised list to include all:
1- 454 casull, mild to wild and can do all a pistol needs to, except conceal
2-45-70 - thumper
3-45 acp
4- 357 mag
5-223

---honorable mention for the 380 acp, little and easy to carry.

I could survive with just those 5, who needs long range anyway?
 
Since it's in the rifle discussions section, I'll limit my 5 to primarily rifle cartridges in centerfire only.
.22 Hornet
.22-250
.25-06
.308
.450BM (or .45-70, either way)
 
I thought we were doing rifle calibers only.
My revised list to include all:
1- 454 casull, mild to wild and can do all a pistol needs to, except conceal
2-45-70 - thumper
3-45 acp
4- 357 mag
5-223

---honorable mention for the 380 acp, little and easy to carry.

I could survive with just those 5, who needs long range anyway?
Yeah. I intended it to be rifle only, but didn’t put that in the title.
 
.222 rem

6.5 Grendel

6.5 Creedmoor

6.5-06

.35 Remington* (lever action)

everything that isn’t the .35 Remington I want in a bolt action rifle!

those for me cover it
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top