I did not evaluate the cleaning properties of these products for the following reasons.
1. I was unable to formulate a credible and objective design of experiments to evaluate (with equity) the cleaning properties of each product that covered lead, copper, carbon, gun powder, black powder, primer residue, shotshell wad residue fouling.
2. A large segment of the products in this evaluation did not claim to be cleaners (i.e. 3 in One oil, paste wax, motor oil, Silicone and several others)
3. I was not particularly interested in the cleaning properties of these products because my interests were not entirely gun-centric and had equal interest in archery/bowhunting, tools, knife making, other outdoor gear that don’t require the rigor of a gun cleaner.
4. I am a Hoppe’s No. 9 solvent fan for gun cleaning because I am pleased with how it performs and more importantly because the glorious perfume takes me back to so much past enjoyment and prior hunts and my dad. Would it be wrong to say that I will on occasion crack open a bottle just to smell it???
5. Ive never struggled to clean a weapon because I strip them down to the last pin and if need be use acetone to rid the surface or any and all contaminants so I didn’t deem it a problem I needed to find a solution for (pun intended)