Parents Say I am Not Welcome Thanksgiving Because I have Guns.. What To Do??

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's a mental thing...
I'm sure your state has a list of places you can not carry: schools, bars, gov't buildings, airport, etc. In your mind, just add "Mom & Dad's house" to that list. It's really as simple as that. Much to be gained...but, in reality, little lost. Pick your battles wisely.
 
...

reply #1 and 2 nailed it already.

Their house, their rules - and they will be gone too soon.



One mods sig says - be an enthusiast instead of an ideologue.
 
Last edited:
Just bring a baseball-bat and a glove :evil:
and carry it around at all times.
 
Seems like a pretty plain choice you've got to make. Which do you want more: to be armed and prepared to defend yourself, or to see your parents?

Your dad says he and your mom aren't comfortable having a gun in the house. You say you aren't comfortable not having a gun with you. It appears you've reached an impass.

There are some situations where compromise simply isn't possible; either you'll have a gun and your parents won't be happy, or you won't and you'll be unhappy and putting yourself at greater risk than is necessary. In addition, a gun is much safer from theft when it is strapped to its owner rather than locked in a car.

Whether you decide to go or not, do not attempt to go armed and hide it from them. Whether they find out or not, to violate your parents express wishes and attempt to conceal it from them is the very worst kind of disrespect.
 
Their house, their rules.
Your safety, your rules.

They have the right to forbid guns in their house.
They have NO right to compel your presence.

Your visiting them constitutes a hardship. They've got no business imposing conditions on a HARDSHIP.

Don't show up once and they'll probably change their minds.
 
Mom has been gone 25 years but we lost Dad just this last summer. I will miss Dad at Thanksgiving when the rest of us are together laughing and remembering.

My wife has a strained relationship with her parents, someday I imagine there with be regrets over that.
 
It's funny how people get caught up with having some kind of blind loyalty to people who accidentally share genetic material with them. That whole "you, as the child, owe your parents for raising you" shtick is bushwah.

Why get twisted up about respecting them when they apparently have little respect for you? You're a grown up person. You may be their "child" for life, but as their treatment of you evolved as you got older, why does it stop because you are an adult now with your own life and beliefs?

I suggest you spend your free time with those who love you without a price tag attached.

I sincerely understand your situation and I hope you'll find the answer that suits you the best.
 
Your post doesn't give any indication of which State this will take place in. Here in South Carolina a CWP holder must ask permission to enter anyone's home while armed. Failure to do so is a misdemeanor. So depending on that State's laws, you might not have a choice.

Will you be consuming alcohol? Another factor that may come into play depending on that State's laws.

Overall this seems to me to be more of an authority issue. If that is the case and you feel belittled then don't go. Or go to their town, stay in a hotel and disarm while in their house then leave. I don't see that approach as any worse than disarming while going into a No-Carry zone.

And the next time they come visit you, make them sleep in the "gun room". :evil:
 
My take is pretty simple. Their home and their rules. I don't personally know you or your parents, however, if it were me I would go to dinner and enjoy time with your parents. Leave the gun in the car or wherever, like the garage which was offered. I guess unless your parents reside where you have fears of being attacked there is no need to have a gun during Thanksgiving Dinner. Once cooked a turkey dinner presents no viable threat.

Principals are just fine but setting them aside for your parents wishes makes you a better person. To my thinking this is not that big of a deal or issue. Certainly not worth a divide or rife.

I am likely about close to your parents age with children your age. Very, very important to me is maintaining a good relationship with my children. Sometimes this means sacrifice on their part and sometimes on my part. They call it compromise.

Just My Take
Ron
 
Their house. Their rules. Leave your pistol in your car. If they insist on making an issue of the fact that you own guns, well, I am not trying to be an SOB when I say this, but a man's got to stand on his own two feet. Explain to them that whenever they want to open civilized communications with you, they'll have your number. Then walk away.

My mother is an anti-gun, liberal hippy type who forbade me from owning guns or even being around them, to the point that she would not let me go to Boy Scout camp if there were going to be any guns, and not go to Scout summer camp unless the Scoutmaster promised I wouldn't be allowed to shoot at the rifle range. She also filled me up with a lot of pap about how one should not only turn the other cheek when faced with violence, but that it was morally and intellectually superior to let my self be beaten to a pulp than to raise a hand against another human being. That made me a lot of fun on the schoolyard, let me tell you- I got beaten up regularly because I would never fight back.

Suffice it to say that has all been finally purged from my system some time ago. There's a difference between instigating violence and protecting oneself.

I learned to shoot from Scouts, so I guess she was right about the Boy Scouts corrupting me with guns. I bought my first gun the day I turned 21 and had to keep it at my Dad's apartment because Mom wouldn't let it in the house, and threw a hissyfit when I told her what I'd bought that day. Strained things around the house let me tell you. I never kept guns in the house while I lived there to respect her rules, but I didn't live there much after that.

I still hear from her every now and then. It's a shame that my kids don't know their grandma very well, but she brought it on herself.
 
Last edited:
You invite them over and you cook for them.

Find another relative who is pro-gun or just neutral on the whole matter and have Thanksgiving there...

Take them out somewhere nice for Thanksgiving, this way they don't have to cook and you can carry (if the establishment/state laws allow it).

Go over their house, honor their wishes and enjoy their company.
 
You are an adult and you can deal with the consequences of your decisions, but understand "their home, their rules" applies to anything whether it is carrying a gun or drinking or race or ethnic attitudes or bringing others over. There's nothing of "gun control" in it because gun control is about government applying rules to everyone's lives everywhere all the time. Simply put, it is their rules within those walls.

If you have truly serious issues with your family you need to address those and move forward. If they're truly awful people, fire them. If this is a petty power struggle then don't bet the rest of your relationship with them on it.
 
Last edited:
If you're working 12 or 13 hours a day trying to keep a small business afloat and this issue is getting you so upset, here's what you need to do.

Lock up the front door of the business and post a sign saying "Closed for the Holiday, be back tomorrow."

Either leave the gun at home or be prepared to lock it up in the car when you get to their house.

Enjoy their company, the conversation, the dinner and most of all...UNWIND A LITTLE BIT! :D
 
I understand your dilemma. It's "their house their rules" posts leaves out one important aspect - respect for you. I had many disagreements with my father and didn't want to be around him - so I moved 2800 miles away so I didn't have to deal with him as part of my life - and don't regret the choice.

I visited with my parents every week by phone and for 25 years, never spent a Thanksgiving or Christmas with them - that's the family arrangement we came to. If you can't get along with them and you're miserable the entire time you're there - what's the point of being there?

I like the ideas of inviting them over for Thanksgiving or meeting them at a restaurant. I don't think you should force yourself into a situation that you find uncomforable - that's not fun. Your parents also have to realize that their choices come with consequences - not just your choices.

If you can rationalize a compromise fine, if not just accept that you have principles to live by the you have to feel comfortable with. Wish them a happy Thanksgiving, call them and have a nice conversation - worked for me for 25 years.
 
If they had a phobia against spiders and snakes would you insist on bringing your pet tarantula and python into the house with you? After all, it's your right to have animals as property.

They know your feelings about guns, you know theirs. They aren't going to change. Up to you whether you think it's worth it to spend time with them before they're gone.

I live 6 hours away from my parents, usually saw them 4 or 5 times a year. Ten years ago my 69 year old father died totally unexpectedly one morning of a brain aneurysm while walking on his farm with my brother. He was gone within minutes. I own several hundred guns, everything from pristine 1st generation Colts to C3 MP5's, and I would destroy every one of them in a second to be able to see him again.
 
Principals are just fine but setting them aside for your parents wishes makes you a better person.

No it doesn't. It makes you a person with weak principles.
 
Last edited:
Make a deal. Tell them you'll leave your gun in the trunk if they'll leave their liberal propaganda in the toilet. This way there will be nothing to talk about and you can focus on the food--just like Thanksgiving was meant to be.
 
I been watching this thread for a couple hours. I have an opinion that both parties are having control issues and this issue is just the focus not the cause.
It is easier to talk about things, rather than feelings and the underlying emotions. Either way the solution is in talking, compromise, respect and love, not arguing.
Then again i have been known to be wrong.
 
Leave it in the car. Avoid discussions of politics. Tell them you love them. Enjoy your visit. When finished, put gun back in holster when in the car. Life is too short and it's hard for parents to realize their kids can think for themselves.
 
Life is too short and it's hard for parents to realize their kids can think for themselves.

Buckling under to hoplophobia just puts a bandaid over paranoia and mistrust.
 
So "fighting hoplophobia" is more important than your family?

YGBSM.

For the OP: it has been hit several times here all ready -- ditch the pistol for the short amount of time you are with your family and go visit them for the holidays.

If you are that wrapped up with a tool (your CCW) that it is overshadowing your relationship with your own flesh and blood, then your priorities are WAY out of whack.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top